3 ms·
From all the open source contributions, we know Kenneth enough that he's not trolling. Thus I say assume that he misread the Linus discussion and leave it at th
by Smerity 14y ago
From all the open source contributions, we know Kenneth enough that he's not trolling. Thus I say assume that he misread the Linus discussion and leave it at that. He was trying to make a point and picked the wrong example.
The core of his argument is what's important. He has contributed countless open source tools and libraries, many of which are highly coveted. This is the sort of individual the Python community should (and does) treasure. The other day however he released a tool and was then essentially "teased" about the quality and size of the contribution on Twitter.
I think the person doing the teasing realised later this was a mistake as that whole discussion is gone now (from both sides) but I'm sure for a day or two Kenneth was downright depressed. The person doing the prodding is well known and was someone Kenneth respects. Constructive criticism from someone you respect is amazing but non-constructive criticism from that same person is debilitating.
The core concern is that words can hurt and prevent future contributions to OSS, especially if the unkind words are from someone you respect in the open source community.
- kenneth_reitz 14y agoMost of this post was written before the Linus incident, and he was just being used as an example. I removed the stuff about Linus until I can find an accurate example.
- kenneth_reitz 14y agoAlso, you are 100% correct about the context of this post. All is well now though :)
- Smerity 14y agoI'm glad to hear all's well. Your original point is incredibly important and I'm glad you made it. Years ago when I was 13 or so I pointed out a bug in Blender to Ton Roosendaal[1]. My knowledge of C was ... let's just say I could probably cause memory leaks by staring at the code. He not only attempted to hunt down the bug but he made a 13 year old kid feel welcome in the community even though I was of next to no help in hunting down the bug. Although bad interactions can stay with you for a long time, kind encounters like these stay with you too :) [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ton_Roosendaal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ton_Roosendaal