6 ms·
Snapdragon X Elite Multi-Core Superiority Claims over Apple's M3 Were Right
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y ago- 12 cores vs 8 - 8 perf. cores vs 4 - higher TDP - ~$1,968 vs $1,499 not a fair comparison, you need to compare against the M3 Pro, and then you loose ;)
- Synaesthesia 3y agoI would have been shocked if Snapdragon had suddenly beaten Apple silicon because it would necessitate such a huge increase in performance, that it's nearly impossible.
- Rinzler89 3y ago"However, bear in mind that the Snapdragon X Elite was previously tested at two power limits; 23W and 80W, so it is possible that the SoC obtains a higher single-core and multi-core score with the bigger power draw at the expense of heat and rising temperatures, not to mention battery life if the Galaxy Book 4 Edge would be used without being plugged in." Meaning this comparison is relatively pointless at this stage until third party unbiased apples to apples comparisons in controlled environments are possible. Comparing Geekbench scores of different CPUs operating at unknown power limits in unknown environments are pointless.
- 2muchcoffeeman 3y agoThe initial results are still looking impressive though. There is finally good non-Apple ARM. Time to move the goal posts and see if they can actually get Windows or Linux working as well as MacOS on ARM.
- joakleaf 3y agoThis part in the article feels a bit sloppy: "A fair comparison would be pitting the Snapdragon X Elite against the M3 Pro, but it is likely that the more capable Apple Silicon would obtain a higher multi-core score." OK, so to get the scores for M3 Pro, go to GeekBench Mac benchmarks (https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks https://browser.geekbench.com/mac-benchmarks): Scores: M3 Pro (12 core): 15274 M3 Max (16 core): 20958 Vs. Elite (12 core): 13925 Still impressive though.
- xattt 3y agoI can’t tell if Snapdragon’s Elite branding is supposed to be the same as Apple’s Pro. If that’s the case, then comparing it to a base M3 is not appropriate.
- hmottestad 3y agoForm factor and pricing will play a big role. You can’t get the M3 Pro in a MacBook Air, and it costs a bit more than the base MacBook Pro models.
- pyb 3y agoWouldn't performance per watt be the correct measurement for this class of device ?
- planb 3y agoOr Performance per Dollar?
- salojoo 3y agoPerformance per dollar has traditionally been the selling point with PCs. Performance per watt is the selling point with Apple silicon. Does this one fit somewhere in between?
- LoganDark 3y agoASi has performance-per-dollar for days if you need the unified memory. i.e. it's more performant than some datacenter-class GPUs while potentially also having far more memory as well.
- kotaKat 3y agoCorrect. Everything QCOM has been demoing has been at two power points: 23W and 80W. These tests look remarkable but the real test's going to be out in the field when they're power-throttled to nothing and back in hardware designs trying to cut every cost they can, including their power budget. It's great they made a Hemi engine, but it's not going to fit in the Smart car that companies want to put it in.
- hu3 3y ago> In multi-threaded workloads, Geekbench 6 reveals that the Snapdragon X Elite is actually 16 percent faster than the M3 and trails behind the latter in the single-core run. What's impressive to me is that Snapdragon X Elite is already competitive despite being built in an older N4P tech (announced in 2021). IIRC Apple's latest offerings are built using N3B. So Qualcomm is onto something here.
- krger 3y ago> So Qualcomm is onto something here. Yeah. Using 12 cores to get 16% more performance than an 8-core processor gets.
- tarruda 3y ago[flagged]
- chasil 3y agoThe odd thing is that the Qualcomm CPU is 89% as fast as the M3 in a single core test. It shouldn't take 12 cores to achieve dominance.
- bcaxis 3y agoPower limits probably affect this. And scaling cores isn't linear, their cores clearly scale poorly. Though Geekbench particularly scales poorly with cores.
- gambiting 3y agoI mean...............yes, you're right. But at the end of the day if the CPU is faster at the same energy used(I assume it is), then the end user won't care whether the CPU is 1, 8 or 128 cores(and why should they). It's like people saying that Apple products are inferior because they usually have less ram than competition - and yes, that's technically true, but in practice it literally doesn't matter, they are still usually just as fast if not faster than competition with more ram - so why should the end user care.
- jsheard 3y agoWhat's the software story expected to be like with these desktop Qualcomm chips? Any chance of official Linux support, or are we just getting Windows drivers and maybe semi-working reverse engineered Linux support years down the line?
- onefiveone 3y agohttps://www.phoronix.com/news/Qualcomm-Mainline-Linux-2024 https://www.phoronix.com/news/Qualcomm-Mainline-Linux-2024
- jacooper 3y ago> But still a work-in-progress is audio support, DP Alt-Mode, enabling the DSPs, USB-C power delivery, and GPU acceleration. AKA still garbage.
- perihelions 3y agoThinkpad has a ARM Snapdragon model and people have been working on it in Linux for a while. Linux support is unofficial, and still crap, years after release. For example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37431710 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37431710 ("Linux on the Arm-Based ThinkPad X13S: Getting There")
- exabrial 3y agoSystem76 hopefully listening! (To prevent rumors, I’ve never seen them mention arm support before… maybe someday)
- jsheard 3y agoI don't think there's much System76 can do if the ARM SOC vendors aren't willing to cooperate by openly releasing code and documentation for their parts.
- tomComb 3y agoHopefully it gets chrome OS support so that it has official Linux drivers.
- causality0 3y agoPerhaps I'm out of date on the subject, but does it matter how fast it is when Apple's x86 translation layer makes Microsoft's look like banging rocks together? Not to mention the fact much of Apple's ecosystem now runs natively on ARM whereas that is decades away for Microsoft if it ever happens at all.
- xgdgsc 3y agoA native app list: https://armrepo.ver.lt/ https://armrepo.ver.lt/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kossTKR 3y agoDoes Windows run natively on ARM + most of its software? Do they have their own translation layers as fast as Rosetta 2? Just curious as to how it works.
- Almondsetat 3y agoRosetta 2 was/is "impressive" because Apple was smart enough to bake some x86 functionalities into their ARM designs to aid the transition. On the other hand Qualcomm and other OEMs don't have in their interests to offer such functionalities so Microsoft is forced to 100% emulate x86
- goosedragons 3y agoYes, Windows 11 runs natively on ARM. There is ARM native versions of MS Edge, Office, Visual Studio. Most software from 3rd parties is still x86/x64 based but some things like Firefox are available for ARM. They do have their own translation layers for both x86 and x64 based apps. It's "slower" than Rosetta 2 but it's just commodity ARM hardware with no accommodations for certain x64 instructions like Apple Silicon. I've been mostly impressed by it.
- gambiting 3y agoOh, for a second I thought you meant the limited VS Code, not the real Visual Studio - but I checked and they do actually have a proper full VS running on ARM now, that's super cool. Would make me seriously consider buying an ARM windows laptop.
- jeroenhd 3y agoLast time I dug into this, the conclusion seemed to be that Windows' translation layer, built in cooperation with Qualcom themselves, is actually quite competitive. Performance numbers weren't that far off from Rosetta for desktop applications, with an estimated performance 0-15% lower than Rosetta, which is quite low for a platform without x64 memory model optimisations. The first release could only do one architecture (32 bit or 64 bit, I'm not sure) but its capabilities have been expanded. A lot of benchmarks are outdated and it seems like nobody has been paying much attention to it in a while now. The biggest problem with Windows on ARM doesn't seem to he the binary translation, but the slow SoCs the translation is running on. The most important tools (browsers, Office) work fine on ARM without translation. The translation layer is necessary, but I'm not sure if common use cases will see all that much use for most people.
- jchw 3y agoWhat I really wonder is if these new Snapdragon SoCs will be closer to what we're used to with PC hardware today. e.g.: Will we get SystemReady and the ability to disable Secure Boot? There doesn't seem to be any information regarding that, so I guess probably not. But after a lot of false starts, it does seem like competitive alternatives to x86 computers that are also more "open" PC platforms are probably happening in the imminent future. This would be nice. I suspect that what isn't imminent is seeing stuff like this show up in desktop parts, but if it does, here's to hoping for modular main boards with DIMM slots.
- goosedragons 3y agoYou can disable Secure Boot on at least some of the existing Snapdragon-based ARM PCs already.
- my123 3y agoAll. Every single arm64 desktop machine supports disabling UEFI Secure Boot.
- FloatArtifact 3y agoHowever is there support cycle less than x86? Not only that there's a lot more fragmentation. Is there backward compatibility to run aprogram 6 years ago for an arm hardware that was released this year?
- almatabata 3y agoI might be missing some examples but the last breaking change i remember was the deprecation of the 32bit support: https://www.gsmarena.com/arm_will_drop_32bit_support_in_the_big_cortexa_cores_starting_in_2022-news-45688.php https://www.gsmarena.com/arm_will_drop_32bit_support_in_the_... I think ARM are clearly more comfortable breaking compatibility than Intel.
- shrubble 3y agoIf there is an always-on baseband processor that loads a binary blob or like the Pi, where the GPU actually manages the initialization and running the ARM CPU, then it's a no from me... without open source bootloaders we'll still be subject to the tender mercies of Qualcomm.
- mrAssHat 3y ago[flagged]
- rubymamis 3y agoI wonder what type of applications we use daily makes use of multiple cores?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- K0IN 3y agoI wonder why the snapdragon does only slightly increase in compute power even tho they nearly triple the power consumption, or am I reading the charts in the source (linked on page) [0] wrong? https://wccftech.com/qualcomm-unveils-more-snapdragon-x-elite-pc-cpu-benchmarks-23w-80w-reference-laptops-tested/ https://wccftech.com/qualcomm-unveils-more-snapdragon-x-elit...
- kuter 3y agoIt looks like the future for laptops is ARM. I hope Lenovo makes a ThinkPad with this chip, there already is a ThinkPad with a Snapdragon SoC (ThinkPad X13s), but from what I have read it's not very good. I considered getting a MacBook to use with Asahi but some important features are still unsupported (like HDMI output support).
- frankjr 3y agoThis is such a bizarre article. First, they say superiority claims were right all along, and then paragraph after paragraph they reveal worse single core performance, worse multi core performance (needs 4 more cores to gain 16% advantage), higher power draw, and to finish it off they mention that Geekbench is not really a great benchmark.
- dogma1138 3y agoNot only 4 more cores but the QC chip has 12 performance cores rather than the 4+4 setup of the M3. So 50% in total core advantage and 200% when it comes to high performance cores only for 16% multi-threaded lead is hardly an advantage. Ofc there are caveats to this if QC’s performance cores are closer to Apple’s efficiency cores in terms of size and power consumption then it’s a different story. But that doesn’t seem to be the case. The other major caveat is that QC has so far only been demoing its SoCs on devboards which don’t share the same power and thermal restrictions as real world designs. Whilst the M3 figures are for real world hardware. So squeezing the Snapdragon Elite into a MacBook Air style form factor might paint a very different picture.
- The_Colonel 3y agoApple performance cores are very big in terms of area, you can't just compare the numbers. I think it comes down to performance / watt / area, while single core performance is also important.
- akmarinov 3y agoWhen can we get a device with it though?