4 ms·
>The labour market is tightening – and it's getting harder to find a job. as a small rant, I am getting tired of the whiplash between "it's harder than ever to
by johnnyanmac 3y ago
>The labour market is tightening – and it's getting harder to find a job.
as a small rant, I am getting tired of the whiplash between "it's harder than ever to find a job" and "the economy has recovered and unemployement is record lows". This is normally easily explainable but these seem to both be bipartisan points from my browsing on the topic. So I am simply perplexed.
-------
On topic: Ghost jobs are such a weird concept in this day and age. As we see here, it is extremely easy to get hundreds, thousands of resumes within days of a job posting, so why pretend to keep resumes on record to call people on later? The latest I've been contacted about such a role was some 5 months later, and that was due to a referral randomly pinging the company for a tangential job. Otherwise, anything that hasn't responded within a month may as well be cast to the void.
The most common lip service seems to be what you expect:
>Half the respondents reported they keep job listings open indefinitely because they "always open to new people". More than one in three respondents said they kept the listings active to build a pool of applicants in case of turnover – not because a role needs to be filled in a timely manner.
Exactly my point. But maybe it's just me. Has anyone ever had a >1 month response from a company that has experienced turnover?
> More than 40% of hiring managers said they list jobs they aren't actively trying to fill to give the impression that the company is growing. A similar share said the job listings are made to motivate employees, while 34% said the jobs are posted to placate overworked staff who may be hoping for additional help to be brought on.
Well, these seem to be the more brutally honest answers. Fraud is probably too strong a word, but this does feel like exploitive behavior that should be reigned in.
- dan-robertson 3y agoRegarding the start of the topic, just note the world is not homogeneous. For example the US economy/job market is in a better state than the uk one; there are seasonal fluctuations in demand for work that keep statistics always changing; some jobs may be more in demand than others (eg low-skill wages were going up in the US while big tech companies did layoffs). And the news story is so often on the complaining side (eg that there are no jobs or that there are no workers) where I think it can be easy to not notice that the direction changed.
- ghaff 3y agoIt's also simultaneously possible to have low unemployment numbers and have companies be pretty deliberate about new hires and have people tending to stay where they are. And, anecdotally, I see mostly pretty senior people leaving--maybe retiring a bit early. Was just having a conversation about this with a friend of mine.
- tracker1 3y agoIt can also really vary a lot based on job type. Software development is a pretty small niche in terms of total US jobs, doesn't mean that a lot of devs are currently looking. Most of the jobs I've been applying to have hundreds of applicants. It's been rough to say the least. Since January, I've had a couple times where I'm in the final few and an offer at a startup that didn't get the funding they needed. I'm getting relatively anxious and far more open to most things at this point. A 1/3 pay cut is rough, but I need a job.
- downrightmike 3y ago> More than 40% of hiring managers said they list jobs they aren't actively trying to fill to give the impression that the company is growing. Sounds like securities fraud
- myth_drannon 3y agoOnly if it's publicly traded company. 20ish people startup, anything goes.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yieldcrv 3y ago> 20ish people startup, anything goes. its up to the person involved in a securities transaction to bring the lawsuit, or snitch nice bounties for this by the way, doesn't rely on the presence of shares, or being publicly traded. bonds, options, warrants, just as good employees and contractors and outside personnel can snitch too, just make sure the amounts are worthwhile. if you use a lawyer the US government allows anonymity for this programme
- Keegs 3y ago> I am getting tired of the whiplash between "it's harder than ever to find a job" and "the economy has recovered and unemployement is record lows". This is normally easily explainable I’m curious. How can these be true at once?
- jfoster 3y agoOne sector booms whilst another busts.
- underlipton 3y agoI think it's orthogonal to sector. Wealthy and established workers are doing REALLY well, everyone else is struggling.
- jyunwai 3y agoThe bank J.P. Morgan recently published an analysis about employment in the US [1] (this is the best source I could initially find with no paywalls and a non-superficial, sector-by-sector look at the data). According to the report: * "The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported that the U.S. economy added 275,000 jobs in February." However, "unemployment rose to 3.9% in February, the highest rate since January 2022." In January 2024, the overall employment rate was 3.7%. * "A spike in construction, retail and food services jobs contributed to the surprising gain in employment in February." * "Payroll gains in February were distributed across many areas of the economy. Health care, leisure and hospitality and government led the way, contributing to almost three quarters of the job gains." This matches with the anecdotes that I've been hearing from day-to-day conversation: certain sectors such as health care and the service industry are short on people, whereas openings are far fewer in other sectors such as technology. However, I couldn't find employment data specific to the tech sector in this brief report. [1] https://www.jpmorgan.com/insights/outlook/economic-outlook/jobs-report-february-2024 https://www.jpmorgan.com/insights/outlook/economic-outlook/j...
- mvdtnz 3y agoTried to hire a plumber or concrete placer lately? Prepare to be ghosted or given a "fuck off" quote. However, place a listing for "web developer wanted" and you'll drown in applicants. It turns out that when fields close to technology and media tighten up, the techno-media bubble lose their minds about it. Not so much when the labourer market dries up.
- UncleOxidant 3y ago> as a small rant, I am getting tired of the whiplash between "it's harder than ever to find a job" and "the economy has recovered and unemployement is record lows". If you're in tech (as most of us are here) it can be pretty tough to find a job right now unless you have mad AI skillz. But in other sectors it's generally pretty easy to find a job right now. So both can be true depending on what sector you're in.
- bigthymer 3y agoI just watched an investor talk about any field that is effected by changing yields (interest rates) is getting crushed but others are doing fine. Tech was probably the most sensitive field but I think construction and banks are also effected. Construction is complicated because data centers are doing fine while multi-family and commercial are screwed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- johnnyanmac 3y agoI wish that was true, but I was also going around to staffing offices the past few months looking for any temp work to make ends meet and almost all of the dozen staffing agencies said that roles were sparce right now. So if nothing else it seems like it's not tech exclusive. It's weird because I am still at least getting recruiter calls, but I'm simply being cut very early in the process more often, so I don't necessarily want anything too long term This is in Los Angeles by the way. I hear California in particular has higher unemployment than average, so maybe it's a local issue.