4 ms·
Get rid of Section 230 and sites like Hacker News would be forced to go offline overnight. People like to disparage social media platforms they don’t use, but
by Aurornis 3y ago
Get rid of Section 230 and sites like Hacker News would be forced to go offline overnight.
People like to disparage social media platforms they don’t use, but forget that the sites they do use are playing under the same laws.
> If you don’t believe this compatible free speech on the internet, post content you don’t think belongs on the internet here and see how quickly the community gets rid of you.
You’re missing the point. The moderators and/or community getting rid of someone after they posted the content is too late. It would have been up and available for a while. The content would have already been “published” and the liability already triggered in a world where no Section 230 like protections existed.
If you like being able to post things online on websites you don’t own, you need protections like this to exist.
- dotnet00 3y agoThere are other options between getting rid of section 230 and accepting the one-sided abuse of it by big tech.
- blactuary 3y agoCorrect. Section 230 is so wildly misunderstood. What it's doing is protecting the owner of a website from being liable for content users post. Without those protections, there would be no comment sections, no sites like FB/IG/Twitter or Hacker News, because absolutely no one is going to take the risk of allowing user-generated content that they are liable for. The people who rail against Section 230 and "censorship" have it exactly backwards, if they got their way and 230 went away, instead of having specific content removed they wouldn't be able to post anything at all.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt looks like 230 was passed in ‘96, but Usenet was around for more than a decade before that… somehow, there seems to be a way to make it work? Email could still be possible. I wonder if something like AIM could work without 230. Maybe federated social media? You’d only want to host people you actually trust, but maybe that isn’t so bad. Edit: I think it is not that surprising that people misunderstand 230, specifically 230c2. We have: * A constitution that prohibits restrictions by the government on free speech * Provides “decency” restrictions on speech in some cases * An exception for sites that act more like communication service providers, as long as they don’t editorialize, which considers the content they host not their speech * A Good Samaritan exception for sites to do moderation, so their edits and redactions are not interpreted as editorializing An exception to an exception to an exception is easy to misunderstand.