2 ms·
Annecdotal experience: my kid got a concussion last fall (from horsing around in the hotel pool at a hockey tournament; hotel pools are more dangerous than yout
by toast0 3y ago
Annecdotal experience: my kid got a concussion last fall (from horsing around in the hotel pool at a hockey tournament; hotel pools are more dangerous than youth hockey, I think), and the ER didn't give us much useful stuff, but the local DR did have us go through a concussion protocol which was shock that we sent him to school on Monday when he got injured on Saturday, but then try a bit more each day as long as symptoms don't get worse, go back a day if symptoms do get worse.
Avoid activities that have a high risk of head contact. That meant no ice hockey until he was cleared, but he was encouraged to do off ice drills.
Overall it didn't seem too bad. He felt better and was cleared in about 2 weeks, with some lingering behavioral changes for about a month after that. And he didn't feel great with some roller coasters we did at 4 months after.
But obviously, every concussion (or mild traumatic brain injury) is different.
- hinkley 3y agoSecond concussions can be life altering, so we want to be absolutely sure our concussed friends and family are recovered before they do anything energetic.
- toast0 3y agoThe article presents that you might not recover without doing energetic things. But yeah, you've got to be careful ... and judgement and risk taking can be negatively affected, so you've got to be more careful than usual. Activities will be more risky than usual, but doing nothing isn't good either.
- hinkley 3y agoNo, that’s not what the article says. If there is one thing developers can be relied upon to do, it’s this: if there is a Fallacy of the Excluded Middle, they will find it, fall into it, and then set up a household there. Just like the author did. It’s one thing to avoid immediately going back onto a football field, where you might get hit again before you’ve recovered, or to work, which might be cognitively straining. But instead of *nuanced* advice that included downtime or a scaling back of activities, the recommendation became total rest. A 2022 study published in the journal Pediatrics found that children who spent less than two hours a day on screens in the first week after a concussion had worse concussion symptoms after one month than did those who engaged in “moderate” screen time of two to seven hours a day. I don’t think anyone would call screen time energetic, by either the definition you guys are using, nor the one I was thinking, which was, “activities that can lead to injuries” which I’ll admit adds to the confusion. “Not doing energetic things” includes many more options than hiding in your bed sleeping.
- jemmyw 3y agoWouldn't this be an inverse cause and effect? It's not that spending less time using a screen is detrimental, it's that a worse brain injury causes people to need more rest?
- porkbeer 3y agoTfa says this is the exact wrong thing to do.