8 ms·
It's official: Europe turns to the Falcon 9 to launch its navigation satellites
- robertlagrant 3y ago> as well as Project Kuiper satellites for its primary commercial customer, Amazon. ESA subsidised by Jeff's hatred of Elon. And millions of taxpayers, of course.
- outlace 3y agoBut Amazon also contracted with SpaceX: https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2023/12/01/amazon-buys-spacex-rocket-launches-for-kuiper-satellite-internet-project.html https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2023/12/01/amazon-buys-spacex-rocke...
- SCM-Enthusiast 3y agoonly after the board sued.
- consumer451 3y agoWhich I found to be an impressive feat of governance in this day and age.
- TMWNN 3y ago>ESA subsidised by Jeff's hatred of Elon. Isn't it ESA subsidizing Jeff's hatred of Elon? I thought Amazon is paying less than market rate so as to keep Arianespace workers busy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bloopernova 3y agoSort of related question: is it possible to get more precise global positioning from a lot more satellites? I was wondering if a swarm of satellites is capable of GPS.
- jvanderbot 3y agoI can only answer from theory, but the geometric dillution of precision decreases with N, the number of independent measurements of satellite signals. In practice, there's a floor to the noise which is a reasonable lower bound on your uncertainty. There's also factors that can't really be overcome from more sats, like multipath effects.
- jcrawfordor 3y agoMore satellites is mostly better. Multi-constellation receivers for example can obtain higher precision by using some combination of different GNSS. There is a minimum error you can practically achieve this way that has a fair amount to do with the wavelength, but it does help. In most cases, though, faster/more reliable fix will probably be a bigger advantage than precision. When you have a partial sky view, more satellites means a better chance of enough satellites falling in that window for a fix.
- zettabomb 3y agoI'm curious, hoe do multi-constellation receivers use them all at once? Are the signals just all the same thing? On some level I know they're just atomic clocks, and the governing equations should work if all of them are synchronized, but I can't help but think that feeding data different constellations in all at once wouldn't produce a good result. Or perhaps you can answer somewhat the opposite question - if the data IS all the same, then why are there multiple constellations and standards? Apart from Beidou, which I believe can actually serve as a radio repeater of some kind, aren't they all doin the same thing?
- jcrawfordor 3y agoThe calculation of a fix from GNSS is actually rather complex and the potential complexity is almost unlimited. The most accurate GNSS fixes are obtained from offline solvers that analyze long-duration (e.g. 24 hour) recordings of the GNSS data streams and use computer models to determine the most likely solution accounting for many types of error. This is all to say that there isn't really one approach to calculating a fix from GNSS, and receivers embedded in devices like phones use pretty simplified methods so that they can run in real-time and with a short time to first fix. Most GNSS are largely similar, though, and there are certainly enough papers describing how to perform fixing across satellites of independent constellations so I'm sure it's been implemented in at least higher-end devices. Still, I suspect inexpensive consumer receivers are probably calculating a fix per constellation and then combining those. Fixing across constellations requires combining ephemera, time base, etc. data that varies between them, but all of these are known with high precision, you just have to pull them together. Since most GNSS are mostly the same, new GNSS constellations are usually launched either to improve coverage in a region, or these days with several global constellations, more often for sovereignty reasons. If you have weapons systems that rely on GNSS, it's better to have your own constellation. GPS for example no longer has a wartime selective availability capability (that would deny use by anyone other than US forces) but it did in the past and, if WW3 broke out, it would probably be implemented again. For much this reason different GNSS constellations tend to operate in different bands (not always, though) so that a country can selectively jam adversarial GNSS systems without affecting their own. GNSS has its origins in the military and is still largely a military capability today, with Galileo being the odd one out that focuses more on commercial applications (Galileo's selective availability capability is used to charge a subscription for higher-precision uses). And some GNSS do have "accessory" capabilities, probably the most prominent being Galileo's two-way search and rescue messaging capability that will compliment COSPAS-SARSAT. But that's always been the way with satellites. For example, the GPS constellation carries detonation sensing equipment for nuclear counter-proliferation. It just saves money to combine payloads. One of the reasons to not put GNSS constellations in separate bands is that it simplifies the construction of multi-constellation receivers. Of course, it also makes it more difficult to selectively jam. Some combination of these interests mean that GPS, GLONASS, and Galileo are very close siblings in the radio spectrum. It gets surprisingly political.
- brynhughes 3y ago[flagged]
- fswd 3y agoThese have to be spy satellites. GPS is just a timing signal, in space. Technology we had 40 years ago. There is no way you need $100M to build this and have special government authorization to collect the debris.
- wkat4242 3y agoUS spy sats cost an order of magnitude more. Like a billion. And you don't spy from 22000km. That's a GNSS orbit. You do that from low earth orbit. It makes no sense being 40x as far away than you need to, needing that much more magnification (if optical) or signal strength (if EM espionage) I'm pretty sure this is just Galileo. Yeah it's just timing but Galileo has high accuracy and does SAR reception too. And it's government so the price goes up :) Also, the EU as an entity does not have a military or espionage agency. If someone does that in Europe it's coming from a country, not the whole EU.
- tialaramex 3y agoRight, Europe's GNSS birds have the same extra carrier as the current US GPS birds, but whereas the US can say "That's for military use" the EU can't because it does not have a military, so it says that's a "Public safety" feature.
- gamepsys 3y ago1. These will be the most accurate GPS satellites available for civilian use. Precision costs money. 2. GPS has huge military implications. These satellites will be leveraged by the military. There are literally military secretes involved in these satellites. 3. The 100M is for the launch, not the satellites. Space X's standard fee is 67M/launch. It seems fair to attribute a lot of the premium to extra security costs around handling military technology.
- actinium226 3y agoThere was another comment about how the $100M is for the rocket and not the satellites, but I'm here to point out that Aerojet Rocketdyne is charging something like $100M to refurbish existing RS-25 engines from the Shuttle era for Artemis, per engine. In case it's not clear, that's not $100M to build the engine, it's already built and tested, it's $100M to "refurbish."
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoDon't we in Europe have our own space rockets?
- tekla 3y agoNo. Ariane 5 is retired, and 6 is still in development. Other launchers are not currently available.
- zettabomb 3y agoIt's a very unfortunate situation. I don't understand why they didn't keep Ariane 5 going until 6 was ready - I've worked in the space industry (in the US) and customers would pay us ungodly amounts of money to not change something even when costs started rising because of old instrumentation, lack of knowledgeable and alive personnel, or our own suppliers going out of business/getting bought out and killing the product line we needed. They'd pay 2-3x the cost of a redesigned product (which would be subject to the same level of testing as the original) just to keep the old one, with the mindset that "it hasn't failed in 50 years so it won't fail now". I mean we're talking about measurements being made with pen plotters because they'd get angry that "something changed" if we sent them a digital plot taken on the same equipment.
- okanat 3y agoWell they put their eggs into one Arianne 6 shaped basket, hoping that it won't delay much. It got delayed by a lot.
- krisoft 3y ago> I don't understand why they didn't keep Ariane 5 going until 6 was ready It is not as if the US had no capability gaps. For a long long while they had to buy seats from Russia to get their astronauts to the ISS. > we're talking about measurements being made with pen plotters because they'd get angry that "something changed" if we sent them a digital plot taken on the same equipment That level of conservativism doesn’t sound entirely healthy to be honest.
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoWhy cant the EU use ISRO rockets?
- murderfs 3y agoBecause they're more expensive and inferior? There's a reason that ISRO's only launches in like the last 5 years are domestic launches, and two launches for a competitor to Starlink that needed an alternative after Russia invaded Ukraine (and ended up launching twice as many satellites with SpaceX regardless).
- huytersd 3y agoWhat the hell are you talking about? In the past five years ISRO has launched 177 satellites for 19 different countries. I remember watching one for Singapore just last week. https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1883677 https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1883677 How is it inferior? It’s the same orbital insertion and they have a near 100% success rate.
- SJetKaran 3y agoI think some of the larger payloads cannot be launched by ISRO at the moment
- murderfs 3y agoThe vast majority of those satellites are basically a joke. They're all tiny cubesats, and the entirety of their commercial space program in that period could probably fit on a single Falcon 9: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_foreign_satellites_launched_by_India#2020s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_foreign_satellites_lau...
- consumer451 3y agoThe cost of launch on most of these projects is not the main cost component. If you spent years and hundreds of millions on the payload, you are willing to pay more to launch on a platform with a very proven track record, like Falcon 9.
- 627467 3y agoWhenever I read anything about rocketry and Europe I'm reminded of this quote: > Let us say we had ten guaranteed launches per year in Europe and we had a rocket which we can use ten times—we would build exactly one rocket per year," he said. "That makes no sense. I cannot tell my teams: 'Goodbye, see you next year!' [0] European "strategic autonomy" in a quote. [0] https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/05/ariane-chief-seems-frustrated-with-spacex-for-driving-down-launch-costs/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/05/ariane-chief-seems-f...
- tekla 3y agoIt's so weird how increasingly irrelevant Europe is becoming on the world stage. How is a single American private compan lapping around all of the EU seemingly effortlessly?
- 627467 3y agoIf your read the article I linked above and countless adjacent ones you'll see a subtext of blaming "unfair State support" (ie. Pentagon/USG) for SpaceX success. Before spaceX, the target was Boeing. Ultimately it is really about being desinterested/unambitious/distracted.
- adastra22 3y ago…says the European state-sponsored rocket company.
- raverbashing 3y agoYeah, but Boeing/ULA is also way behind of SpaceX I've heard this called "boomer engineering" and I couldn't agree more SpaceX has people and procedures with way more flexibility to do stuff (and a lot of unpaid overtime). Which can be good in some cases and bad in others
- soco 3y ago
- carabiner 3y ago[flagged]
- Muromec 3y agoI would rather keep my 2 hour lunch and 3 months of vacation, anyway, thanks
- audunw 3y agoThose kinds of benefits is what allows Europe to attract talent from across the world. I have lost count of the number of times I’ve heard people who have moved here (northern Europe) say that they couldn’t dream of having kids anywhere else. It’s not like Europe is ever going to compete with USA or China when it comes to throwing a ridiculous amount of money at you as long as you work 24/7, 365 days a year. Or would you prefer that Europe entered this game and pushed work conditions to even tougher standards? .. no, so it’s better that Europe tries to compete on other qualities. We might not get the same kind of talent as USA, maybe not the most extremely driven ones, but I still see plenty of very talented people coming here every year. Europe still has many world class industries doing just fine. Most notably these days is Airbus, which seems to have benefited from a lack of relaxed regulations and hard work culture.
- mardifoufs 3y agoThat's probably true at some scale but the immigration numbers don't lie. More Europeans move to the US than the opposite, and more anecdotally, most immigrants in general would rather move to the US or Canada than to Europe. Same for international students. In my home country, Morocco, Europe is basically seen as a step above but still not close to being similar to north america or Australia for example. Youth unemployment, lack of opportunities, much more discrimination and racism than in the US (yes, regardless of what Europeans would like to believe) or Canada...
- briandw 3y agoWho's dreaming now? https://twitter.com/tesla4k/status/1676077165983723520 https://twitter.com/tesla4k/status/1676077165983723520 "SpaceX primarily seems to be selling a dream. $50M launch is a dream. Reusability is a dream. How do you respond to a dream? You let people wake up on their own. They (SpaceX) are not supermen. What they can do, we can do. - Ariane space exec, 2013"
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoand that is why europe is so much poorer than us. we really let people dream big, fail and dream big again here and that is amazing.
- tayo42 3y agoEasy to dream big when you personally have billions of dollars. Normal people in the US aren't dreaming big or able to fail and take risks. If anything Europe has tons of social safety nets for people to make risky choices.
- sgtnoodle 3y agoI have several friends that immigrated from Europe, and they've all made comments about their respective countries that suggest that's not really the case in practice.
- boc 3y agoSounds great in theory, but in practice we observe the opposite. Turns out having an bigger reward for taking a risk is a better motivator than having a softer cushion to land on if you fail...
- TeMPOraL 3y agoYou're both right. Having bigger risk/reward spread leads to more success cases and more broken people who risked everything and failed.
- perihelions 3y agoThe European situation is actually a very close mirror of the American one. Europe lost one option (Soyuz) because of war, retired production of a second option prematurely (Ariane 5), and has development problems delaying a third option (Ariane 6) by multiple years. America's in the same boat: we're phasing out one Russian option (Atlas V, which relies on Russian engines); retired production of a second option (Delta IV); and have a third option years behind schedule (Vulcan). SpaceX is the only outlier in the pattern. Without SpaceX, the US would be in almost the same position as Europe right now. So I'm skeptical about explanations suggesting some deep systemic differences are at work here.
- nyokodo 3y ago> Without SpaceX, the US would be in almost the same position as Europe right now. Yes, without decades of public and private capital and other NASA resources supporting commercial space startups that bred, amongst other highly innovative companies, a world beating launch service and global low-latency satellite constellation the USA would be in the same boat as Europe. That is a big systemic difference! The USA has a much more consistent emphasis on private enterprise backing up state capacity that periodically inject rapid innovation and makes things cheaper even if similar forces to Europe gradually entrench monopolies that slow things down and makes them more expensive.
- snowpid 3y agoso you think there is no private space industry in Europe? Do you work in that field?
- TMWNN 3y agoCompared to the US's SpaceX, Blue Origin, Rocket Lab, Sierra, and others, no, Europe has no private space industry to one order of magnitude. (Spare me the talk about how Arianespace and Airbus are "private".) Rocket Lab could have chosen Australia to move to. It could have moved to Canada, or to an ESA member nation and thus gain access to Kourou. But it chose the US despite the ample existing competition there.