4 ms·
I don't think it makes sense to attribute any special amount of quality to Moai; IIRC only one commercial-quality game (Crimson Steam Pirates) has been released
by kevingadd 15y ago
I don't think it makes sense to attribute any special amount of quality to Moai; IIRC only one commercial-quality game (Crimson Steam Pirates) has been released in it. DFA will count once it's out, I guess, but that's a ways away.
Having used Moai myself I wouldn't really call it commercial quality. The documentation is poor, the code is cryptic, and it tends to crash or do strange things instead of report errors. It also fails to abstract out hardware limitations or notify you of them (for example, it'll let you use 4Kx4K textures and then when you run on a machine with a 2Kx2K limit, Moai just falls over instead of providing clear error feedback or scaling-down the texture.)
- pygy_ 15y ago> only one commercial-quality game (Crimson Steam Pirates) has been released in it. DFA will count once it's out, I guess, but that's a ways away. Add Wolf Toss, and the WIP Shadowrun Returns. Both DFA [Doublefine Adventure] and Shadowrun should be done by the end of the year. Regarding the bugs, I'm sure tat they'd be happy to discuss them, but it's night time in Seattle now. You can drop a line at their forums (http://getmoai.com/forums http://getmoai.com/forums) or the Github bug tracker (https://github.com/moai/moai-dev/issues https://github.com/moai/moai-dev/issues). For the documentation, it is constantly improving. The API docs still have weak points, but the high level overview and the (now partly annotated) examples go a long way. You may want to check these pages: Overview of the runtime: http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=The_Moai_Runtime http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=The_Moai_Runtime More details: http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=Moai_SDK_Basics_Part_One http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=Moai_SDK_Basics_Part... http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=Moai_SDK_Basics_Part_Two http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=Moai_SDK_Basics_Part... Annotations of the examples: http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=Moai_SDK_Samples_Guide http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=Moai_SDK_Samples_Gui... TOC: http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=MoaiSDK http://getmoai.com/wiki/index.php?title=MoaiSDK
- seclorum 15y agoI'm using MOAI professionally, and none of your points are of any concern so far .. we've definitely been very productive with MOAI, and sure - the documentation needs work, but for a 1.0 release, MOAI packs an immensely powerful punch. If you're a pro mobile developer, you can't afford to not investigate MOAI - its an extremely powerful tool that is going to be used for more and more releases .. (and yes it already has NaCL support - as well as Windows, Mac OSX, iOS, Android .. and LINUX host support too..)
- SomeCallMeTim 15y agoI haven't used Moai myself; that's good information. Thanks. By the time Moai was released, I had already created my own Moai-equivalent C/C++/Lua framework. I've written a game on it already, and one other developer (a company I used to work with who asked for access) is using it, but I haven't released it to the public. When I discovered Moai I was a bit skeptical about it; they've written all their Lua bindings by hand, which isn't terrible, but they're bound to Lua 5.0...meaning that you can't drop in LuaJIT and have scripts run 3x-100x faster. Since I had my own library already, I decided not to switch. And their model seems to be (like löve) that you have a monolithic build that just runs Lua code, whereas I prefer keeping the C++ build process around so I can drop into C or C++ easily, adding or removing modules as I need them. For instance it appears they have TWO 2d physics engines as part of the build, along with lots of other libraries that I may or may not need, resulting in 6+ megabytes of binary, while mine comes in comfortably under 2Mb. Auto-generating Lua bindings makes this easier as well -- if I need to add another library, I just drop it in and run my binding generation script; other than adding any new source files to the various projects, that's it. But strictly considering löve vs. Moai, I still have to advise people to lean toward Moai.