You are arguing a strawman. I'm not saying that I am guessing Y and that in my opinion it is what they need. I'm saying that if the asker provides Y it will oft

You are arguing a strawman. I'm not saying that I am guessing Y and that in my opinion it is what they need. I'm saying that if the asker provides Y it will often turn out better for both of us. I never once suggested that I would answer something that they didn't ask.