4 ms·
The Rising Price of Power in Chips
- ForOldHack 3y agoIncrease the surface area exposed to coolant. yea, Its an easy fix, but someone had to point it out. Pesky thermodynamics
- datameta 3y agoIn Figure 2 depicting 2.5D warping, why is 246C a relevant temperature? In my experience with IBM Power and Z systems, north of 85C is considered the high end already. What am I missing? Interesting article overall.
- mikewarot 3y agoThe picture shows temperatures up to 316K, which is 42 C.... so likely it's a typo for 46 (or 45?) centigrade. It's the repeating of an earlier mistake.[1] Which apparently partially arises from [2] which is behind a paywall. [1] https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ansys-receives-2021-tsmc-oip-partner-of-the-year-awards-for-next-generation-design-enablement-301430460.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ansys-receives-2021... [2] https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Heterogeneous-Integration-Using-Organic-Interposer-Scott-Bae/df1f85b53ae17e719ad23ba0bca09456412eb81a https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Heterogeneous-Integrat...
- datameta 3y agoAh yes, that's it right there. Excellent sleuthing, thanks.
- godzillabrennus 3y agoGreat breakdown of current challenges.
- amomchilov 3y ago(ヮ)
- RetroTechie 3y agoWhat hardware advances giveth, today's beyond-ridiculous-overweight software stacks taketh away.
- sliken 3y agoI think of that as a win. Heavy software stacks create a demand for faster hardware and the market provides. Those of us with use cases that represent a tiny marketshare, but actually need the performance can do so with light software stacks. So the question is, how can we make the overweight software stacks even slower?
- Out_of_Characte 3y agoBy going back to using interpreted languages. No more precompiled binaries where changing/adding patches and flags require full builds, just stream compiled/compressed source code directly to the target. You could also extern the software to a webserver and only cache small parts of the software on the client. Instead of gigabytes of install sizes you'll be required to have a 1 or 10 gbit network link to run and stream features as you're acessing them.
- taneq 3y agoMake it “industry standard best practice” to provide devs with absolute top end cutting edge hardware “for productivity and efficiency gains”. Repeat this at every opportunity at conferences and industry events until it becomes ubiquitous. Profit as devs slather abstraction layers, trivial libraries, emulation layers etc. on because “developer time is worth more than CPU time” and “it’s not slow on MY computer”. :D
- bevekspldnw 3y agoI’ll replace my i9 workstations with an ARM equivalent as soon as I can. The power draw on i9 sucks, more so with the A6000 running.
- error_logic 3y agoThe idea that ARM solves power issues seems a bit overblown and driven by Apple purchasing the most advanced nodes sooner than competitors, causing people to associate the efficiency gain with the architecture even though a lot of it is the silicon process. Edit: Also Apple can and does do away with legacy support which is less about the architecture and more about expectations of what is included vs. deprecated. The push to ARM seems like it will result in a loss of support and control in the users' hands (converting expectations of PCs into those of smartphones) but now I'm really into speculative territory...
- lend000 3y agoThis is probably largely accurate -- not to mention the fact that Apple has been using efficiency cores longer than x86 competitors.
- LoganDark 3y agoThe efficiency cores actually aren't the primary thing that makes M-series chips so power efficient, even though they help. Even when you're ripping big data apart the chips do it faster than nearly anything else on the consumer market, while managing to be far more efficient as well. It's not just the process node, it's stuff like decoding multiple instructions in parallel being simpler due to the architecture.
- DinaCoder98 3y agoIs there any evidence that x86 can compete with arm on per-watt computation?
- error_logic 3y ago
- moffkalast 3y ago> “The base leakage is lower than the previous technology, but the overall total power is higher,” said Melika Roshandell, product management director at Cadence. “So at the end of the day, your thermal is going to be worse because you’re packing a lot more transistors into one IC and you’re pushing the performance. So why not match the previous gen's TDP and just use whatever gains you get from more efficiency? Back in the 90s 300W was considered extreme for an entire system, today just a single 4090 can pull a full kilowatt. This constant increase manufacturers have been pushing to compensate for diminishing returns is unsustainable and completely absurd.
- Vecr 3y agoAMD lets you do that, and it's probably recommended in some cases. They don't force you to (except in some laptops?) because would give the user less freedom and because it would leave performance on the table. It does mean that the default boost settings have the chip running at a bit less than 100 Celsius on any standard air cooler.
- milesvp 3y agoI’m curious about what is happening in the field of reversable computing. I haven’t heard much about it at all in the last 20 years. Basic information theory tells us that it takes energy to destroy information, so building ALUs that limit destroying information seems like a bit of a no brainer for attempting to create lower power (and heat) computing. The basic premise is that for any operation that loses info you store enough bits to allow the operation to run backwards. If you were clever about it, you could design your chips to only destroy bits in places that can be effectively as well. I’m sure reality gets in the way of pure theory, but I was sure that people were spending enough effort on the concept to have heard more about it.
- zozbot234 3y agoReversible computing doesn't help wrt. static or leakage power, which is an increasing fraction of power draw in recent device nodes. It does help wrt. dynamic power, and can be implemented via charge-recovery logic - but this comes at a cost in area which increases static power.
- pillusmany 3y agoOur power problems today are far away from the theoretical limits you described. But reversible computing is inevitable in quantum computers, so it's researched in that context.
- sgdpk 3y agoI have worked on this aspect on quantum computation [1]. The main problem is that reversibility is a feature of isolated quantum systems. In practice, they are not isolated. Why? It's not just because of small interactions with the environment that we cannot control. It's that even the apparatuses that we use to control/drive the logical instructions (lasers, electrical transmission lines) should be taken into account if the computer is to be considered isolated. But usually they aren't, and this leads to inevitable losses of reversiblity in the data register. In other words, unitary (reversible) operations do not come for free. I think that in quantum computers it is more likely that energy-efficiency will come from some sort of algorithmic advantage. [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.10470 https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.10470