3 ms·
This is barely even policy. It will never happen. A list of problems: * Fundamentally what this does is offer some workers doing a 40-hour non-exempt workweek
by tptacek 3y ago
This is barely even policy. It will never happen. A list of problems:
* Fundamentally what this does is offer some workers doing a 40-hour non-exempt workweek an additional 4 billable hours. But all that does is take a snapshot of current wages and offers a temporary benefit; prevailing wages will adjust to capture this phenomenon. Remember that very few full-time workers in the US make the minimum wage.
* The economy is not set up to run on a 4-day workweek, most especially for the non-exempt employees who are the only people this bill applies to. A doctor's office is not going to shift from 5-day weeks to 4-day weeks to accommodate this, so either the non-exempt intake person is going to get converted to two non-exempt part-time intake people, or they're going to work a 40 day workweek anyways.
* There is a huge swath of the economy that is in the same economic class as the median non-exempt worker but makes a salary, and, for no reason anybody backing this has explained, they get no benefit from this at all.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoHonestly I think such bills are an immediate answer to the problem of more of the workforce being automated. And at if we get to a point where technology has reduced the need for labor by 50% they are almost inevitable. In such a scenario, mandating a 20-hour work-week for example would be a reasonable solution to what would otherwise turn into mass unemployment and poverty. I don't think it's the best solution, but it's a decent one that requires less of a fundamental shift to society.
- tptacek 3y agoYou can say that a real policy to shift the economy to 4-day workweeks would be an answer to automation. But you can't reasonably say this policy is, because it doesn't do anything meaningful. It will give, for a period of some months, a ~10% pay raise to a fraction of US workers.
- jedberg 3y agoEvery one of these arguments were made when the five day workweek was introduced. Turns out the economy adjusted.
- tptacek 3y agoThat the economy will adjust is my whole point. (I do not think that the exempt/non-exempt argument was made at the time, since the 5-day work week long predates the FLSA).