2 ms·
> India's Eastern Fleet is not equipped to defeat a near-peer blockade What near peer is going to blockade the Eastern Indian Ocean? Outside of a couple of re
by alephnerd 3y ago
> India's Eastern Fleet is not equipped to defeat a near-peer blockade
What near peer is going to blockade the Eastern Indian Ocean?
Outside of a couple of relatively minor naval and listening posts, the PLAN doesn't have a significant footprint in the Eastern Indian Ocean.
> A critical input are semiconductors. That said, none of this is novel--which is why onshoring production has been a long-term priority
Agreed, but you don't need leading edge nodes for this use-case, and India has been leveraging Tower Semiconductors fabs in Israel for this use-case for over 20 years at this point.
P.S. How did you use italics? That's actually p cool
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> What near peer is going to blockade the Eastern Indian Ocean? This isn't how one plans for geopolitical risks. Each of the world's limited global and multi-regional blue-water navies (U.S., Russia, China, the U.K. and France) have the unilateral power to shut down India's economy. That's real leverage. > Outside of a couple of relatively minor naval and listening posts, the PLAN doesn't have a significant footprint in the Eastern Indian Ocean Agree. But it's clearly developing its capabilities. Not a coincidence that a ring of naval bases are cropping up around India. > How did you use italics? Put the text between asterisks.
- alephnerd 3y ago> This isn't how one plans for geopolitical risks People love to assume policymakers spend months and years on Grand Strategy, yet in action most of the hypotheticals that come up just don't make sense. It's not some big game of Civ or Risk. > blue-water navies PLAN is not a blue water navy yet and by most standards won't be for the next 7-8 years. > Not a coincidence that a ring of naval bases are cropping up around India Agreed, and it's not like India doesn't have similar bases in the Eastern Indian Ocean or in the SCS as well.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> People love to assume policymakers spend months and years on Grand Strategy, yet in action most of the hypotheticals that come up just don't make sense Whether anyone is acting on or mitigating a risk doesn't change the risk's existance. A good way for a country to lose its sovereignty is to assume its risks won't be capitaised on. > PLAN is not a blue water navy yet and by most standards won't be for the next 7-8 years That's proximate. > it's not like India doesn't have similar bases in the Eastern Indian Ocean or in the SCS as well Bases are an asset. Not immunity. If someone needs to coerce India, threatening or deploying a blockade (ideally, on energy) remains a capital way to do it. Barring building and maintaining one of the largest navies in the world, India's only real remedy to the situation is onshoring production and reducing energy import dependence. (Though, as you say, that's no guarantee it will be done.)