3 ms·
> I think there's just a generalized frustration that a cadre of mostly very bright people seem to have largely spun their wheels for 20 years. Otoh: very poss
by RetroTechie 3y ago
> I think there's just a generalized frustration that a cadre of mostly very bright people seem to have largely spun their wheels for 20 years.
Otoh: very possible their work produced spin-offs that were useful in other fields (math advances, thought experiments, practical research tools & equipment, people in other fields having a look at their work from a different angle, etc)
AND having bright people chew on a subject for decades & come up (mostly) empty, is a good hint there's nothing there. 'Unknown' vs. 'we've tried hard & not found much' is a useful result by itself. Think of it as reducing the search space.
- int_19h 3y agoThe problem with this argument is that it's very hard to quantify or even to test in general. And, of course, the obvious next question then is: if they were working on something else, could that have produced a lot more useful spin-offs?