5 ms·
It’s Balkanizing. Every community ends up having a general other chat channel and we’ve made all these small tiny islands for that general chat channel to be in
by fragmede 3y ago
It’s Balkanizing. Every community ends up having a general other chat channel and we’ve made all these small tiny islands for that general chat channel to be in. That’s what we’re losing. The hacker Slack that I’m in the Lisp enthusiasts group, the factorial discord. All those general chats are in their own tiny little islands instead of being in a bigger, wider world. That’s what’s changing. We’ve got these small private secret tiny islands and that’s great. I love them and protect mine and nobody’s allowed in unless you know someone. Is that the way it’s supposed to be? Because there are marauders out there that are just going to come in as bots and mine it for content if it’s not protected. We’ve lost the earnest here I am, out in the world sort of feeling, to be replaced by like oh, there’s a wild world out there and we better protect and put up a wall to protect the world around us.
- Dalewyn 3y agoIRC is like that, the command line nature rather violently excludes all the noise from the signal such that those who still use it today are usually worth chatting with.
- Forgeties79 3y agoI can tell you right now I’m going to be chewing on this comment for a few days. I think you’re really striking at the heart of a major issue here.
- swagasaurus-rex 3y agoI see several converging factors 1) It’s impossible to distinguish between human and AI. Breaking a captcha is a resume building weekend project for any dedicated hacker. 2) The turing test has thoroughly been solved. There’s already a trend of accounts on reddit that reply with helpful but obviously ai generated content to farm reputation. 3) Spam and troll content is still an unsolved problem that requires a dedicated team to solve. 4) Communities themselves can be hostile, especially when the majority adopt black and white thinking. 5) Vetting new accounts is mostly done by verifying email or phone, and doesn’t filter out bad actors. Some of these problems are solvable. The AI ones seem like a tall hurdle. There are some verification methods like video that AI struggles to replicate but it will soon be intractable to distinguish between human and AI online.
- red-iron-pine 3y ago> 4) Communities themselves can be hostile, especially when the majority adopt black and white thinking. many of these communities will inevitably fall into that thinking, even when they start out as a more open forum, due to selection bias, us-vs-them / in-group-out-group, and a tendency for more controversial, angry, or loud posts to get more views.
- fragmede 3y agoAnd even if I’ve met someone briefly, who’s to say they haven’t wired a bot into slack to speak for them? At what point does it cross the line? I fully admit to using ChatGPT to help organize my thinking, but that seems benign compared to wiring up a bot and have it fully shitposting as me.
- fragmede 3y ago5) vetting new accounts for some of the more private communities is invite only, so you’ve got to know somebody. Limits the growth but makes sure there are no bots.