3 ms·
An under appreciated aspect of the "housing crisis" (define that however you want) is how illiquid the market is. A big factor in this is the 3-6% cost of each
by xnx 3y ago
An under appreciated aspect of the "housing crisis" (define that however you want) is how illiquid the market is. A big factor in this is the 3-6% cost of each transaction. That's $11-23K for the median US house price of $387,600. Compare that to the $100 title transfer fee of a car. There would be a lot more housing transactions if it didn't cost the equivalent of a year's rent to do so.
- tempsy 3y agoAre there really more transactions in other countries where the commission is much smaller? I'm not sure that is really one of the main reasons why a seller decides to sell a home or not.
- radlad 3y agoWouldn't lower fees encourage more frequent speculative trading of properties? Most homeowners are not jumping houses every year or so.
- smileysteve 3y agoMany speculators get their license specifically to avoid these fees; so the professional speculators can speculate for less marginal overhead than an individual that intends to live in the home.
- whimsicalism 3y agoMost housing that is “speculated” on is still rented out. Encouraging price discovery lets us provide cheaper housing in areas of high demand before it becomes a major problem.
- whimsicalism 3y agoDebt financing has a lot more to do with illiquidity.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoThree are two housing crises. The first is a market-rate housing crisis which is caused by government zoning that limits the construction of new homes and thus leads to supply shortages and high prices. Zoning reform will fix this crisis. The second housing crisis is one of people who can’t afford housing no matter the price. These people need govt assistance, preferably in the form of vouchers. The transactional costs from realtor fees does reduce liquidity, but it is a secondary factor compared to zoning.
- whimsicalism 3y agoMore than just vouchers, these people need services provisioned in places other than those with the most expensive housing costs in the country. The quality of services offered by NYC and SF to the homeless is unparalleled but it simply is not economical/borderline absurd to try to house them in the economic agglomeration centers of the US.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoYep. Often the reason a person can’t afford a home at all is due to other needs or issues (job training, mental health, etc..). A comprehensive services package could be of immense benefit if administered correctly. Your second point (NYC, SF being still too expensive) illustrates how solving the market rate housing crisis will help solve the non-market rate housing crisis.
- whimsicalism 3y agoEven with lots of house building, the market rate will not get low enough to make it economical to house most of these people. Given the unmet demand for density right now, it will take a lot of building in a lot of metros for there to be a significant decrease in rents in urban centers. Even with really a ton of building in SF, we are talking 25% reduction in rent when these people would have trouble even with a 50% reduction in market rents. Massachusetts has recognized this problem, which is why most new vouchers are in Fall River, MA rather than Boston - it is much cheaper to house.