4 ms·
Of course it matters! It means Google doesn't actually get to say how Mozilla runs Firefox. They have a contract for a service ("make us the default search for
by jsnell 3y ago
Of course it matters!
It means Google doesn't actually get to say how Mozilla runs Firefox. They have a contract for a service ("make us the default search for the next N years, and we'll pay you X% revenue share on those searches"), Mozilla fulfills their part of that contract, and that's it. Google can't, for example, demand that Firefox must support some web standard proposal as a condition of being paid. If they tried making such demands, Mozilla would just sell their service to somebody not making such unreasonable demands.
And the reason people keep parrotting this idea on HN is to imply that there is some kind of wrongdoing and malicious use of funding as leverage going on. But that idea only works if this isn't a normal commerical arrangement with multiple potential bidders.
Another way it matters is that the utterly moronic ideas people throw around for this being an antitrust figleaf. Paying for default search engine placement is just how that business works, and worked before Chrome even existed.
- rglullis 3y ago> Google can't, for example, demand that Firefox must support some web standard proposal as a condition of being paid They don't need to demand that, but how would you explain that Mozilla (despite all their talk about privacy and safety in the Internet) never considered putting an ad-blocker in the default install? The point is: Mozilla needs funding from any of the Big Tech more than any of the Big Tech need Mozilla. They have, for all intents and purposes, sold out to the highest bidder and it doesn't matter who it is.