6 ms·
It would be interesting to view the evolution over long periods of time. This simulation is 2D, but it's similar to what happens in globular star clusters. In
by pfdietz 3y ago
It would be interesting to view the evolution over long periods of time.
This simulation is 2D, but it's similar to what happens in globular star clusters. In these, there's a phenomenon called the "gravothermal catastrophe".
The particles (stars, sponge bits) relax to thermal equilibrium, where the kinetic energy of a particle has a distribution where probability declines exponentially in energy/temperature. Some of the particles will have energy high enough to escape to infinity (to "evaporate"). When they leave, the remaining particles are more tightly bound, so the cluster shrinks. The particles then move faster (by the virial theorem, total kinetic energy is always 1/2 the negative of the gravitational potential energy). Evaporation accelerates until the cluster basically explodes.
Why this doesn't happen to actual star clusters was eventually determined to be due to three body collisions that cause binary stars to form, and these stars then inject energy into passing stars (causing the binary star orbits to shrink). This energy injection reheats the cluster, inflating it again and preventing runaway evaporation.
I'm not clear that the simulation here can handle formation of such binaries.
- scotty79 3y agoThis looks cool: https://twitter.com/PeRossello/status/1754253187731599760 https://twitter.com/PeRossello/status/1754253187731599760
- pfdietz 3y ago>The only force at play is newtonian gravity, which we modify by adding a softening length, ε. > This way we avoid numerical instabilities due to divergent forces when two particles get to close together. So it appears he doesn't handle close encounters that form binaries. Probably reasonable if he's using heavier discrete particles as a proxy for dark matter.
- hermitcrab 3y agoI wrote my own toy gravity simulation. 2 stars that come very close together at a clock tick will experience a massive force that throws them both right out of the system. This is an artefact of artificially dividing time into clock ticks to make the calculation tractable. As I understand it, 'softening length' is a fudge to stop that happening.
- pfdietz 3y agoYou'd have to use a more sophisticated algorithm with variable time steps for closely interacting particles, I think. And then some way to deal with particles that become bound.
- hermitcrab 3y agoThat sounds like a bit of a nightmare. Especially when you have a large number of bodies.
- andbberger 3y agoyup. molecular dynamics simulations are hard-core. and the parallelization is highly non-trivial so you need fast fabrics and complex message passing to scale. one of the raisons d'être for supercomputers
- pfdietz 3y agoDid your simulation use the O(n) gravitational potential algorithm? You don't need to spend O(n^2) time per time step.
- hermitcrab 3y agoIIRC I was calculating forces for every pair, which is ok for small N (e.g. a solar system, rather than a galaxy).
- 4gotunameagain 3y agoIntegrating physics simulations like that is very inefficient and inaccurate, as it does not conserve momentum. I get it, it was a toy, but if you're really interested look up adaptive step symplectic integrators.
- hermitcrab 3y ago
- andrewflnr 3y ago> Evaporation accelerates until the cluster basically explodes This sounds very much like what happens at the end of a black hole's lifetime as it evaporates by Hawking radiation. Any chance that's a real connection?
- Enginerrrd 3y agoNo, but also maybe yes, but it's way over my pay grade as a physicist. In short, I think the fact that gravitational systems have negative specific heat capactiy is very relevant. As gravitational systems lose energy, the "temperature" of the ensemble of particles goes up. (I.e. objects with smaller orbits have higher velocities.) It is probably not exactly an accident that this relationship holds for blackholes as well: the hawking radiation formulas suggest a larger and larger temperature for blackholes with smaller and smaller event horizons. The hawking radiation stuff is built upon entropy / temperature relationships so I think there is actually some kind of connection there. There might even be something baked into the energy conditions / bianchi identities of GR that is manifesting in that way, but I'm speculating.
- pfdietz 3y agoI don't think so? The physics is completely different.
- andrewflnr 3y agoWell yeah, probably, but sometimes very weird analogies between systems turn out to produce real physics, and it doesn't even seem impossible to me that there's something similar happening behind the event horizon of a black hole. I'm just hoping someone smarter than me has already done the math.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoHawking radiation is due to process outside the black hole.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- raattgift 3y agoI like your comment, it provoked some catch-up reading, so forgive me pecking a bit at what you wrote. The visualization is pretty limited, and was probably just a fun way for the astrophys student to use his choice of tools. (Which we should encourage! His work is great!) I am also not the only person to think the visualization would be useful when teaching early astro or astrophys undergrads. For example, <https://twitter.com/BenShappee/status/1769066245339402612 https://twitter.com/BenShappee/status/1769066245339402612>. (BTW, Shappee was in ASAS-SN from the start. ASAS-SN is awesome, I promote them whenever I can squeeze them in: <https://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/asassn/index.shtml https://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/asassn/index.shtml>). Digging deeply into the consequences of this example of obviously physically improbable initial conditions could be somewhere between entertaining and enlightening, but would quickly go over the head of early astro students first encountering the virial theorem and negative heat capacity. "Getting the physics right" would be a significant research project. You'd also generally have to do without animations, unless you are very patient and have a big compute time budget (see the acknowledgments section of the MNRAS paper below, and my final paragraph). Motivated by the previous paragraph's themes I found a recent (2022) MNRAS open access paper which among other things has a good overview of the (recent) state of the art in modelling star clusters, some good teaching material in section 2, and in section 3 we see their software packages. I'd suggest you begin with the summary in section 6.1. https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/516/3/3266/6668807 https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/516/3/3266/6668807 In principle simulating the Spongebob cluster could produce information in the top two graphs of figure 7, and a 2d version of one or two of the graphs in figure 6. The additional information in those figures is certainly interesting, but nowhere near as pretty as the Spongebob animation. And I'm not sure what extracting similar figures for the Spongebob simulation would be useful for. Conversely, the Spongebob simulation could not generate figure 9, and that figure is especially interesting to me (q.v. §4.2 & final sentence in §3.2). And finally, "The movies of the full simulations, from which Fig. 6 was produced, will be made available upon reasonable request as well and will be uploaded publicly in the future". Not sure the upload ever happened, although I didn't really search much (e.g. it's not linked at the arxiv <https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.04470 https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.04470> or in DDG media searches on title or a few of the authors).