6 ms·
Internet providers have left rural Americans behind. One county is fighting back
- uberman 3y agoAn interesting quote from the article I found personally relevant "adding broadband increases the value of a property by about the same as adding a bedroom". From my personal experience living in a rural community, I would say that is a very conservative estimate.
- solardev 3y agoIs that still the case even with Starlink?
- kortilla 3y agoNot really. Starlink wiped out the value of shitty DSL lines and microwave links to rural spots. It’s not a substitute for fiber though. When my friend was looking at places in the middle of nowhere along the coast of Oregon to move to now that his kids are off to college, Starlink completely changed the calculus so he didn’t have to worry about connectivity at all.
- ghaff 3y agoMy brother recently got decent wired or fiber broadband at his house in rural Maine. But he had Starlink for a while before that and it was a game-changer. You could actually do all the normal Internet things. The prior wired connections got 1Mbps down with a tailwind and the subsequent mobile hotspots had very restrictive data caps and also were still pretty slow.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoCan you share the story about the provider wiring up that rural Maine connectivity?
- ghaff 3y agoI don't know the details. It's not that rural. It's a few miles from Ellsworth (small city) but it's down a private road. They had sorta broadband part-way down the road already. I think it's Verizon they have but am not sure. They were actually happy enough with Starlink but they switched when this became available.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThanks! Always curious to hear more about this topic, trying to get fiber pulled to a property in Old Forge NY that currently is using StarLink (which is fine for now).
- ghaff 3y agoAs far as I know it "just happened." Presumably whatever provider decided that it would be profitable to extend Internet to a group of homes that are decidedly not low income. Maybe they had some requests from homeowners. I'm not even sure why my brother switched. It was presumably cost as they were perfectly happy with Starlink. (Which, as I wrote, I was perfectly happy with as well the times I was up there.) Pre-Starlink, lack of decent Internet options were increasingly an issue with the people along the road. Not that I go up there a lot but I couldn't have worked remotely from up there pre-Starlink.
- uberman 3y agoLove Old Forge! Used to drive through it all the time going to Lake Placid when I was young.
- OfficeChad 3y ago[dead]
- a2tech 3y agoThe rural county I grew up in got tired of empty promises and with cash from the Obama administration has started rolling out fiber county wide. You can get gigabit fiber for a reasonable cost 10 miles from the nearest town and down semi maintained dirt roads. Any place the electrical lines go.
- t3rabytes 3y agoIt works (and is the best option bar-none) until the big few lobby the state to outright ban municipal ISPs as happened in my state (NC). So frustrating.
- uberman 3y agoWhile simultaneously saying broadband is available in your area because one house in the entire census track has it. We challenged the agreement with the town and they told us that we techmically had fiber service but it would cost 50k to activate it since they had to run fiber from their pop. Coupled with informing us that once we did so, our neighbors could then hook up for 49 bucks.
- chimeracoder 3y ago> We challenged the agreement with the town and they told us that we techmically had fiber service but it would cost 50k to activate it since they had to run fiber from their pop. Coupled with informing us that once we did so, our neighbors could then hook up for 49 bucks. If only there were a way to spread that cost equally among the people who would benefit from it, and a legal structure for collecting that payment, representing the interests of the constituent people, and ensuring that the telco held up its end of the arrangement!
- AzzyHN 3y agoIt baffles me that people are in support of that kind of thing. I doubt the majority of voters are, but the fact that anybody would say "yeah we should have our utilities privately managed for profit" is absurd
- zachmu 3y agoWhy are we pretending starlink doesn't exist?
- evanriley 3y agoAre you pretending that Starlinks upfront cost of $599 and $120/mo is affordable for the community that this article is about?
- ghaff 3y ago$120 per month is well within the range of most monthly internet plans. The article doesn't say how much monthly service for this county-driven initiative will cost. Yes, there's an upfront cost (though cable providers typically have a hookup too) but it's not huge in comparison to monthly fees.
- thfuran 3y agoI'd consider paying that much for 10gpbs, but nothing less.
- ghaff 3y agoIf you have better/cheaper options, by all means take them. Many people do not so it's pay that or do without.
- thfuran 3y agoSome people, but I very much doubt most.
- ghaff 3y agoI wrote "many." And, yes, many people do not have good wired Internet access and paying a relatively small premium to get the equivalent of wired broadband access at all is worth it for a great many of those people. No one is asking you to pay if you have better options.
- morphle 3y agoBuilding your own optical fiber ISP, even rural, is not hard if you use the right tech [1], but most use the wrong technologies [2] and are more expensive to get of the ground. I would be thrilled to set one up for you (remotely). You need 1000 customers per employee and starting capital of $100K to be profitable. You use Starlink as backup to your main backbone. [1] https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Merik-Voswinkel/publication/309254511_Fiberhood_Smart_Grid/links/5807410c08ae5ad1881691e3/Fiberhood-Smart-Grid.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Merik-Voswinkel/publica... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXYaAd5ubok&t=173s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXYaAd5ubok&t=173s
- TheRealPomax 3y agoSeems like you missed the part where large ISPs have successfully forced states to ban municipalities from building their own networks. It doesn't matter how hard or easy something is if it's illegal, even if the laws that make it illegal are themselves extremely obvious examples of regulatory corruption.
- ftth_finland 3y agoNot all states. About 20 do, the rest do not.
- mlhpdx 3y agoStates and municipalities don’t need to build it; small community-run organizations (nonprofits or not) can do so in Oregon.
- morphle 3y agoThe world is a lot larger than the US. Why do you assume only municipalities build their own networks?
- TheRealPomax 3y agoBecause the article is specifically about the insanity that is "internet in rural US"?
- ak217 3y agoI think WISP/point-to-point wireless over the last mile, with fiber only in the core town areas, is much more promising than pulling fiber long distances to every rural residence. This technology has come a long way and is super affordable now. That's what the government should be subsidizing. But more importantly, the feds should be preventing local governments from outlawing municipal ISPs (https://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadblocks https://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadbloc...).
- ftth_finland 3y agoWireless tech is a flash in the pan. The gear has to be replaced every few years as it ages out. Contrast that to fiber, you install it once and use it for decades. Government should only be subsidizing permanent infrastructure.
- ak217 3y agoNot my experience, and even if the depreciation is faster, the capex is so much lower that point-to-point wireless still comes out ahead.
- ftth_finland 3y agoIt's not just the capex, but the opex also. Forklift upgrades aren't free. Furthermore new wireless kit like Tarana is expensive.
- mlhpdx 3y agoIn Oregon we have “community” telcos that have been installing high speed internet in rural areas for decades, and continue to do so[1]. The service/tech provided by these companies is far better and cheaper than the national/large ones. This works well enough that I’ve seriously considered starting one to serve the ~100 homes in my areas that are an ignored island in a sea of fiber around us. [1] https://www.telecompetitor.com/blue-mountain-lights-up-fiber-broadband-in-oregon-community/ https://www.telecompetitor.com/blue-mountain-lights-up-fiber...