5 ms·
These rules have really nothing to do with AI. They're trying to impose a ban on deceit.
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
These rules have really nothing to do with AI. They're trying to impose a ban on deceit.
- ajross 3y agoThat's like saying speed limit signs have really nothing to do with cars, they're trying to impose a ban on collision velocity. Which is true, but only speciously, as the rule exists only because motor vehicles made it so easy to go fast.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey don't have anything specifically to do with cars. They apply equally to motorcycles, trucks and anything else that could go that fast. Get pulled over in a tank or a hovercraft and try to tell the officer that you can't have been speeding because it isn't a car. Should we like deepfakes any better if they're created by a nation state using pre-AI Hollywood production technology, or "by hand" with Photoshop etc.? If 3D printers get better so that anybody can 3D print masks you can wear to convincingly look like someone else and then record yourself on camera, would you expect a different set of rules for that or are we talking about the same kind of problem?
- ajross 3y agoYou missed the analogy, so I'll spell it out: before we had cars[1], we couldn't go fast on roads, and there were no speed limit signs. Before we had AI, we couldn't deceive people with easy fakes, and so there was no need to regulate it. Now we do, and there is, and YouTube did. Trying to characterize this as not related to AI just isn't adding to the discussion. Clearly it is a response to the emergence of AI fakes. [1] And all the other stuff you list
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoTrying to shovel in "and all of the other stuff" breaks the analogy though. Misinformation isn't new. Image gen is hardly the first time you could create a fictional depiction of something. It's not even the first time you could do it with commonly available tools. It's just the moral panic du jour. YouTube did this because the EU passed a law about it. The EU passed a law about it because of the moral panic, not because the abstract concept of deception was only recently invented. It's like having cars already, and speed limits, and then someone invents an electric car that can accelerate from 0 to 200 MPH in 5 seconds, so the government passes a new law with some arbitrary registration requirements to satisfy Something Must Be Done.
- anigbrowl 3y agoPedantic but, I hope, amusing: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/when-president-ulysses-s-grant-was-arrested-for-speeding-in-a-horse-drawn-carriage-180981916/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/when-president-uly...
- speff 3y agoFrom your comment's tone, it seems like this is supposed to be a bad thing. The only people who would be upset about this are folks who are trying to pass generated content off as real. I'm sorry if I don't have much sympathy for them.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago"You have to tell people if you're lying" isn't a stupid rule because lying is good, it's a stupid rule because liars can lie about lying and proving it was the original problem.
- speff 3y agoThe problem is that there wasn't a rule that could be used to take a misleading video down. Now there is. Finding out a video is maliciously fabricated is a different problem.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> The problem is that there wasn't a rule that could be used to take a misleading video down. Of course there was. The community guidelines have prohibited impersonation and misinformation for years.
- speff 3y agoFrom the report button on a youtube video: Misinformation - Content that is misleading or deceptive with serious risk of egregious harm. That sounds like a quagmire of subjectivity to enforce. You can argue whether generated content was created to mislead or whether it would cause _egregious_ harm. Now there's no more arguing. Is it generated or is it real - and is it marked if generated? I still fail to see the downside here.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoYou're acting like this is a court with a judge. The company makes up subjective rules and then subjectively enforces them. There was never any arguing to begin with, they just ban you if they don't like you, or at random for no apparent reason, and you have no recourse. > Now there's no more arguing. Is it generated or is it real - and is it marked if generated? I still fail to see the downside here. How is this supposed to lead to less arguing? If there was an easy way to tell if something is AI-generated then you wouldn't need the user to tag it. When there isn't, now you have to argue about whether it is or not -- or if it obviously is, whether it then has to be tagged, because it obviously is and they've given that as an exception.
- Gormo 3y agoDeceit usually implies some sort of intent to defraud. I'm not sure using software to generate background music for a video fits that description.
- jachee 3y agoRIAA has entered the chat. "It defrauds us of our hard-earned middle-man cut."
- mock-possum 3y agoRequiring labeling / disclosure is not the same as banning.
- jahewson 3y agoIn this case it is, because labelled deceit is not deceptive.
- ehsankia 3y agoIt's a label, not a ban. Just like sponsored content is not banned, but must be disclosed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dang 3y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39747921 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39747921.