3 ms·
I don't understand how the domain name has any relevance here. Are you worried that Montenegro will somehow MITM this company's credentials to steal a bunch of
by stavros 3y ago
I don't understand how the domain name has any relevance here. Are you worried that Montenegro will somehow MITM this company's credentials to steal a bunch of passport photos, or just "foreign bad"?
- Terr_ 3y agoNeither of those, although since you bring it up I'm curious how much a rogue ccTLD could substitute DNS records and produce alternate certificates to take over a domain beneath it. Rather it's about end-user security habits, their credulity of arbitrary domains, and the mental load of noticing risks. Imagine the IRS had an online payment portal, do you believe it should it be advertised as pay.irs.gov or as paymytaxes.com? (Or perhaps pay-my-taxes.com or pay.taxes.com is the real one?)
- toast0 3y ago> Neither of those, although since you bring it up I'm curious how much a rogue ccTLD could substitute DNS records and produce alternate certificates to take over a domain beneath it. The TLD can change domain records at will. Change the NS and DS records, and you control the domain. Control the domain, and you can get a certificate. If the ccTLD is sophisticated, they might carefully target the changes, but maybe not. It would be bad for business, for a TLD to become known to hijack customers' domains. But, maybe its worth it, if you can steal a bunch of US identities?
- ongy 3y ago> foreign bad Sort off. The `.gov` tld is explicitly for US gov tasks. Whether the service is trustworthy or not is a different question. Whether it makes sense to use an external service for identification is another. But if it's used for official means, they should at least get a branding contract and brand and host it properly. If only because the governance of `.gov` can and should be used to mark things official.
- concinds 3y agoYou should not have to send your personal data to foreign services in order to use government services. You don't know the retention policy, or data storage policy. Your elected representatives (supposedly) have no control over it.
- rbanffy 3y agoWhile there is little reason to assume the company is based in Montenegro, the shadiest thing is that a government is using a third party to verify identities instead of fixing the compliance issues of login.gov.