5 ms·
I mean, the free market is working pretty well. http://libgen.rs/ http://libgen.rs/ The government-granted monopoly, not so much.
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
I mean, the free market is working pretty well.
http://libgen.rs/ http://libgen.rs/
The government-granted monopoly, not so much.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> I mean, the free market is working pretty well. > http://libgen.rs/ http://libgen.rs/ Exactly. What a lot of economists tend to "forget" is that markets also include black/illegal markets and markets that are hardly controllable by the government.
- j_maffe 3y agoUnfortunately many are misled to believe that pirating books published by cartels is unethical.
- c0pium 3y agoPlease explain your alternative mechanism for compensating the author for their work.
- j_maffe 3y agoI'm not proposing an alternative mechanism. I think people who can comfortably afford to pay the asked price for a book should of course do just that. On the other hand, for the billions of those who do not have that privilege, I wholeheartedly recommend piracy. It is of no cost to the author/publisher (since they weren't going to pay anyway) and of tremendous positive impact for equality and social mobility for the community. In a perfect world piracy would be an unfair and unnecessary venture. In this one, for many people it is absolutely justified.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> Unfortunately many are misled to believe that pirating books published by cartels is unethical. It's not a question of ethical vs unethical, but about which evil you consider to be the worse.
- j_maffe 3y agoYeah, I agree. I think it can be a case-by-case situation depending on both the reader and the publishere/author. An undergrad needing a course textbook that's published by a monopolistic cartel with a 300% markup? Absolutely. For well-paid worker in a developed country buying a novel written by a niche author? probably not the right thing to do.
- akho 3y agoIt's very unclear how book sales translate into income for authors. You are rewarding middlemen; these middlemen have a role that may or may not be important these days.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoHow is this a market if Boone is paying? If anything, this is communism? You can’t even have a market of IP without government granted ownership of IP. This tired old trope that Government vs market doesn’t work here
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe bad communism is when the government takes your stuff and you don't have it anymore. This is "communism" in the same way that everyone being able to breathe the air or speak English without paying a proprietor for the right is "communism". This is often a motte and bailey that communists use, but you're attacking the motte. You're essentially arguing that there isn't a market for air. But there is. This is the market served by submarines and firefighting gear and spacecraft and HEPA filters. If no one had a monopoly over copies, you'd still have a market to supply them, they'd just generally be really cheap and the supplier would be someone like Cloudflare. Likewise there would still be a market for creating works, because people would pay for commissions. There might not be as many of them, but there would still be a market.
- WalterBright 3y ago> You can’t even have a market of IP without government granted ownership of IP. Sure you can. See Germany in the 19th century with no IP protections. Business and prosperity boomed! Consider also the incredible success of open source software.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> You can’t even have a market of IP without government granted ownership of IP. What on earth are you thinking? For essentially all of human history, every work of art was produced for the market, and it was impossible to own any IP.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoI mean digital - of course you can have a market for physical things.