2 ms·
The ultimate limit on # of Starship launches may be from water pollution in the upper atmosphere. Each Starship launches produces about 600 tons of water (eith
by pfdietz 3y ago
The ultimate limit on # of Starship launches may be from water pollution in the upper atmosphere.
Each Starship launches produces about 600 tons of water (either in the exhaust, or from oxidation of hydrogen in the exhaust). Let's ballpark this and say half is ejected in or above the stratosphere (any ejected above the atmosphere quickly returns to the atmosphere.)
The Feb. 2022 eruption of Hunga Tonga–Hunga Haʻapai injected an estimated 146 million tons of water into the stratosphere. So, under the ballpark assumption this would be equivalent to half a million Starship launches. Beyond that (if even that is acceptable, as the water stays up there for several years) materials in space might have to be obtained from space sources, not by launch from Earth.
EDIT: why was this downvoted?
- ben_w 3y ago4000 ish tons of propellant, half a million launches per year, would be 2 gigatons total propellant per year. Until the Sabatier process plants are running at scale, that will also release a non-trivial fraction of current global CO2 emissions.
- pfdietz 3y agoI got something wrong in the first post. I misread the propellant mass and was only looking at the second stage. So, multiply the water production by a factor of 4. Not half a million launches, but 1/4 of that. So the water constraint on launches is even worse than I was saying (this is likely what led to the downvote?)
- ben_w 3y agoRe: downvotes — I never ask when I get them, and I didn't vote either way. (I think even asking that is frowned on?)
- pfdietz 3y agoWell, I've never been dinged for it, but I'll stop if that's the case. It would have been more useful to get a critique there; I could even have corrected the post before the edit window ended.