2 ms·
Duritz is a world class music professional who has lived and breathed the music business for over 20 years, but somehow you know better than him how to sell his
by guelo 15y ago
Duritz is a world class music professional who has lived and breathed the music business for over 20 years, but somehow you know better than him how to sell his music?
- tptacek 15y agoI see your Adam Duritz-backed ad-hom argument and raise you David Lowery: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3850935 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3850935 Frankly, I'd rather have Lowery on my side than Counting Crows. But, matter of taste. Too busy to read? Here's the top line: * Lowery is Cracker and Camper Van Beethoven; also, a programmer with a math background and now a recording engineering. * Most musicians make fuck-all from concerts and merch and many live out of their van. * Musicians were sharing their music for free long before file sharing sites started profiting off their work. * Technology isn't making recording high-quality music cheaper, but is sapping the returns from doing so. * When you factor recoup and automatic sale royalties into the picture, the major label system was giving midlist artists a middle class existence, which they've now lost. * Studies showing an uptick in sales after file sharing are often rigged in obvious, comical ways. * Youtube and Facebook have made it impossible for midlist artists to set up their own shops online.
- guelo 15y agoI don't know who the hell David Lowery is and I don't really like Counting Crows' music, but I don't know what music taste has to do with this discussion. Duritz wasn't saying that bittorrent is going to fix all of music's problems, he's just admitting the new realities and figuring how to work with them, "You can either cry about it or make use of it" he says. You can dismiss Duritz' experience as an ad hom argument, but the fact that he has been able to keep his business going for over 20 years, long past his hit songs, including owning a record label where he guided other bands, shows that he is not stupid when it comes to this subject. I reacted to your cavalier dismissal of his point of view. On an off topic note, your link gave me a new perspective on your attacks against one of the most important orgs of our times, the EFF. I'll just say that I think if the entire professional music industry disappears we will still, as a society, enjoy tons of music. As long as people enjoy making the stuff it will be produced, same with software and video. But if we lose the internet as a open democratic channel of communication that will take a very long time to replace.
- tptacek 15y ago"I don't know who the hell David Lowery is and I don't like Counting Crows but I'm going to continue arguing as if the primary source this person just cited wasn't one click away, and not only that, as if the person who cited that source hadn't taken the time to summarize in bullet form that very source. And also, I'm going to sound irritated about it."