3 ms·
I'm more surprised why we don't see more of the opposite - western startups testing their ideas in Africa as a sandbox and then expanding out. Not a huge amount
by Havoc 3y ago
I'm more surprised why we don't see more of the opposite - western startups testing their ideas in Africa as a sandbox and then expanding out. Not a huge amount of disposable income there sure, but for the right product its the perfect testing ground.
e.g. zipline doing on demand blood deliveries to hospital in Rwanda. I bet their recent US drone authorization was in no small part due to their ability to point to a live operation doing at scale life/death critical deliveries with success.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOWDNBu9DkU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOWDNBu9DkU
- resolutebat 3y agoDoing business in Africa is playing life in hard mode, particularly if you're a startup with no local connections.
- notahacker 3y agoGetting VC-sized returns from medical deliveries in Africa is incredibly difficult compared with building a CRUD app and throwing VC money at sales and marketing to people that speak the same language and use the same web platforms as you and have orders of magnitude more to spend. Some of the interesting tech stuff coming out of Africa like mobile money doesn't translate into a Western environment even if it excels in Africa too.
- alephnerd 3y agoRwanda's success is overstated. They hired an amazing PR and Lobbying team from Racepoint and BTP Advisers to rehabilitate their image since 2010.
- suddenclarity 3y agoRwanda always rubbed me the wrong way since Sweden (among others) is handing them millions in financial aid every year only for them to use the money to be a shirt sponsor for Arsenal FC.
- alephnerd 3y agoYep. It's all show and little substance. Neighboring Uganda was also a wreak in the 1990s like Rwanda due to it's civil war from 1979-1986, but it has (re)built a relatively robust ICT and Financial Industry, while Rwanda's projects are mostly show or PR driven. Uganda has a massive financial sector (for a country as poor as it is) with Citigroup, Barclay's, Standard Chartered, and just about every major Indian bank operating there, along with a surprisingly professional stock exchange for a market it's size, and IMO has the same potential that Kenya had in the 2000s, which itself feels like India in the 1990s when Bangalore and Gurgaon were getting on their feet. Rwanda doesn't have similar champions.
- thfuran 3y ago>Uganda has a massive financial sector (for a country as poor as it is) Is that actually a good thing?
- alephnerd 3y agoYes. A strong and professional financial sector is a massive value add for development. Access to capital is often one of the largest blockers to business creation, and Uganda's robust financial system can ease foreigner investors qualms about investing in Uganda directly. There's a reason why foreign companies used to make a HK Shell to enter the Chinese market - it was because business and financial jurispruence was historically stronger in HK over mainland China. By having a robust local financial sector, FDI can just go directly to a business in Uganda instead of having to create a subsidiary of a subsidiary domiciled in Marutius, UAE, London, Singapore, etc which has benefits for Uganda from a tax collection perspective along with from a foreign investors relations standpoint. Add to that the fact that neighboring Kenya has an equally robust financial sector as well and that means there is a lot of capital that can flow all over East Africa.
- thfuran 3y agoHaving a financial sector is useful. I'm not convinced that having an especially huge financial sector is good. I think the financial sector often drives a lot of socially undesirable outcomes, and having any company or sector represent a very significant chunk of an economy, whether that's local or national, tends to give it more political influence than it really ought to have. >There's a reason why foreign companies used to make a HK Shell to enter the Chinese market - it was because business and financial jurispruence was historically stronger in HK over mainland China. That and they were legally mandated to open one somewhere in China.
- lupire 3y agoAre you saying the medical drones are overstated?
- alephnerd 3y agoNaw. I meant the Rwandan economic miracle. I always see Rwanda used as the poster child of "Digital Africa", when in reality countries like Kenya, Uganda, Madagascar, Ghana, etc have much more sophisticated economies and have a stronger ICT and Financial Industry base. None of the leaders of those countries do the level of PR buys that Kagame and his cronies do, despite all being in the same basket in the 90s. I can't think of a single economic champion from Rwanda that can compete pan-Africa, compared to East African peers like Uganda.
- fakedang 3y agoIf you go by the book, it's actually easier to start operations in Rwanda than it is in some states of the US South. And that's being charitable to the Americans. But Rwanda is one small country in Africa that's unlikely to give you the VC level returns that are expected by your investors. Indeed, there are some Africa-centric startups that started in Africa and ended up expanding outside (Flutterwave is one, started in Nigeria; then there's the massive flop named Swvl which started in Egypt, before expanding to other countries in the Middle East).
- rvba 3y agoWikipedia page about swvl is fascinating: the backstories of the people behind look like something written by themselves or by their marketing department (never corrected to neutral point of view). Then we learn that some spwcial purpose vehicle purchased it and stsrted layoffs nearly immediately? Purchase at last day of march and layoffs in may? How was the due dilligence made? Were those people not needed? 99% loss of value too
- fakedang 3y agoDue diligence in the Middle East? Haha! The founder rode on the coattails of Careem and its founders. He was even feted by the sheikh of Dubai on Twitter. Careem (itself a former unicorn sold to Uber at $3.1B, now recently sold to a telecom for $400m) exited their position just before the Swvl SPAC.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoTargeting a foreign culture with different regulations is always gonna have problems. Easier to do it once your product is built out and proven.