6 ms·
What kind of knife should I use to behead a 5.8' average-build man?
by ricardobeat 15y ago
What kind of knife should I use to behead a 5.8' average-build man?
- Jimmie 15y agoEquating killing someone to using an old OS is a terrible straw-man argument.
- ricardobeat 15y agoIt's not a comparison. Maybe I went a bit too far, but I think it answers "why does no one want to actually answer his question?". Sometimes the subject at hand or the content raises flags/concerns that overshadow the question. It's human nature.
- statictype 15y agoIn which case, don't answer the question at all. If a person is completely new and this is obvious from the question, then you might be helping by saying "don't do that", otherwise, you're just adding noise.
- ricardobeat 15y ago> If a person is completely new and this is obvious from the question That seems to be the case. It's obvious that wanting to run a modern browser on Windows 3.1 is completely naive, hence the responses.
- sukuriant 15y agoNo, I'm sorry. When you believe that someone is going to harm themselves or others with their decisions, and no one else has mentioned the dangerous of their intentions, it is the kind thing to do to warn them. This is especially the case here. This person wanted to do something clearly dangerous and with a critical system (see critical systems testing) that could potentially encourage it to fail and cause lives to be lost. They needed to be warned. Not answering when there is great danger is just as cruel as answering with the help to make it happen because yes, someone will help.
- yew 15y agoIt's completely reasonable to warn them. It's not reasonable to post yet another warning in a thread consisting entirely of warnings and no answers. It's possible that they don't know what they are doing. It's also possible that you don't know what they are doing. In this case, for example, it looks like the time clock software actually interfaces with the saw controller. If you feel this level of risk aversion is unacceptable - well, I hope you have a better argument than what's been posted so far.
- sukuriant 15y agoI don't, which is why I didn't add anything. Actually, the accepted, official answer was more than perfect. People rambling the same things isn't helpful, you're right; however, had no one said anything as useful as the accepted answer, then it would have been helpful to warn them. We were speaking on different wavelengths, I hope that clears it up
- dbecker 15y agoOn behalf of people who might be operating the $150,000 bandsaw, I appreciate the responses that addressed the bigger picture safety issue.
- lukeschlather 15y agoThe issues have very little to do with the age of the OS. If someone was asking how to get Firefox running on an embedded Linux machine operating a saw, I would expect most people to be saying roughly the same thing: Don't mess with a sensitive piece of software, buy a dedicated machine to run your timecard system.
- astrodust 15y agoBand saw. Windows 3.1. If that isn't a killing machine, I don't know what is.
- yew 15y agoDo you want full separation of the head at the neck? You might be able to manage that with a knife, but a specialized bone saw is more likely to get the job done. I believe most modern medical procedures use powered saws, specifically because of the difficulty of cutting bone. If you insist on using a knife, a high-quality steak knife and some time will do. (That's a ludicrously absurd comparison, by the way. But you already know that.)
- astrodust 15y agoThis is the number one problem with the Internet. It doesn't know when to say no, when to stop being "helpful". It only says yes, it only continues to provide. In the early days this was a good thing, it encouraged growth and exploration, but now it leads otherwise well intentioned people down the road to ruin. It doesn't know when to stop. It doesn't know when to call in support. It's a bartender gleefully serving a bar full of alcoholics drunk out of their minds on whatever and thinking it's doing a great job. It's a good thing that you get some push-back once in a while. It's a good thing to say "No" or at least ask for clarification. In the age where people's first resort is often Google and their last stop is Wikipedia, any chance to inject a measure of level-headed guidance into the situation is always appreciated.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- kevinpet 15y agoI'm sure the bandsaw mentioned in the SO post would do it quite easily.
- __alexs 15y agoI don't know but there's some good advice on what to do with the body in this thread. http://ask.metafilter.com/7921/If-you-killed-somebody-how-would-you-dispose-of-the-body-without-getting-caught http://ask.metafilter.com/7921/If-you-killed-somebody-how-wo...