3 ms·
IMO public is generally critical of science unless they get some shiny toys out of it (and the causation is fairly immediate and obvious). And, honestly, can y
by int_19h 3y ago
IMO public is generally critical of science unless they get some shiny toys out of it (and the causation is fairly immediate and obvious).
And, honestly, can you blame them? Nerdy places such as HN have a fascination of fundamental science that is nearly religious in some aspects - not in a sense of dogmaticism, but in a sense that pursuit of abstract knowledge is seen as noble and desirable in and of itself, with any justifications distinctly secondary. But from the perspective of your average person on the street, today, scientists are those people who ask for a lot of money, and use it to build those giant things that run some incomprehensible experiments which occasionally translate to some equally incomprehensible headlines in the news. And that person can think of many ways in which said money could be used to make their lives better instead.
Now, you can reasonably argue that long term, benefits are there regardless, even if they are not obvious, and thus the people actually in charge of allocation resources should disregard such simplistic takes and focus on that long term. But, either way, one cannot be surprised at the discontent.
- Animats 3y ago> IMO public is generally critical of science unless they get some shiny toys out of it (and the causation is fairly immediate and obvious). Someone commented in the Economist a few years back that the last subatomic particle to have commercial applications was the neutron.
- dwaltrip 3y agoEhhh, that's a poor take. The indirect benefits of fundamental research like particle physics are massive. We all know about how the web — which turned out to have a few commercial applications — was invented by Tim Berners-Lee at CERN in order to facilitate better collaboration and data sharing among researchers. There's the advances in high-performance computing and data processing, medical imaging innovations like PET scans, fundamental tech for touchscreens, and so on. And don't get me started on the motivational and inspirational value of science and how it encourages people to pursue engineering and other technical endeavors. Hard to measure, sure, but it's damn important. There's a reason the moon landing was the most watched event in the history of television. It's difficult to overstate these indirect impacts.
- IlliOnato 3y agoReminds me of N. David Mermin's famous saying that perhaps the greatest contribution of String theorists to science was creation of arXiv :-)