3 ms·
Relatedly, UT Austin found the SAT highly predictive and decided to reinstate the requirement: https://news.utexas.edu/2024/03/11/ut-austin-reinstates-standardi
by rayiner 3y ago
Relatedly, UT Austin found the SAT highly predictive and decided to reinstate the requirement: https://news.utexas.edu/2024/03/11/ut-austin-reinstates-standardized-test-scores-in-admissions/ https://news.utexas.edu/2024/03/11/ut-austin-reinstates-stan...
> Those who opted in had a median SAT score of 1420, compared with a median of 1160 among those who did not.
> The higher standardized scores translated on average to better collegiate academic performance. Of 9,217 first-year students enrolled in 2023, those who opted in had an estimated average GPA of 0.86 grade points higher during their first fall semester, controlling for a wide range of factors, including high school class rank and GPA.
- resource_waste 3y agoThese kind of things are making me conservative on knowledge. >10-15 years ago 'standardized testing doesnt matter at all' >You are an idiot if you think it matters >Oops THEY were wrong. You are still an idiot and ahole for disagreeing with me 10 years ago. Obviously there is a golden mean here, but I just remember how radical some of these teachers were.
- username332211 3y agoA golden mean between what? Truth and falsehoods. I hate citing 1984 in any matter such as this one, but there's a word in it for that - "doublethink".
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoA golden mean between "standardized tests don't matter at all" (false) and "standardized tests are the one right way to measure students' abilities" (also false).
- porkbeer 3y agoThey arent binary. Some tests wont matter at all, some will, and many will be in an unverifiable grey area,
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThe people who were saying tests didn't matter were the people that thought other things mattered and had other agendas to push...
- alistairSH 3y agoBut, is first-semester GPA predictive of anything? I'd rather see this result at graduation. Does the higher SAT predict higher graduation rate, better grad school or job placement, or anything else? Note, I'm not arguing it won't be - I don't know. I just know more than a few people who bombed their first semester (most with SATs well above average), myself included, who ended up with decent academic performance once they got over the "shock" of being an adult away from home.
- arethuza 3y agoI did terribly in first year, scraped through second year and did really well in third and fourth years - to the point of getting a first and a class prize. I don't think it was anything to do with "shock being away from home" - but actually realising that some things require hard work.
- alistairSH 3y agoOh, for me, it was definitely "no parents? Party!" That got old pretty quickly, just not quickly enough to save my first semester grades.
- arethuza 3y agoHappily the grade of degree awarded was based something like 75% on final year exams and project and 25% on 3rd year and you just had to survive the first two years. Edit: I had started partying long before going to university so had already got that out of my system... :-)
- rayiner 3y ago> I just know more than a few people who bombed their first semester (most with SATs well above average), myself included, who ended up with decent academic performance once they got over the "shock" of being an adult away from home. Individual students might underperform because they're not prepared for living outside the home, but that factor would cancel out when you're comparing two populations with thousands of students. Note that, according to the article, the 0.86 GPA point difference--which is huge, like the difference between top of the class and below median--was after adjusting for high school GPA. So the analysis should factor out differences resulting from some kids simply being more "put together" as freshman than other kids.
- 077sd015o46 3y ago0.86 GPA points higher during their first semester. Is that really such a massive informational advantage?