3 ms·
this sounds like a ponzi scheme in the making, or at least not going to end well
by paulpauper 3y ago
this sounds like a ponzi scheme in the making, or at least not going to end well
- arno1 3y ago#studybitcoin
- paulpauper 3y agousing tons of debt to buy bitcoin is independent of the case for bitcoin
- latchkey 3y agoIt depends on your vision of 'the case for bitcoin'. To me, it is absolutely the case. You collateralize your debt with bitcoin, to buy more bitcoin. Using your pet rocks to create more pet rocks, creates more scarcity, price goes up. It is a perfect circle. Saylor is a genius to see that, but he isn't the only one. The problem though is that long term, I'd argue that ETH is playing this game a lot better. If you can mentally get past the DAO failure and whatever other drama, programmable money, is the absolute future, especially since they solved the energy usage issue, and soon the scaling issues.
- rwaksmunski 3y agoThat's one way of removing the excess cash out of the economy.
- jongjong 3y agoThe fiat scheme is the bigger ponzi. It's already the case that to earn any decent income in the fiat ponzi, one must have special social connections to business leaders and/or politicians. It's just like under communism. I don't even like Bitcoin and don't own Bitcoin because I have ethical concerns about it. Bitcoin promotes corruption of the socio-political system via extreme, massive-scale tribalism. That said, it's probably the lesser of two evils. As an outsider, it's ironic to witness fiat proponents neglect the power of corruption which they themselves have been benefitting from to a far greater extent than Bitcoiners. The side which can exert the most corruption (the will of their tribe), most quietly, will win. Likely Bitcoin since it has the support of the masses and business leaders. Fiat proponents can only blame themselves. They're the ones who made Bitcoin possible with their global ponzi. I don't like the current system and I also don't particularly like where it's going but the trajectory is clear.
- alchemist1e9 3y ago> Bitcoin promotes corruption of the socio-political system via extreme, massive-scale tribalism. Could you elaborate on what you mean and the mechanism for this?
- jongjong 3y agoThe usual stuff. Political and corporate bribery and extortion. Bitcoin is great for that. Made all the better by the fact that many bribe recipients cannot access their Bitcoins in the current system due to government surveillance of exchanges. This creates an incentive for insiders to take down the current socio-economic system. Just as a short seller has an incentive to see the company crash. They will have no issue accessing their Bitcoins once current governments have collapsed or become sufficiently corrupt. I've witnessed crypto regulators behave in corrupt ways, but it's impossible to prove bribery until they move or sell their ill-gotten crypto. Because, with crypto, you can receive tokens without your own approval. Someone could send you the passphrase of a wallet containing millions of dollars worth of Bitcoin, it could end up in your email spam folder and you could memorize it and, if ever questioned about it, claim you don't remember seeing that email. There would be zero evidence. Yet if you remember the passphrase, the Bitcoin is yours.
- lupire 3y agoThe market cap of Bitcoin is 99% not self custodial with keys people still have control of, not counting Satoshi'd hoard that might or might not be accessible. All the new ETF interest in Bitcoin is just digital beanie babies. Without the tradfi system, there would be almost no demand for Bitcoin, which completely undermines its alleged purpose. If you want cryptocurrency, Bitcoin isnt it.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoIt's not possible to start a new currency system without reference to, dependence upon, and transfers with, the existing currency system - especially given that the existing system is so entrenched due to its extensive history. Given Bitcoin's reason for existence, it's obvious for another reason that "without the the tradfi system, there would be almost no demand for Bitcoin": if everyone trusted that tradfi was a good system and working fairly for all members of society then bitcoin wouldn't have a reason to exist. Bitcoin, like Trump's popularity, is an FU to a system that's reaching or reached a critical mass of people lacking trust in it. And that doesn't mean it's good or bad or better or worse, what it means is that people are looking for an alternative to the perceived hopelessness of their futures if they 'stay the course'.
- kinghajj 3y agoThere's some hay in the cryptocurrency space right now about how MSTR's market cap merits its inclusion in the S&P 500, which some think will cause a "flywheel". (1) Index funds purchase MSTR shares, driving up the price; (2) thus allowing Saylor to issue more debt to buy BTC, which drives that up; (3) MSTR shares appreciate due to its BTC holdings; (4) go to step 1 as funds need to rebalance and add more MSTR shares. The weak points to this idea are definitely step 2 and even 3. MSTR won't be able to keep finding entities to buy its debt indefinitely, and MSTR is already trading well above what its BTC holdings' appreciation would justify, so there's some obviously unsustainable mania going on.
- dharma1 3y agoInclusion to S&P500 is a committee decision, not based on purely market cap. It may not happen for MSTR. MSTR is essentially a leveraged, debt laden commodity trust rn, with a highly volatile commodity making up most of its balance sheet. Their premium to NAV is indeed very high, and makes you think why would anyone buy that vs a BTC ETF. Perhaps if you think BTC goes a lot higher (and stays there) their ongoing leverage and the premium you pay for it now makes sense? Their debt is pretty well structured - v. low interest and matures a long time from now, but remains to be seen how long he can keep issuing it. He also keeps saying he's never going to sell BTC, but I don't see how he's going to service his debt eventually if he doesn't sell. Unless he starts market making with the treasury or somehow putting it to work
- alchemist1e9 3y agowhy is Bitcoin so divisive? why some people just “get it” and other scream until they are blue in their face it’s a scam? it’s such a curious litmus test for something but I’m not sure exactly what.
- throwaway98797 3y agoall faith based stuff is like that religion politics they work because people believe they work
- IncreasePosts 3y agoProbably because of the insane costs of securing the network. If it used trivial resources people probably wouldn't care
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoEvery time bitcoin goes up $1 N number of people will die from the networks CO2 output over the coming centuries. N may be five to seven digits.
- ska 3y agoI suspect what you are missing here is that both sides just "get it", they disagree what "it" is. I don't find the anti-crypto folks to be particularly more or less screamy than the pro-crypto folks, for what it's worth.
- dharma1 3y ago