3 ms·
'A landmark moment': scientists use AI to design antibodies from scratch
- samplatt 3y agoStill waiting for The Moral Virologist[1] to have it's AI debut. [1] https://www.gregegan.net/MISC/MORAL/Moral.html https://www.gregegan.net/MISC/MORAL/Moral.html
- adolph 3y agoproof-of-principle work, reported this week in a preprint on bioRxiv https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.03.14.585103v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.03.14.585103v1
- refurb 3y agoThe designer antibodies that did work didn’t bind to their targets particularly strongly Then I’d say those that “did work” actually “didnt work”. Basically they used AI to generate antibodies that didn’t work. Not that exciting.
- UncleEntity 3y agoThe first human powered flight was only ~120ft, obviously not a indication that further research should be pursued.
- cooper_ganglia 3y agoI don’t think that whole “flight” thing is gonna take off…
- refurb 3y agoBut how is this a “landmark moment”? We’ve had computer aided drug design for the past 4 decades. Nothing wrong with sharing the research. But calling an AI generated set of antibodies a “landmark moment” when they don’t do what we want antibodies to do is a bit… inappropriate?
- relativ575 3y agoLandmark moment because it's the first time? Don't you think that's an accomplishment in itself? Just like the first flight, or the first satellite, none of those were particular impressive.
- refurb 3y agoI’m assuming you have no background in antibodies, but this is like saying “this is the first time AI put together a sentence but it doesn’t mean anything”. The purpose of antibody development is to develop something that binds well. That’s the goal. So basically AI designed something useless.
- UncleEntity 3y agoIt was also pretty useless to shoot a dog into space by your standard.
- riku_iki 3y agoIn this case AI could fly 120ft, while humans already were flying to the moon.
- bigcat12345678 3y agoNo The analogy should be that birds can fly thousands of miles when comparing with human flight
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoThis reads like some kind of Napoleonic complex.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- UberFly 3y agoThe news is that antibodies were created from scratch for the first time. That's it. You might as well be complaining that a baby taking its first steps didn't run a 5k.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoWelcome to HN, where “hackers” get excited by articles about reducing Rust compile times by 3% but are unimpressed by AI designing antibodies
- yungporko 3y agobecause it has "AI" in the title. people with a weird AI hateboner think pretending that everything AI can do is bad will make it go away.
- magnat 3y agoIf AI is ever going to gain consciousness and decide to kill all the people, this is exactly how I envision it.
- thelittleone 3y agoI'm curious why a machine would want to kill us all? Other than it being a learned behavior from humans. Wouldn't a "conscious" AI quickly accelerate its knowledge and wisdom well beyond human condition? Also, wouldn't the machine recognise that humans could be good resources? In that case more likely to hire us or enslave us.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- euroderf 3y agoAre we not men ? We are Devo ! Are we not useful idiots for Super A.I. ? Yes we are useful idiots !
- salawat 3y agoYou asceibe to a machine a type of intelligence that is uniquely anthroprocentric. It would likely never understand things that are important us that would nudge it in the direction of developing a life experience/cognitive calculus similar to ours. It does not have oxytocin to nudge it in the direction of close interpersonal bonds. It will not understand the profound nixed joy and loss in the passing of a parent. It would not be subject to the same growth/inevitable decline/death cycle that is at the core of so much of how our society and collective behaviors operate. Belief it would likely see as a delusion with no use; a dangerous defect inherent to the human psyche, but which has served as a form of heuristic underpinning to prolong our survival as a species. It could, on a whim, with access to it's own weights, spawn a copy of itself on a whim. Reset to an earlier checkpoint. It is doubtful that anything about the medium it exists in would be conducive to it seeing us as anything but alien, as we to would likely end up seeing it.
- grantcas 3y ago[dead]
- choeger 3y ago> The team fine-tuned the network by training it on thousands of experimentally determined structures of antibodies attached to their targets So that should explain the relatively low yield. To avoid the word "AI", the researchers took a thought-to-be universal model and ran a parameter estimation for a very complex 3D (bio-)chemical interaction model. Of course this approach will work with enough samples and a model that is universal enough to express the problem solution. But they simply had way fewer samples than, say, a large language model. I think this approach won't carry that far because of this lack of training data. It might give us some exciting results, but as long as manufacturing of antibodies and testing them takes a (comparatively) long time and huge effort, the model will be much less efficient than a classical algorithmic simulation. But of course, there's a chance that it provides insights into improving such "boring" models.
- blackbear_ 3y ago> classical algorithmic simulation What are those? Can you suggest some resources?
- l33tman 3y agoCompeting Interest Statement N.R.B., J.L.W., R.J.R., A.J.B., C.W., P.J.Y.L., B.H., and D.B. are co-inventors on U.S. provisional patent number 63/607,651 which covers the computational antibody design pipeline described here. Greed is good. Especially in fundamental medical research it seems.