3 ms·
Intuition 1 is incorrect. The probability of the marble being under the box during that period of time was 1 because its state never changed. It was merely you
by kstenerud 15y ago
Intuition 1 is incorrect.
The probability of the marble being under the box during that period of time was 1 because its state never changed. It was merely your incomplete knowledge that encouraged you to (incorrectly) assign a probability of 0.5. You've become confused over WHAT is the subject of your test.
If, however, you were to change the experiment such that there were two boxes, one with a marble and one without, you now have the ability to engage in real probability. The probability that a marble is present under each box is either 1 or 0. However, the probability that you will CHOOSE TO LIFT the box containing the marble is 0.5. This is not a probability of presence or absence of a marble; it's the probability that YOU will choose to look under a particular box.
Probability requires the possibility of change, and the probability of change in a marble's presence under a box (such as by teleporting from one box to another) is small indeed.
- tallanvor 15y agoYou're making assumptions when you say that "the probability that you will CHOOSE TO LIFT the box containing the marble is 0.5". Consider that there may be 3 boxes, and the person setting up the experiment flipped a coin for each box. If the coin landed heads up, a marble was placed in the box. If the coin landed tails up, no marble was placed. This means there may be 0 - 3 marbles total. Until you know the actual state of the box, the probability remains 0.5.
- kstenerud 15y agoProbability is temporal. You need to specify timeframe. If you are talking about before the coins were flipped to decide whether a marble was to be placed into the box, then at that time BEFORE the coin was flipped, the probability would be 0.5 per box. If you are talking about AFTER the coin has been flipped, the probability for each box goes to either 0 or 1. This is regardless of whether an outside observer is aware of the state or not. If you were to now enter the room, having no knowledge of what boxes (if any) have had a marble placed in them, the probability of a marble being in a particular box has not changed. It is STILL either 1 or 0. There are only two ways to induce probability at this point: Pick a single, random box to open, in which case you are measuring the probability that you will choose a box with a marble in it (you are measuring yourself, not the marbles). The other is to guess whether a particular box has a marble in it, and then open it, in which case you are measuring whether your guess is correct or not (once again, measuring yourself, not the marble). Most people go wrong here because they think they are measuring one thing but are actually measuring something else.
- BCM43 15y agoThis would then go down to theoretical physics and whether or not it was already defined which box you would choose. I think something closer to the Schrödinger's cat experiment, and whether the cat will die. In this case, I think you could objectively say the probability is 50/50.
- kstenerud 15y agoThe Schrödinger's cat experiment is flawed, as pointed out by Niels Bohr and explained here: http://web.archive.org/web/20061130173850/http://www.ensmp.fr/aflb/AFLB-311/aflb311m387.pdf http://web.archive.org/web/20061130173850/http://www.ensmp.f... The wave function collapses as you induce probabilistic action. And once again, to speak of probability one must speak temporally. Lack of observation of the change does not negate the change in probability.