5 ms·
So apparently using this thing requires people to sign up and interview through ID.me, a private company with some controversy around facial recognition stuff a
by Terr_ 3y ago
So apparently using this thing requires people to sign up and interview through ID.me, a private company with some controversy around facial recognition stuff and a non-governmental domain in Montenegro.
There's a certain flavor of very banal insanity here, as the US government (A) tries to outsource a core competency of identifying taxpayers in its jurisdiction and (B) promotes a domain name that should instead be a bad-answer in anti-phishing security training.
- XorNot 3y agoThis isn't a US Government problem though, it's an "average voter" problem. The US Government implementing an actual form of secure ID for government use would be treated a gigantic conspiracy to do <insert already possible thing here>. But they still actually need to be able to securely identify residents, so here we are (well, and there is the victims of identity fraud due to the use of social security numbers as unique resident identifiers, a role they were never intended for).
- reaperman 3y agoCounterpoint: https://login.gov/ https://login.gov/
- easton 3y agoWhich actually has an identity verification component: https://login.gov/partners/our-services/#verified-identity-and-authentication https://login.gov/partners/our-services/#verified-identity-a...
- c0pium 3y agoThat’s a federated IDP which can be used to access your identity instead of using your social security number. It doesn’t replace the fact that your social security number is still your username and password in the canonical identity system, which is the problem GP is talking about. Edit: or if you prefer, your SSN is both your user record locator and user secret.
- GoblinSlayer 3y agoThe cause of identity fraud is lack of authentication, not existence of SSN. It's equivalent to going to a bank and telling "I'm Elon Musk, give me my money" and then complain that we must eliminate names to prevent this kind of fraud.
- c0pium 3y agoThat’s what I said, just less precisely. The system is as secure as the least secure auth mechanism, the existence of better ones is irrelevant.
- Terr_ 3y agoThat political concern is real, but it wouldn't block them from at least white-labeling the private service though an *.irs.gov domain.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 3y agoBut does the *Federal* gov have to ID citizens? Why can't that be the responsiblity of the states? We keep assuming that a massive top-heavy and easily corruptable Fed gov is the only option. It's not. We're getting what we're getting becuase we're keep buying the ruse, the status quo, instead of insisting on a system that protects us in the way the founding documents intend.
- pjc50 3y agoI've never understood the US belief that the states are less corruptible than the Federal government when the opposite seems to prevail in many places, and local government seems to be even worse.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoNo one said the odds of corruption are less. But when everything is top heavy and centralized, the economies of scale for corruption are much better. That is, for example, buy off a single Fed official vs buy off 50 similar officials at the state level. And if someone tries that and one state gets exposed that's a red flag for all the other states to check their shit. States are the equivalent of a diversified stock portfolio. The Fed gov is like betting it all on Enron.
- toast0 3y agoIt's a lot easier to escape state corruption than federal corruption. If I don't like how my state maintains its affairs, I can move to one of the other 49 states (or territories) with relative ease. If I don't like how the US maintains its affairs, I have to convince another country to accept me, and as a US citizen, I've still got a US paperwork burden unless I renounce citizenship (which isn't easy either).
- lupire 3y agoWe certainly could run Federal taxes through States (mandate states to assess and tax income, use the Feds only to investigate states, not investigate individuals), but that requires an attitude of anti-Federalism that is too pedantic for the average government official or citizen who only has headspace for or "government", and is opposed by the modern Federalists who favor a stronger union (intentional power, less civil war) over general independence and local control. anti-Federalists lose because the governments they build are structurally weaker than Federalist. Similar to how the extreme end of Anti-Federalism, "we don't need laws; everyone should just be nice" is a failed model for practical government.
- stavros 3y agoI don't understand how the domain name has any relevance here. Are you worried that Montenegro will somehow MITM this company's credentials to steal a bunch of passport photos, or just "foreign bad"?
- Terr_ 3y agoNeither of those, although since you bring it up I'm curious how much a rogue ccTLD could substitute DNS records and produce alternate certificates to take over a domain beneath it. Rather it's about end-user security habits, their credulity of arbitrary domains, and the mental load of noticing risks. Imagine the IRS had an online payment portal, do you believe it should it be advertised as pay.irs.gov or as paymytaxes.com? (Or perhaps pay-my-taxes.com or pay.taxes.com is the real one?)
- toast0 3y ago> Neither of those, although since you bring it up I'm curious how much a rogue ccTLD could substitute DNS records and produce alternate certificates to take over a domain beneath it. The TLD can change domain records at will. Change the NS and DS records, and you control the domain. Control the domain, and you can get a certificate. If the ccTLD is sophisticated, they might carefully target the changes, but maybe not. It would be bad for business, for a TLD to become known to hijack customers' domains. But, maybe its worth it, if you can steal a bunch of US identities?
- ongy 3y ago> foreign bad Sort off. The `.gov` tld is explicitly for US gov tasks. Whether the service is trustworthy or not is a different question. Whether it makes sense to use an external service for identification is another. But if it's used for official means, they should at least get a branding contract and brand and host it properly. If only because the governance of `.gov` can and should be used to mark things official.
- concinds 3y agoYou should not have to send your personal data to foreign services in order to use government services. You don't know the retention policy, or data storage policy. Your elected representatives (supposedly) have no control over it.
- ergonaught 3y agoI have a couple of years of emails from the SBA which are, effectively, completely indistinguishable from phishing attacks. They use URL shorteners with weird (unrelated to .gov) domains, they never reference anything that demonstrates familiarity with my actual identity, every single URL passes through a tracker (again unrelated to .gov), etc. It's all just broken.
- dangus 3y agoIt also seems weird since the US government runs login.gov
- tomrod 3y agoApparently login.gov doesn't have the right security process in place to meet the right CISA standard (paraphrasing). So instead of funding it, we continue issuing 95% of maintenance funding each boxing round between showboating legislators issuing continuing resolutions.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoLogin.gov does not provide a sufficient level of identity assurance (IAL2 [1]) to serve as the IDP for this pilot and IRS functions in general (ID.me liveness check and facial recognition). IRS is working with Login.gov to upgrade Login.gov to deprecate ID.me for this purpose [2] [3]. Would it make sense to not proceed with this pilot until this was ready? Certainly not; Login.gov will catch up and meet IRS in the future as Direct File expands next filing season. Very similar to when Social Security Administration (ssa.gov) transitioned from ID.me and their internal IDP to Login.gov on September 18, 2021 [4]. (Login.gov partners with USPS to perform in person identity proofing for those who cannot perform remote proofing via a mobile device; a bar code is generated, which you print out or display on a mobile device for presentation to a USPS clerk with a government credential) [1] https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3-Implementation-Resources/63A/ial2remote/ https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3-Implementation-Resources/63A... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30430851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30430851 [3] https://fedscoop.com/irs-to-adopt-login-gov-as-user-authentication-tool/ https://fedscoop.com/irs-to-adopt-login-gov-as-user-authenti... [4] https://faq.ssa.gov/en-US/Topic/article/KA-03217 https://faq.ssa.gov/en-US/Topic/article/KA-03217
- revlolz 3y agoI hate Id.me. I had an interview with them and their hr reps conducting were the most egregious power tripping fools I've met in my career. In their hubris they demanded several hours of psychology testing for a basic, mid level tech role, paying right below market average. They harrased me for two weeks after I had the audacity to tell them "no thank you, I'm not wasting my time."