6 ms·
The question to ask, is not whether we can become as dense as Manhattan or Brooklyn, bur rather, do we want to be more like our Northeastern counterparts? In t
by hkmurakami 15y ago
The question to ask, is not whether we can become as dense as Manhattan or Brooklyn, bur rather, do we want to be more like our Northeastern counterparts?
In the 70's, most of what is now called "Silicon Valley" was farmland. All those shopping centers and apartments named after man-made formations of fruit trees are because, well, there used to be a lot of those trees there a few decades ago.
In four short decades, we have developed the land to the point where, as others here have mentioned, "no more open land" to be easily developed. We are now faced with a choice: do we develop further? If so, to what end, and for whom? What are the costs?
But first we must consider, who is the "we" in my queries above? Whose interests should be considered? The long time residents of the Valley? The young, vibrant, restless newcomers?
Understandably and naturally, there is friction. There is tension. The old timers already have what they need: a comfortable single family home with a family to fill its corridors. Why would they or should they allow others to disturb their peace and comfort that they worked so hard for? They fight to protect the space and luxury they feel entitled to, and arguably are.
The newcomers find it increasingly difficult to not only find such an abode, but to find even a reasonably priced rental until located within a reasonable distance from their offices. Understandably and naturally, they pine for amenities that are well within reach for others their age in other parts of the country. They rightfully feel that they are entitled to what they need: reasonable living arrangements.
Both sides have legitimate arguments. Silicon Valley is a beautiful place, and it would be a shame to turn it into a concrete jungle. But on the other hand, there is an undeniable generation inequality with respect to real estate: real estate prices in Palo Alto only declined by about 15% during the worst times of the financial crisis, and have most likely reached new heights by now. Every year, it becomes more difficult to find affordable housing, particularly near the mega-employers like Google. The year over year increase in rent in Mountain View is in excess of 10%. Only the privileged amongst the youth can afford the slim pickings that are available, as the rent is enough to crush the savings of more modestly salaried engineers.
Who is right? It is more of a generation divide than a class divide. I sympathize and empathize with both sides, being both a young, modestly compensated professional in the tech sector, and also the son of immigrants to Silicon Valley who sacrificed a monstrous portion of their lives to attain the little that they have to show for it. Whichever way the ball rolls, I'm in line for both pain and pleasure.
"We", both the old and the young, are both right to lay claim to what we believe should be rightfully ours. Such a situation does not have a simple, elegant solution. But we can at least start by acknowledging to each other that yes, you are completely justified to want what you want.
- WildUtah 15y agoNobody is going to take their homes away from single-family homeowners on the Peninsula. The proposal is to upgrade zoning around El Camino, the 101, office parks, and downtowns to allow willing sellers to make even bigger gains by selling to higher density developers. Those developers would be allowed to put up Pacific Heights style tasteful, quality higher density (nothing Manhattan-like). Or that's the fantasy proposal. I don't think there are any real proposals to make Peninsula development rational or useful to the people who live there. The local politics is content to choke on its overpriced and aging stagnation until some foreign center captures the magic of Silicon Valley.
- aggie 15y agoRather than filling in the land between 101 and 280, which would turn into LA-esque traffic nightmares, why not expand into the East Bay or farther south of San Jose?
- mukaiji 15y agoThere are housing development underway between south San Jose and Gilroy, but unfortunately, the jobs are not located there. While that may remove some pain off of the real-estate market further North, opening more development south of San Jose won't do much good if all the jobs stay in the Palo Alto / Mountain View/ Sunnyvale/ Santa Clara region.
- aggie 15y agoThat's true. I guess I see the "jobs area" expanding. I'm thinking at some point, companies will pitch it as a job perk alongside the arcade machines and catered meals--"our office is located in south San Jose where your rent will be two thirds of what it would be in Palo Alto!" Not to mention the office rent would be lower. I guess this all depends on what exactly attracts the company to Silicon Valley and how much that attraction is degraded by being on the fringes of the Valley.
- rayiner 15y agoThere are objective ways to measure these things. New York City is the most efficient place in the whole country, with half the per capita energy consumption as the national average. Energy isn't free, and pollution isn't free, and those both argue very strenuously for favoring efficiency over soft fuzzy factors like the ones you mention.