3 ms·
You are assuming the cost/mass of a spacecraft is somehow a constant of nature. It's not, not at all. Reduce the cost of launch and there's enormous benefit o
by pfdietz 3y ago
You are assuming the cost/mass of a spacecraft is somehow a constant of nature. It's not, not at all. Reduce the cost of launch and there's enormous benefit of reducing the cost of the spacecraft, since that cost now dominates. Use cheaper (if heavier) materials, use higher margins to reduce design and testing costs. Use COTS technology and spend mass (shielding, pressure vessel) to make it work in space. Perhaps most importantly: launch large numbers of spacecraft with the same design to amortize design cost over more vehicles. Reduce design cost by hardware-rich development where problems are found by testing in space, not exhaustive preliminary analysis.
- qayxc 3y agoThe problem is that the assumption holds true more than ever: https://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/small-satellite-market-150947396.html https://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/small-satel... Small sats are cheaper and a rapidly growing market. Technical question: what do you suppose a - say - 50t commercial payload would even be? Currently there's two options that I am aware of: space stations (where again launch cost is NOT the primary cost factor) and space telescopes. Unless you can provide actual data and facts, I am not convinced at all this is going to change. Especially, since COTS hardware already IS used in the commercial spacecraft business. You can simply buy a standard bus and put your own hardware on it. Heck, you can even buy satellite components online: https://www.cubesatshop.com https://www.cubesatshop.com
- pfdietz 3y agoYou post a link about satellite construction at current launch costs. That has nothing to do with what I was talking about, which is what happens when launch costs fall to as little as $10/kg. I want you to imagine what happens if two countries in conflict have cheap launch. Space assets are important, and it would become worthwhile to protect them. That means mass, the more the better. The market here would be almost unlimited. And that's just one possibility. Consider space manufacturing (like ZBLAN fibers), high power (multimegawatt) comsats, high resolution imaging from high orbit (mirrors tens of meters across). These are just off the cuff ideas; we could keep listing others. None of them have to be terribly convincing to rebut an argument there's obviously nothing to be done.