3 ms·
The News Business Is Cratering
- drewcoo 3y agoGarbage. Trump's second term will "fix" this. Because they're not really selling "news" in the first place . . .
- LordShredda 3y agoLocal news maybe, and that is a shame. International agencies like Reuters, AP News are still alive and do heroic work on the field
- chiefalchemist 3y agoI see it as the opposite. With Reuters, AP and a couple others is there a need for (in the USA): ABC, CNN, Fox, NBC, MSNBC, etc.? Sans their editorial* programming, these are all for the most part regurgitating the same "news" from the same POV, etc. And they're all amplifing their commodcommodity-ness by racing faster and faster to the bottom. Where's the surprise? Why should any of us feel sorry for the Fourth Estate's intentional effort to fail the rest of us? On the other hand, Local is unique and isn't as easily commodified. * Yes, they call their editorial content news, but the rest of us would be wise not to be as confused as they are. Journalism and editoral are two very different desks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- netbioserror 3y agoReuters and AP regurgitate garbage DC government complex propaganda, it’s disinfo at best and power-reinforcing evil at worst. The people who work there are lazy and sycophantic if they can’t be bothered to get up, go somewhere, and expose information that actually pisses powerful people off. This is the reason the narrative positions independent journos on Substack and Twitter as a threat. They’re the only ones left holding power to account and punching up. And the best people in the corporate journalism world inevitably get ejected into the independent sphere with social media as their only outlet.
- arrowsmith 3y agoIsn't this story like 20 years old by now?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoIf Donald Trump wins the Presidency, it will revitalize the news business. There will be tons of fear and outrage for them to monetize.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoWho is 'them' here? Seems like anytime I hear people use 'They', 'Them' as some broad category of some secret organization driving things. It is increasingly hard to decipher what the 'they/them' is referring to? Is it Q-anon? Deep Christian State? 'They' are doing this to 'Us'. But can never really pin it down? Every conspiracy is always shifting to a new 'They'.
- drewcoo 3y ago> Who is 'them' here? If you can't tell, you're not part of the conversation. If you're (much more likely) trying to frame the poster as some kind of conspiracy theorist . . . there's a different STFU for that one.
- blovescoffee 3y agoI feel like in this instance “them” is pretty clearly news agencies
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoYes. Addressed later From other post. Thought on re-reading OP comment, 'them' could just refer to generic 'media', and not be right/left. It shows how even language is getting warped. Frequently right leaning news uses 'They' for every type of boogie man. So if a comment has 'They' it sounds right leaning.
- geraneum 3y agoIt doesn’t really matter. It’s fluid and redefined as needed.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoThere is no conspiratorial “them”. The pronoun just refers to the people in the news business.
- overstay8930 3y agoGood journalism isn't free, and nobody is willing to pay. Especially when I can spend a couple minutes on Google and find very obvious misinformation coming from very large publications. The future is probably what Apple is doing with News+, subscription to access a bunch of news for steady revenue (with ad support), it's pretty clear nobody is gonna subscribe to a generic news service at this point, only niche like finance gets subs, or Substack/blogs if you find a trusted source for certain information.
- jeffbee 3y agoI don't think it's true that "nobody is willing to pay". As the article points out large outfits like The Washington Post, and smaller ones like Politico and Talking Points Memo, and niche ones like Financial Times, get most of their revenue from subscribers, not ads. What is inarguable is that the old model of ripping off advertisers and misinforming readers is finally dead, but it has taken a long time for the operators of that model to internalize the reality. The death blow was dealt by Craigslist, so we've been waiting quite a while. Personally, I refuse to listen to pleas to "support local news" coming from outlets that have been trying to destroy everything I value for decades. There may be 1 or 2 worthwhile journalists working at the LA Times, for example, but I will never ever give that organization even one dollar. Those journalists need to leave that paper as far as I am concerned.
- CPLX 3y agoThe old model is working fine it’s just that Google and Meta are using illegally acquired monopoly power to take all the money for themselves.
- jeffbee 3y agoGoogle and Meta have brought more advertisers to the doorsteps of news outfits than they could possibly have imagined, but it has also allowed advertisers to direct their spending to outlets that are actually effective. Google and Meta also absorb all of the costs to host and serve the advertisements, acquire the inventory, and operate the marketplace. Newspapers get everything for free now and they are still whining about it. Before Craigslist, local newspapers in the USA got the majority of their ad revenues from ripping off the public for classified ads. It used to cost $50 to list your used car, or advertise your garage sale. If you are a fan of the "disruption" that Silicon Valley people are always yakking about, this is the gold standard.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoCan AI do the investigative research? Sure, maybe AI can replace pundits that regurgitate stories. Replace the talking heads. But seems like we are loosing the 'originating' data, someone has to uncover the stories.
- monero-xmr 3y agoA lot of what local news did - reporting on what is happening locally - is reported more than ever. It’s just done by citizens taking videos and posting them online, where they disseminate more widely than ever before. I see local government budget reports posted on my city’s subreddit where people dissect and debate them, with detailed understanding of local politicians’ positions. I don’t see how the demise of local newspapers is ruining society. They are just an anachronism.
- karaterobot 3y ago> No matter which side you stand on the democracy-requires-a-free-and-vigorous-press proposition, we’re about to test it. As the article itself notes, nothing about this has really fundamentally changed in decades. We're long past the collapse of the news industry, and it turns out we still have a free and vigorous press. It's just not very good. We didn't lose news, what we lost was editorial oversight, basic ethics, fact checking, the pursuit of an objective voice, the resources to do good work, the courage to stand on principles, and so on. We got garbage clickbait websites and a readership both underinformed and oversaturated by news. Freedom and vigor are not at risk. Rats are free and vigorous, and rats thrive on garbage and will survive in any environment.
- Gimpei 3y agoCan we really blame loss of objectivity on the loss of the business model? The NY Times is doing fine and they totally threw out objectivity as a goal. Seems more like a cultural shift to me.
- wrp 3y agoIt might help the discussion to distinguish editorial stance from editorial oversight. You could have a news source that is well managed yet highly partisan. Some people respond to complaints about modern trashy journalism by referencing examples from the early 19th century that are at least as bad as anything today. I think what we see over history is that the mid-20th century was a high-water mark for the "appearance" of objectivity in journalism. When I look at reportage of specific cases, I'm not so sure of the actual objectivity.
- yabatopia 3y ago> they totally threw out objectivity as a goal. Seems a bit hyperbolic. Could you share some examples of that? Not from the opinion pages, but from the news section?
- karaterobot 3y agoWhat would qualify as an example here? A news article with a bias isn't proof that objectivity isn't still a goal, and by this definition studies of media bias wouldn't be evidence either.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CM30 3y agoThe big change is that news in general has been 'unbundled', since everything you could possibly get from a newspaper or magazine in the olden days can now be gotten on its own via the internet (usually for free). The hard hitting journalism aspect was basically subsidised by all the other stuff there, like sports and entertainment news, classified ads, property listings, comics, etc. Now all of those things have free competitors that usually offer a better product, so we're left with the issue of "how do we fund the journalism that matters, if most people don't want to pay for it on its own?" The other issue is that because the internet has lowered the barrier to entry for writing and news reporting so much, people have no real incentive to pay for anything. This has also hit many of the things unbundled from the newspaper above, since so many people want to write about tech/celebrity/entertainment/sports news that there's no reason to pay for it; there'll be an alternative that's just as good for free elsewhere. Also probably doesn't help there that in quite a few fields, companies and organisations are just skipping the middleman altogether, and offering their updates straight to the consumer. See stuff like Nintendo Directs and State of Plays in gaming, or Apple Keynotes and stuff in general tech. When most outlets are just listing things announced in said presentations with the minimal amount of analysis, there's not much reason to get the information from them anymore. Not sure what the solution is sadly. The problem is that there's certain types of reporting that only work with enough funding/corporate backing to make it viable, but most people don't care enough about it to pay, since that's a tiny minority of the stories in most newspapers and magazines. And with so many competitors, it's hard to justify charging for anything when so many others are just offering it for free.
- kwere 3y agoIndipendent journalists, micro teams publications (<10 people) of hard hitting investigative journalism on topics that go viral on social media to reach millions of potential customers
- someonehere 3y agoMy family still gets the Sunday paper. It’s now as big enough you can roll it up and wrap your hand around it and touch your middle finger to thumb. Crazy that ten years ago it was the size of a football. Now it barely has anything in it.