4 ms·
Where are all the people defending "piracy" on this post? How much effort were a few paragraphs that got copied vs how much effort does it take to produce a mo
by davidw 15y ago
Where are all the people defending "piracy" on this post?
How much effort were a few paragraphs that got copied vs how much effort does it take to produce a movie, or a professionally recorded song?
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoPiracy is when it is the little guy stealing from the big guy... and that is ok. This is the big guy stealing from the little guy... and that is bad, mkay? lol
- sophacles 15y agoNo it isn't that at all: Piracy: "here is a free copy of the avengers" Plagarism: "here, I made you a movie, I call it the avengers" One about replicas, one is about credit. There is a difference. Quit being disingenuous about them being the same.
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoI don't think they are the same and I don't think I claimed they were. Clearly the words have different definitions and apply to different actions. One takes the work of the creator and passes it along to others without the creator getting [paid|credit|traffic|whatever creator desires] for it. The other takes the work of the creator and passes it along as their own work without the creator getting [paid|credit|traffic|whatever creator desires] for it. I was trying (with humor) to explain why some people will defend piracy and then rail against plagiarism. They do have a common thread in kind of screwing the content creator a little... but in different ways. And often in a "Big Guy vs Little Guy" scenario, people will take the side of Little Guy... regardless of who took which action. Also... kind of funny to see the difference in the meaning of plagiarism among those outraged by this plagiarism. It seems that even among those that are angry here, there is a disagreement over whether plagiarism is or is not simply about giving credit. Some seem to think that it is an issue of credit or proper use of quotes... while others seem to think that even with proper credit given plagiarism still exists. So maybe plagiarism isn't so easy to define/avoid? Not sure.
- nikcub 15y agoThe equivalent would be cutting the credits off a movie and replacing them with release group name and scene shoutouts.
- davidw 15y agoThe point being, whenever there is an article about "piracy" - being this sort of generic, "victimless" action (say "crime" and people will really go apeshit on you) - and people fall over themselves to defend it, say it's not a problem, indicate that it's just a symptom and fuck the content people if they can't deal, and so on. It's interesting that when it's just one person with their own story, that is somehow closer to HN, it seems to either change opinions, or bring out a different set of commentors. This despite the in question few paragraphs being orders of magnitude less effort to produce than a lot of the content that is typically "pirated". (Note all the downvotes with nary a response)
- nikcub 15y agoThese are two separate issues. They have only become confused because the MPAA/RIAA insists on referring to piracy as 'copyright theft' when it is not. Plagiarism and copyright theft (in the real, classic, sense) has always been a criminal offense.
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoI got your point. And yes they are two different things with (probably) two different sets of commenters. Many people provide many different rationales and justifications for why piracy is ok. It is unpopular to say otherwise and will get you downvoted. That is just how it goes.
- Xylakant 15y agoThe question is not whether pirating a movie is morally right or wrong but rather "how much damage to the internet and the society are we willing to accept when chasing people who copy movies?". Having to pay a fine when you're caught copying a song is fine. Having to pay inflated damage claims (tens of thousands of dollars for a single song) is not. Monitoring large portions of the internet only to support an industry that missed a crucial point is not fine either. So that's why no one defending piracy shows up here: Since pretty much no one is defending piracy as "morally right." (edit: fixed stupid autocorrection errors.)
- davidw 15y agoI think it's a complex, and nuanced subject with no easy answers, and agree with you that things are likely tilted too far in favor of content producers. Draconian solutions are not a solution I favor. That said, I have been here a while and see an awful lot of commentary that seems indicative that the authors neither think nor care much about the fate of content producers. There are plenty of other intelligent comments too, but I really did notice a big difference on this thread compared to one about piracy. See mikeash's comment for instance, which says that piracy just isn't as bad as plagiarism.
- mikeash 15y agoHere we go again! Piracy and plagiarism are different things. Piracy is when you copy something without permission. Plagiarism is when you fail to attribute a source. Piracy as we discuss it here almost never involves plagiarism. Have you ever seen a movie torrent where the movie was claimed to be produced by some pirate group instead of the actual movie studio that really made it? I've never even heard of such a thing. The community here tends to find plagiarism far more distasteful than piracy. And there's absolutely nothing inconsistent about that. There is no reason that these two quite disparate concepts require someone to have a common stance on both.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]