5 ms·
Better Idea: A Lemon Law for commercial equipment. Doesn't matter if Taylor uses copyright, DMCA, patents, contract law, replace-every-10-hours proprietary fi
by bell-cot 3y ago
Better Idea: A Lemon Law for commercial equipment. Doesn't matter if Taylor uses copyright, DMCA, patents, contract law, replace-every-10-hours proprietary filters, brittle plastic gears, or what - companies that inflict unreliable & high-maintenance crap on the economy need to suffer sustained fiscal agony.
- kube-system 3y agoThat doesn't really make any sense in the context of a franchise. AFAIK McDonalds franchises are required to buy those specific Taylor machines.
- bell-cot 3y agoWhy doesn't it make sense? Taylor makes crap, Taylor sells crap to "Smallville Burgers, LLC", Taylor pays agonizing penalties & fines. Doesn't matter if the victim bought the Taylor equipment because McD's contract required it, or because their daughter is a Swiftie.
- kube-system 3y agoTaylor doesn't think there's anything wrong with their machine, the maintenance is just onerous. The result of applying any Lemon Law here would be that Taylor buys the machine back. Leaving the franchisee without an ice cream machine, and potentially out of a franchise. Given that an ice cream machine costs thousands, and MCD franchises cost millions, it is a no brainer to just deal with the machine.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoIf Taylor just buys everything back, they no longer have a business, no? Wouldn't that be a good incentive structure for change?
- kube-system 3y agoTaylor wouldn't be buying anything back because no franchisee wants to torpedo their investment over an ice cream machine.
- bell-cot 3y agoAssume a loophole-free Commercial Equipment Lemon Law would disallow any "Oops, sorry, your contract with McD. requires you to suffer while we profit!" crap. Or perhaps McD. would also be liable for agonizing fines?
- kube-system 3y agoThen you're not talking about a lemon law, you're talking about something else. I think what you actually want are laws that regulate franchise agreements. That's the actual problem here.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> If Taylor just buys everything back, they no longer have a business, no? No. They have a monopoly. If they’re forced to buy them back, they’ll incorporate that cost into the next round that the franchises are required to purchase.
- bell-cot 3y agoIf Taylor buy $X machines back for $X plus agonizing financial penalties, then figures they'll recover the losses selling $2X machines...$4X machines - then the SEC will be expecting "Taylor may not be a viable or sustainable business" disclosures in Taylor's next quarterly filing. If there is one - major creditors and investors could move first.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> then figures they'll recover the losses selling $2X machines...$4X machines Yes, this is what having a captive market means. The problem is the franchise agreement. Shoehorning this into a lemon-law framework doesn’t work.
- bsza 3y ago> Leaving the franchisee without an ice cream machine, and potentially out of a franchise Their ice cream machines are broken so often that it’s already become a meme. They might as well not have them at this point.
- kube-system 3y agoRight, we know they're broken all of the time. However, the franchisees must have the machines to comply with their franchise agreement which grants them the ability to sell any McDonalds food.
- indymike 3y agoForcing a buyback of defective equipment does not preclude the purchase of a new, non-defective unit. Without the lemon law, the buyer would toss the old unit out without compensation and buy a new one. This way, the buyer will get money back from the defective unit and be able to get a new unit with it.
- wtallis 3y agoThe McDonald's franchise agreement is what precludes the purchase of a non-defective unit.
- indymike 3y agoSounds like Taylor will be set up to loose a lot of money if they don't fix the lemon. Even if it's just swapping out a lemon for a new lemon, Taylor will have an incentive to fix this.
- kube-system 3y agoThere's a lot of miscommunication on this topic. These "broken" machines aren't actually "broken". They require extensive cleaning cycles and some operations require manufacturer servicing. It's just they way they work, it's documented, and there are service contracts in place to do the servicing. When the kid at the drive through says the ice cream machine is "broken", what is actually meant is that it is currently not producing ice cream, and they don't want to argue with the person who wants ice cream. But the reason isn't that it is malfunctioning. Taylor isn't losing money "fixing" these machines, the maintenance they do on them is on contract, and is quite lucrative.
- devNoise 3y agoThe machine it sells to McDonald franchisee are crap. They make other ice cream machines for other franchises and they don't seem to have the same repair issues.
- 7thaccount 3y agoIt does because McDonald's isn't the one that suffers. It's the franchise owners having revenue extracted by them from the ice cream company and McDonald's corporate. Taylor makes perfectly good machines for other restaurants iirc.
- kube-system 3y agoA Lemon Law wouldn't let franchisees use different machines. A Lemon Law would (might) require Taylor to buy them back, which wouldn't be desirable for a franchisee.
- bombcar 3y agoFrom what I recall (and I may be wrong) the McDs versions are "idiot proofed" in ways that the other restaurant machines aren't. The complaint is you can't de-idiot proof it, even if you know what you're doing (and some McDs franchises are owned by people who run other restaurants with the other machines). It's quite possible that McDs requires these idiot-proof ones because the risk of "someone got sick from the ice cream gonorreah machine" is too high.
- ransom1538 3y agoThis. They breakdown on purpose if not cleaned. Being dairy and all, I think it's a good plan.
- bsder 3y agoThe McDonald's machines ARE unique and supposedly superior. They can sterilize the feed liquid without removing it from the machine. Nominally, this is far more idiot proof than other machines which are dependent upon underpaid fast food staff cleaning the machine correctly every single night. The problem is that Taylor didn't allocate enough development funding because the sales volumes are low and consequently they produced an unreliable machine. Even worse, Taylor gets to double dip by being the only people allowed to repair the unreliable machine. McDonald's only cares in that the machine doesn't give customers food poisoning--for them, mission accomplished. Taylor only sees positive cashflow from repair and consequently has zero incentive to improve the machine--mission accomplished. The fact that the franchisees get shafted isn't on the radar.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoThe problem exists outside the arena of franchisor/franchisee relationships. The downthread idea of a DMCA exemption for repair reasons is a very good one.
- kube-system 3y agoYeah, a DMCA exemption for repair is a great idea. It has absolutely nothing to do with lemon law, however.
- Reason077 3y ago> ”McDonalds franchises are required to buy those specific Taylor machines.” This is the weird part. Why doesn’t McDonald’s step in and certify an additional equipment supplier so that franchisees have a choice? This would put competitive pressure on Taylor to improve their machines, since franchisees are likely to avoid equipment that is unreliable or has high maintenance costs. McDonald’s customers would be happier too. It reflects poorly on the McDonald’s brand that there is this constant guessing game (or having to check in the app) of whether shakes and flurries etc are available at any given time/location.
- entropicdrifter 3y agoMcDonald's corporate doesn't give a shit about the health of their franchises, they're getting kickbacks every time they renew their contract with Taylor. Taylor makes non-garbage ice cream machines that work just fine at, e.g. Wendy's. McDonald's just has the brand-recognition and clout to get away with a shitty corrupt practice for the moment, so that's what they're doing. For money.
- raverbashing 3y agoBecause the only thing McD cares about is getting theirs "Ice Cream machine out of operation because of technical issue?" Not their problem
- mattmaroon 3y agoThey used to be, but have not been for like four years. But most of them still choose it anyway, because it is a perfectly good machine, and even with their ridiculous repair restrictions, the economic case is still better than the competitor.
- pwg 3y ago> Better Idea: A Lemon Law for commercial equipment. Even better idea: Amend the DMCA to permanently add an exemption for bypassing DRM for repair purposes. Of course it likely won't happen because those most impacted by the adjustment of the statute would buy a sufficient number of congress critters to block passage of the amendment.
- Simulacra 3y agoBe thankful for your government, it's the best that money can buy.
- madeofpalk 3y agoThat is actually what the FTC and DOJ is proposing here, when reading their actual ask rather than blogspam poorly rehashing it. > This proceeding concerns possible temporary exemptions to the DMCA’s prohibition against circumvention of technological protection measures (“TPMs”) that control access to copyrighted works, including functional software that facilitates the repair and monitoring of consumer and industrial product McDonalds soft serve are mentioned only as an example of what would benefit > As described by Public Knowledge and iFixit, four “index” examples of commercial and industrial device categories would benefit from the proposed expansion: commercial soft serve machines, proprietary diagnostic kits, programmable logic controllers, and enterprise IT > The proposed expansion would benefit competition in areas beyond those outlined by Public Knowledge and iFixit. For example, increasingly sophisticated agricultural equipment often employs onboard computers that control error identification and repair, limiting options for farmers in need of quick repairs. https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/ATR-FTC-JointComment.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/ATR-FTC-JointCo...
- mikepurvis 3y agoNice to see PLCs called out here— they're ground zero for traditional factory automation, and are typically the easy route to anything that needs to be low volume and programmable while also being capital-s Safe. But anything smarter than a tape-following AGV also has a computer on it running a bunch of high level perception and control software, so there's a natural friction point there, particularly if the PLC can only be flashed from proprietary Windows-based software.
- dimitrios1 3y agoBest Idea: companies that inflict unreliable & high-maintenance crap on the market naturally go out of business because people freely choose to no longer purchase their unreliable and high-maintenance crap.
- Y_Y 3y agoSo you're proposing to change the people. I can't imagine that's easier than changing the law, even if I agree with you that the free market should solve the problem.
- dimitrios1 3y agoFrom what I understand (could be wrong): McDonalds forces their franchises to buy these Taylor ice cream machines, and despite the high cost and frequency oof repairs, McDonalds franchisees continue to own and operate McDonalds meaning that despite the troubles, it is still worth it. If the ice cream machine caused a big of an issue, McDonalds would see less franchisees, and discern from their research that the machine was an issue, and change brands. Again, it starts with the customer. If people really are that pissed off McDonalds ice cream machines are seemingly always broken, then they should stop going to McDonalds, and then the feedback loop will start from there. It's not like there isn't ample other options (Wendys, Burger King, etc). That tells me that this "problem" is really overblown, and while McDonalds customers really would prefer to have the option to reliably order ice cream, it does not deter them significantly enough from consuming McDonalds, and doing something like simply purchasing their ice cream from a different location. If McDonalds wants to recoup that income, then they will, again, prioritize that initiative, and work on improving the ice cream machine, but again, that juice does not seem worth the squeeze.
- sahila 3y agoYou’re making it out to be far simpler than reality. McDonald’s is more than just an ice cream place, they sell Big Macs, fries, a clean place with wifi, and cheap coffee. It would have to be the sum of those worse off than a competitor. A bad ice cream machine could just mean sub optimal profits / experience.
- mattmaroon 3y agoTaylor isn’t selling lemons. Their machines are among the best. They simply (like any soft serve machine) can’t withstand improper use and they’re being run mainly by teenagers who don’t give a shit. The lack of serviceability is the problem here. McDonald’s has for a few years been allowing franchisees to use Carpigiani (the other big brand in commercial ice cream machines) but they’re not better machines and while they are much more open in regards to servicing, parts must come from Italy and wait times are longer. Most of the franchisees are still opting for Taylor even though they have a choice.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoThe average age of a McDonalds employee is 23. https://www.zippia.com/mcdonalds-crew-member-jobs/demographics/ https://www.zippia.com/mcdonalds-crew-member-jobs/demographi... I'd also like to add my own experience with jobs that tell me constantly to go faster and faster: that you have to do everything so fast requires a certain level of durability in your equipment and tools. If you are moving fast, you have less leeway to be careful with things.
- mattmaroon 3y agoOk 23 isn’t that far from teenager and I agree employers are at least partially (maybe largely) at fault, but that just backs up that Taylor is not selling lemons.
- Kerrick 3y agoThe average age of a workplace being run by one 60-year-old manager employing five 16-year-olds is also 23.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoThen maybe they should hire fewer 16 year olds.
- nickff 3y ago
- nightfly 3y ago> brittle plastic gears That fail protecting the rest of the mechanisms
- grecy 3y ago[flagged]
- stouset 3y ago> brittle plastic gears FWIW, in most cases this is done intentionally not as a cost-saving measure but to improve repairability. It's cheaper and easier to have a 5¢ nylon gear fail when subjected to out-of-spec loads than to have catastrophic failure of multiple structural parts that happen to be the weakest link in the kinetic chain from the motor. This does also cause them to fail through regular use, but having to do minor maintenance is a fundamental aspect of operating machines that are designed to be repaired and not simply thrown away.
- Atotalnoob 3y agoDo all of them need to be plastic, or can just one? Typically what I have seen is one gear is plastic and the rest are metal
- mikepurvis 3y agoAlso depends what the larger policy is around that one designed-to-fail part. Is it a toolless swap, with the store manager having a baggy of them in a cabinet somewhere? Or is even the sacrificial component only able to be swapped out by a special technician who must be specially summoned with some amount of cost and lead-time?
- simcop2387 3y agoThat'll depend a lot on the plastics and forces involved. Sometimes metal against plastic like that will increase the wear of the plastic parts because of the differences in hardness of the materials.
- adolph 3y ago> when subjected to out-of-spec loads A clutch similar to a drill could be used to protect a drive chain.
- nickff 3y agoClutches are much larger, more expensive, and liable to fail themselves if not regularly actuated. Most commercial equipment is quite well-designed by thoughtful people; a non-expert is unlikely to come up with a better design at a moment's thought.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CatWChainsaw 3y ago[flagged]