45 ms·
I remember the day, sometime after I transitioned from high school to university, when I realized I was an adult, with agency and the power to decide whether or
by ryandrake 3y ago
I remember the day, sometime after I transitioned from high school to university, when I realized I was an adult, with agency and the power to decide whether or not I needed to go to class. I had just spent the last 12+ years of my life in the prison-like U.S. K-12 public school system where every limb movement was dictated by grown-ups. Now, here I am, with the ability to actually decide how I need to spend my time! I didn’t always make the right decision, but got better at it as I went through university.
I think some people forget this when they go into their first professional office job, and revert back to primary school mentality: I have to go to this useless meeting! Boss says I need to be there, so what can I do?? This “all hands” is required. We forget we are grownups with agency and the ability to set boundaries and expectations with others.
A lot of junior employees feel they simply have to attend every stupid meeting that appears on their calendar. When asked, I advise them that if they don’t think there is anything to learn, and you don’t have anything to contribute, simply don’t go. Nobody is going to send you to the principal’s office. I show them my calendar where I am double and triple-booked every half hour of every day: I decline meetings constantly! It’s not a big deal.
- notso411 3y ago[dead]
- scotty79 3y agoYes! I'd very much advise every young person (who can) to start a business right after school instead going to work as an antidote for the oppression ingrained by more than decade of school. Especially the kind of business that provides services for other businesses. Seeing "grown ups" in contexts where they struggle and mess up and talking to them as equal and having ability to reject them if they want something you don't provide was very important.
- stavros 3y agoIt's hard for me to decline meetings because I'm always afraid people will make wrong decisions. My job was very hard before I got invited to the meetings, as I had to run around correcting these decisions after the fact. Now at least I can catch them at inception, and minimize the damage.
- swiftcoder 3y agoI spent a chunk of my early career in this particular rut, and at some point you hopefully realise that it doesn't matter all that much. No one person (except maybe the CEO) is on the hook for every decision being correct, and even the CEO is only responsible in a macro sense. Trying to take on the role of perfect-decision-maker is either only going to burn you out, or alientate your whole team. I'll still try and point everyone in the right direction, but if the team really wants to chase their tail for a month? I'm still going home at 5, they'll figure it out eventually.
- stavros 3y agoUnfortunately, in some situations it does matter. There's a very visible change in the organization from last year, when I was excluded from meetings, to today, where I (or similar senior people from the team I recruited) are included. It's been very striking, the teams are executing much faster, we're building better things, the engineers seem happier and take more initiative, and the software is higher quality. Yes, any decision in itself probably doesn't matter much, but an accumulated year of single decisions across the whole company matters greatly.
- theK 3y agoI am a bit familiar with this pattern. I think this and what the OP describes are the two sides of a similar coin. On the OP side we have a culture that is too inclusive whereas in your case it is a culture of not breing inclusive enough. Not inclusive enough as in not involving the correct people needed to evaluate a decision. But the OP doesn't limit themselves to business, they Aldo mention brunches, birthdayd and other non work events. From my cursiry reading, I think they are more interested in making the point that one shouldn't join random events just because they where invited but rather evaluate whether participation is meaningful first.
- stavros 3y agoThat's a fair point, you're right. I was narrowing it down to a business context, because usually the consequences of missing one party or outing aren't as severe.
- silverquiet 3y agoI guess I'm pretty cynical, but I presume you need to be aware of when attendance is taken in all of these contexts. The big townhalls are obviously ego trips for the senior leaders with little to no operational information of use to the peons. But if you get known as someone who doesn't attend them, then you'll probably be known as someone who doesn't respect leadership.
- ryandrake 3y agoMaybe I’ve been really lucky to have great jobs my entire career, but I’ve never worked anywhere where anyone gave a shit whether you joined a 20+ person “town hall” or “all hands” meeting. It’s not like the managers were up in a balcony with a telescope looking to make sure everyone was there. My criteria have worked out pretty well for me so far: 1. Do I need to contribute the the content or decision making of this meeting? 2. Is there anything important to my job that I can only learn by attending this meeting (as opposed to reading the notes/slides later)? If 1 OR 2, I try my best to attend. This has gotten me through about 25 years pretty well.
- danaris 3y ago> I think some people forget this when they go into their first professional office job, and revert back to primary school mentality: I have to go to this useless meeting! Boss says I need to be there, so what can I do?? Because often, that's exactly how people are being treated. There's still a very strong trend in management philosophy that says that Manager Knows Best, and their direct reports just need to do whatever they say, Or Else. And any pushback against that is just going to be seen as insubordination—proof that that employee is a troublemaker who needs to be disciplined. It's a self-perpetuating philosophy because of that, and it can be very hard to convince a manager who's deeply invested in the belief that he's a superior being compared to his subordinates that this philosophy is neither correct nor productive.