5 ms·
"It portrayed the average Princeton/Yale/Harvard/Stanford student as extremely bright and morally earnest but ultimately rather uninspired and herd-like conform
by Alex3917 15y ago
"It portrayed the average Princeton/Yale/Harvard/Stanford student as extremely bright and morally earnest but ultimately rather uninspired and herd-like conformists."
Colleges go out of their way to select 'herd-like conformists' during the admissions process, so why would they then try to change them once they got there? This Brooks article never made any sense to me.
- wmf 15y agoThe admissions people say they reject excellent-but-bland applications, but perhaps it's a matter of degree.
- alwold 15y agoI think by "bland" they just mean that they reject people who don't have enough of the conforming resume-building activities that they expect :)
- Spearchucker 15y agoThere's a school of thought in the UK that feels institutions like this reject applications from applicants who's family don't have deep pockets. Similarly, there's the perception that Eton is capable of producing well-educated idiots. Understand me here - this isn't my view. Just saying it's a view that's out there.
- socksy 15y agoI'm not sure Eton is really applicable here, since the income of your parents matters a whole lot more than the application process (and Eton suffer for it in the league tables) — and whilst you may argue that Ivy League schools do just that, I doubt it's quite to the same extent.
- 234547556 15y agoBear in mind that the ivy leagues get to grade their own students whereas the etonians sit national exams...
- EricDeb 15y agoYes... so instead they accept people who superficially differentiate themselves and pretend to be non-conformists which then becomes another "admission strategy."