3 ms·
Imagine we had this technology 20 years ago and we switched to fully automated web design. I bet all web design would still be deeply nested tables. I doubt th
by croes 3y ago
Imagine we had this technology 20 years ago and we switched to fully automated web design.
I bet all web design would still be deeply nested tables.
I doubt that something like React, Vue, Svelte would exist.
- parautenbach 3y agoProbably one of my favourite comments. Thanks. My version: Can an auto AI create cumulative knowledge (the core of the scientific method)? My take is no. You can use it to identify gaps (opportunities) in research or to summarise research, but can it actually come up with a novel and consistent theory?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoI mean.. that kinda sells AI in everything for me, but then I am a statist.
- emehex 3y agoI think about this "potential for ossification" a lot, especially in the Python Data Stack. Because there's a ton of pandas code on GitHub (much of it trash) any data task asked of ChatGPT/Claude inevitably returns some pandas (mostly correct, but often wrong/inefficient/ugly/hard to grok). How could a new library (like Polars, or my own failed "redframes") possibly unseat pandas now? Might LLMs actually lead us to, and get us stuck in, a "local maximum" of sorts?
- falcor84 3y agoAs I see it, the issue with using tables for layout is that they made it difficult for humans to maintain and iterate over time, but I don't have a problem with an LLM working at that level. Equivalently, I don't care that the machine code that my system gets compiled into is full of GOTOs if I don't ever need to concern myself with that level.
- croes 3y agoThink of all the improvements browser got because we wanted to replace tables as positioning tool. Not to mention the inefficiency of a pure table approach, so much wasted render time and energy.
- falcor84 3y ago> so much wasted render time and energy. It was amazing two decades ago when we came together as an industry and refocused our priorities on making the web faster and more energy efficient</sarcasm>
- diarrhea 3y agoThis is an excellent point. A sibling comment of yours called it ossification. There hasn’t been much innovation or change in Instruction Set Architectures, and there can’t be as the entire world of software relies on these. Only true disruption, such as ARM is for x86, can very slowly change that. So with that in mind it seems plausible that for example pandas becomes the ossified, low level standard high-level code “compiles” down to. I’m sure tons of such API wrappers already exist, but AI might make it so that we truly never need to interact with the lower layers. We wouldn’t care if it was pandas or something else. I personally am not bullish on that. If at all, this is still a decade out at least, and there’s always demand for people working at all layers of the stack. Languages like C and beyond didn’t fully alleviate the need for Assembly engineering. In fact, in some sense, the number of Assembly engineers might not have decreased at all, aka wasn’t impacted. There were simply new avenues for new sorts of engineers to enter the field and start producing (C back then, web development today as the tech furthest removed from low levels).