4 ms·
How does it compare to Catch-22?
by mooreds 3y ago
How does it compare to Catch-22?
- Lariscus 3y agoJoseph Heller claimed he would have never written it had he never read The Good Soldier Švejk.
- mooreds 3y agoHmm. A quick Google didn't find that. From https://www.nytimes.com/2004/11/17/theater/newsandfeatures/the-model-of-a-soldier-but-no-model-soldier.html https://www.nytimes.com/2004/11/17/theater/newsandfeatures/t... "Heller, who died in 1999, told various interviewers that Céline and Kafka were his most powerful influences and that "Svejk" was "just a funny book.""
- Zircom 3y agoFound a quote, had to use the anglicized spelling though. https://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2011/08/heller-201108 https://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2011/08/heller-201108 "The Czech writer Arnošt Lustig claimed that Heller had told him at a New York party for Milos Forman in the late 1960s that he couldn’t have written Catch-22 without first reading Jaroslav Hašek’s unfinished World War I satire, The Good Soldier Schweik. "
- malermeister 3y agoGermanized, really.
- _visgean 3y agothere are some references in catch-22 and its follow up Closing time.
- bee_rider 3y agoI was really surprised by Closing Time. I forget all the details of it, but I remember finding it just relentlessly depressing. The only degree to which I thought it worked was, it really emphasized the extent to which we really don’t need to know what happens to characters after the story is done, it is better if we just imagine they go on to have their lives.
- _visgean 3y agoSame. It was so heavy compared to catch-22. But I am not sure the aging perspective could have been written any different.
- rightbyte 3y agoI think if you like one, you like the other. I think the Svejk book have a more innocent tone and is less cynical. But I was way to young when I read them to have a "deep" understanding of the contexts.
- romwell 3y agoI'd say it's more cynical. There's a place for hope in Catch-22. In Svejk, the gruesome absurdity of the war prevails in all situations.
- imjonse 3y agoI found Catch-22 much more hilarious than Švejk.
- ufocia 3y agoI thought Svejk was more available to a younger reader. However, like someone already mentioned, it has enough layers for a reader of almost any age to enjoy. I'd read them both.
- watwut 3y agoIt makes sense unlike Catch-22 that does not make sense.
- soperj 3y agoit only makes sense once you've already read it once.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoCatch-22 is funny during the read but after the end, and in reflection, is pretty dark. Svejk is generally funnier, IMO
- mcepl 3y agoŠvejk is too much slanted by the expectations of “just funny” and by (absolutely awesome, but too nice) illustrations by Josef Lada. When listening to the audio version of the book, I was shocked how actually horrific story it is. I have mentioned elsewhere in this thread a Czech literary historian (M. C. Putna) who called “The Good Solider Švejk” as “Kafka’s ‘Trial’ by other means”. I think he is quite correct.
- The_Colonel 3y agoAs a child, I understood Svejk as pure comedy and didn't get any of the darkness.
- sireat 3y agoI thought Švejk to be much funnier. Rather I thought Catch-22 to be a so-so imitation of Švejk. Then again I've been re-reading Švejk since childhood. Similarly, how you can tell when Hasek dies before finishing Švejk and his friend takes over with the ending, the jokes just fall off a bit.
- romwell 3y ago>How does it compare to Catch-22? It's the Catch-22 of WW1. A bit more gruesome and obscene, both less serious and much darker than Catch-22, and highlighting a wider scope of social (and military) issues.