8 ms·
BitTorrent Is The New Radio, Says Counting Crows Frontman
- paulhauggis 15y agoIt only works if people know to search for you, like the Counting Crows. The nice part about actual radio is that it can give unknown artists airplay (and people will actually listen to it).
- roc 15y agoThat's a largely theoretical advantage for radio. What happens far more often is that the big labels that are paying (directly or indirectly) get to decide what gets played. And listeners are forced to choose between a handful of intentionally-overlapping stations, each of which is pushing, primarily, an unfortunately small number of "hits". While bittorrent itself is not a medium that lends itself to discovery, it does at least serve any non-trivial subset of taste and isn't as easily gamed as radio play and shelf space.
- AncientPC 15y agoManagers pay quite a bit to get "unknown artists" airtime on radio stations. Smaller bands advertising via internet route still have YouTube, Soundcloud, etc. I've bought a few albums as a result. Also, with the proliferation of smartphones, a significant group choose to listen off their own devices rather than slog through yet another pop song + advertising.
- libraryatnight 15y agoIf you belong to a good private (or maybe a public one, too) torrent community, you'll likely end up finding more artists than the radio would help you find. Just looking at new uploads, looking at top lists, browsing by tags, and going through by genre yields new finds. It's easy to listen to new/unfamiliar artists risk free, and most passionate music lovers do find a way of getting money back to the artists. At least in my own experience this is the case. I'm sure there are people who are 100% freeloaders, but I wonder if they'd have bought anything ever anyway.
- goblin89 15y agoSome more or less private trackers do actually promote artists explicitly (featuring select submissions). And even when they don't, people still easily discover new less known bands from searching by genre and reading torrent discussions—I'd say it works even better than radio. Although this depends on the community and submission guidelines of a particular tracker.
- perspectiveless 15y agoThe Pirate Bay have been promoting unknown content on their front page as have other file sharing sites. There's music blogs and youtube channels that promote unknown artists. Not to mention file sharing technologies such as direct connect and soulseek that lets you browse everything a user shares which is another way of discovering new content. You can search for something that you like and hopefully discover people with similar taste and find new stuff in their collections.
- codeine 15y agoThat's true for bittorrent, although as others have suggested, smaller torrent communities focused on a particular genre may also act to provide ad-hoc recommendations. At Presto.fm we're working on a different solution to the problem, by creating a way to discover and stream new music using personalized radio stations seeded with the listener's existing favourite artists or genres. (A bit like some existing services but with a focus on niche artists and a deep catalogue of music). http://presto.fm http://presto.fm
- paulhauggis 15y agoI would much rather see a legal way (with permission from the artist) like Pandora.
- codeine 15y agoEnsuring that artists receive both exposure and fair compensation is important to us. Presto.fm currently uses music content from YouTube, which is licensed under Google's agreements with the major labels and the NMPA, so that artists can receive royalties from the ads included in player. Many independent artists also upload their own music for free, just as they do with Soundcloud, etc, as they recognise it as a great way to reach new audiences.
- psychotik 15y agoRadio is still no good for 'real' discovery. If you're really into music discovery, give Audiogalaxy a shot. Here's something to start with: http://www.audiogalaxy.com/mix/11997-The%20Coding%20Zone/ http://www.audiogalaxy.com/mix/11997-The%20Coding%20Zone/
- dagw 15y ago"Sorry, Mixes are not available in your country" Never had that problem with torrents...
- tptacek 15y agoFar more likely that Duritz is naive about BitTorrent than that he's right about its role in his industry. People listen to songs on the radio and then buy the recording so that they can play higher-quality versions of their preferred songs on demand. Nobody rationally torrents a CD rip and then goes to the store to buy the real version. Further evidence of Duritz naivete: they're releasing a 4-song teaser of their new album on BitTorrent. Exactly what is the advantage of holding back tracks in their official release? It is utterly, absolutely inevitable that high-fidelity versions of all their tracks will be on BitTorrent moments after they become available in any form. Partial teaser releases are a pantomimed form of control and a waste of time. If you believe P2P sharing is a real business benefit, you embrace it for real.
- eCa 15y agoMaybe not buy a CD for themselves. On the other hand.. I have bought and given away music that I've only listened to pirated (more than once). I also most likely wouldn't have been to two Bob Dylan and two PJ Harvey concerts if it hadn't been for Napster and BitTorrent.
- jmatt 15y agoUnless they have credit for writing the song, or self publish, the band makes most of their money from touring and merchandise. BitTorrent isn't a zero sum game. It's difficult to prevent and any action upsets fans. Why not embrace it and get free PR. Meanwhile, the people that will buy it (or request it on a radio station, or listen on Spotify) need to be aware of the music. And both groups end up attending concerts. So it's really a win for the bands. It's the labels that are at risk.
- tptacek 15y agoDavid Lowery says that's not true. He says that your idea of how much artists make from touring suffers from cognitive bias: we pay attention to the anomalously successful huge touring acts, but that the reality is bimodal: a very few major touring acts, and then a huge cluster of artists who make less than minimum wage from even respectably attended club shows. Neko Case made some comments to the effect of how much her returns were from touring _Middle Cyclone_. I went to that show in Chicago, which packed the large Chicago Theater. Neko Case was repeatedly featured on NPR and other media venues. She is anomalously successful. How amazingly lucrative do you think that tour was for her? Hint: if you're picking between being Neko Case and a senior engineer at Google just based on the money... Of course, Steve Albini's famous "Some Of Your Friends May Already Be This Fucked" made much the same point about touring. He'd put it this way: if you're picking between being a midlist touring act and a senior manager at Wendy's just based on the money... Meanwhile, the popular conception of how lucrative a label recording contract was is also mistaken, because it failed to take into account recoup rates and automatic per-sales royalties that are paid out even when albums don't recoup. In reality, the recording contract alone both financed the (very expensive) professional-quality recording of music and provided musicians with a base-level middle class income.
- jeffpersonified 15y agoAs much as I enjoy Counting Crows (did?) I hardly think Duritz is the best indicator of industry trends.
- oldschooltaper 15y agoI think some commenters are missing the point. For Duritz, who admits he collects bootlegs[1], bittorrent is being envisioned here as a promotional tool, not a distribution tool. Radio used to be the main promotional tool. Disc jockeys (once fully human, now often pre-programmed since radio stations have all been acquired by large corporations) could make or break an artist. And it's been this way for as long as the recording industry has existed. Even if you were lucky enough to get time at Sun Studios in Memphis, if the radio did not agree to play your songs, "no one" would know you exist. And you would not become a cash cow for some record company. No listener has to pay for radio. It's "free". Duritz is smart. His band is also in need of some promotion. Who is going to listen to radio at the point when everyone is connected to the internet and when the internet offers a more flexible way to get music "for free"? The answer is no one. That point is inevitable. 1. Assuming he's a reasonably serious collecter that implies he knows all about distribution of "pirated" content. Before file sharing became easy, this used to be the postal mail. People mailed cassette tapes to each other. As an artist, he also sees a side of the "pirating" issue many collectors of bootlegs (perhaps analogous to today's bittorrent addicts) do not see.
- J3L2404 15y ago>Duritz is smart. Citation needed.
- ye-olde-taper 15y agoThis made me laugh. Nice one. :) It's opinion not fact. No citation needed for opinions of the author. Nevertheless I will rephrase for anyone who might confuse opinion for fact: In the author's opinion, Duritz is, with respect to this decision, being smart. Smart means smart in a business sense. Time will tell if he is truly being smart in deciding to do this.
- psychotik 15y agoErr, no. Music streaming services (Pandora/Audiogalaxy/Spotify) are the new radio. Facebook's Open Graph is the new radio. Background music in ads (Apple ads, for example) are the new radio.
- oldschooltaper 15y agoThere was a time in history, when radio was first introduced, when publishers of newspapers sued radio stations for reading the news over the airwaves. It seems rather short-sighted now, doesn't it?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- WiseWeasel 15y agoBT isn't comparable to radio or something like Pandora or Lastfm. It's more like the new version of making a dub tape of a friend's music, labor-intensive and not always convenient or practical.
- oldschooltaper 15y agoPerhaps the internet will lead to musicians who are in it only for the music, the self-expression and the ego boost, not for the money. Maybe the truth is that it has always been this way. Maybe musicians didn't ask to be paid for doing what they love. Maybe record companies just realised they could profit recording and distributing a musician's music. And the musicians were quite happy to be paid. But once record companies give a musician this "easy money", musicians are unlikely to ever want to sacrafice that benefit. Eventually it becomes viewed as an entitlement. Digital recording and the internet means we don't need record companies to distribute music anymore. Will musicians stop making music? Will the quality of music decline? These are very weak arguments with no evidence to support them.
- J3L2404 15y agoDuritz is a muppet. But hey if your hero is Kim Dotcom then he looks cool I guess.