4 ms·
"Nobody rationally torrents a CD rip and then goes to the store to buy the real version." Except this behavior is commonplace. Probably as common as people buy
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
"Nobody rationally torrents a CD rip and then goes to the store to buy the real version."
Except this behavior is commonplace. Probably as common as people buying music they've heard on the radio.
Maybe to you it isn't "rational" in some sort of twisted Homo Economicus model, but in the real world it happens all the time.
- tptacek 15y agoWho do you think a comment like this is convincing? Wouldn't you have to have no real-world friends to believe that people who download music for the overwhelming most part DON'T go on to buy those tracks? All you have to do is ask anyone sitting near you to find out how message-board-fake your argument is.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoAre you implying that I'm not a real person? That my money isn't real? That my friends and their money aren't real? That all of the other people I've met who have done exactly the same thing aren't real? I think you are confused about which comment represents an unrealistic oversimplification that doesn't reflect what's happening in the real world.
- tptacek 15y agoNo, I'm implying that you aren't representative. If you tell me all the people you've met reliably or even routinely buy the music they download from torrents, I will charitably adopt the assumption that you haven't met many people.
- Retric 15y agoAs a rule people don't buy everything they torrent, but they also don't buy everything they hear on the radio. So, the existence of people who buy things they have downloaded before is all it takes to disprove the idea that it never happens. The reality is Bittorrent and the Radio both raised the bar on what it takes before people will break out the checkbook. But, they do not prevent people from paying for music.
- tptacek 15y agoI'm making a stronger claim. As a rule, I'm saying, people† don't ever buy what they torrent, because there is no practical reason to do so. Which is clearly not true of the radio. The radio drove sales of recorded music; BitTorrent saps those same sales. † (substitute "the mass market" if you're hyperliteral and can't get past the fact that you yourself violate the rule)
- libraryatnight 15y agoI'm real, also I tried your experiment and the guy next to me also buys the stuff he finds and likes.
- tptacek 15y agoRemove the abstraction. Ask him what the last three albums he torrented were, and what the last three albums he bought were. Genuinely curious.
- libraryatnight 15y agoLast 3 downloads were a Nero album (which he said he didn't like) Mastodon's the Hunter, and Silversun Pickups "whatever the new one is called" Last purchases were Gotye, the vinyl edition of The Hunter, and Edward Sharp and the Magnetic Zeroes. He says he's going to buy the Silversun Pickups one at some point. You've sparked a conversation down our row, and it's almost an even split between 6 people. Some people argue there's no point to buying the CD after download and that they feel going to concerts is payment enough. There's also some discussion that some listen to so much that they couldn't possibly afford to pay for it all even though they'd like to, but they still want to listen.
- tptacek 15y agoIt was awesome of you to follow up like this. You're clearly more openminded about the issue than I am.
- AngrySkillzz 15y agoLooks like we've got a troll here, just move along. Don't feed the tptacek.
- J3L2404 15y agoYou must be new here.
- sp332 15y agoOn a live-audience episode of Diggnation, Alex Albrecht and Kevin Rose asked a large audience, "How many of you pirate music and movies over bittorrent?" They weren't expecting anyone to seriously admit it. But about half the audience cheered and waved their hands! Then they asked "Well how many of you suckers actually buy music and movies online, like from iTunes?" and about half the audience (mostly the same people) cheered again. They were pretty confused about this (as you seem to be), but the reaction made it clear that it's pretty common behavior. They followed up by asking why people pay for stuff when they have no problem downloading it. The two main answers were: "If I like it, it buy it" and "I expand my collection any way I can."
- tptacek 15y agoI think I'm suggesting not very subtly that people are cheering for what they want to be true, but not for what they actually do. Ask any 10 of those people anonymous what the last 3 things they torrented (and, sure, liked) were and what the last 3 things they bought were, and the sets will be disjoint. David Lowery would say that recorded music sales stats, especially when deconfabulated, bear out that assumption. I'd also suggest that common sense does the same: much of the mainstream market for music can't afford to buy every single track they want to listen to, and yet the suggestion seems to be that they have a monklike devotion to doing that when there is no practical benefit to doing so.
- sp332 15y agoI think people have an amount of money they are willing to spend on music, and they allocate that among bands they want to support. Then they torrent all the other music they want to listen to. Those are not necessarily the same bands.
- tptacek 15y agoI think that's a very credible middle ground interpretation between the poles of "nobody pays, everyone pirates" (which is what I think) and "everyone pays, piracy is just marketing" (which is what HN believes). But, obviously, that middle ground still represents a transfer of wealth away from the people who actually produce music and towards a new breed of networked middlemen who capitalize on other people's work and couldn't give a damn about the future of music. Oops, I let my rant seep back in there. Sorry!
- chrischen 15y agoI highly doubt teenagers and low-wage earning youths torrent with the intent to buy a CD. In fact I know of no one around my age (younger side) who even buys CDs in general. Torrenting and then downloading from iTunes makes no sense either.