3 ms·
RAND has been in the consensus prediction business since .. well.. RAND was a thing. This is pretty much normal. It's just that it carries on under the surface
by ggm 3y ago
RAND has been in the consensus prediction business since .. well.. RAND was a thing.
This is pretty much normal. It's just that it carries on under the surface, most people are unaware where "sources state that there is a 20% chance of .." comments from the military-strategic orbit come from.
These % figures aren't very meaningful. I personally think they are mis-read more than they are understood. I would not cross the road on a 1 in 10 chance of death. I undertake activity which at least formally has a 1 in 100 chance of negative outcome frequently, and most of us do 1 in 1000 or upward without thinking about it.
The Anti-Vax Phobics were rioting on a 1 in 100,000 risk issue.
I tend to think China-Taiwan by 2030 is in the 5% bucket as well for a number of reasons. Principally, the join over news stating the Chinese Military is massively corrupt, and there are generals weeding out over-claimed capacity, the lack of visible improvement in their naval fleet beyond one Aircraft carrier, and the massive bright red wave of blood which will stem from an opposed landing from sea, in modern warfare. Blood is a remarkable thing, in terms of it's influence on the people at large. China is not Russia, they are nothing like as fatalist about their sons and daughters. An occupation of Taiwan will incur massive loss in the generation which is the one-child policy outcome: Many chinese families will lose their investment in the future. Not to mention the missiles coming back the other way will make this invasion a weapon with two sides, one of which faces coastal investment on the mainland.
That and the highly internally facing quality of the rhetoric: Talking up Taiwan is seasonal politics as people jockey for control of the structures. It's not preparatory to invasion.
- rufus_foreman 3y ago>> China is not Russia, they are nothing like as fatalist about their sons and daughters What is your evidence for this claim? How many people needlessly died due to Chinese communism? Maybe 50,000,000? All sacrificed to an ideology. What has happened before can happen again.
- wolverine876 3y agoAlso, at least the histories I've read say the Chinese Communists used 'human wave' tactics in the Korean War.
- wolverine876 3y ago> the lack of visible improvement in their naval fleet beyond one Aircraft carrier Their fleet is expanding rapidly. Usually the discussion from experts is about how quickly China's naval power is growing. China happens to have two carriers now, and one more under construction. Regarding aircraft carriers: China doesn't need an aircraft carrier for Taiwan, which is ~100 miles off the mainland; air force bases on the mainland work much better. Also, the relevance of aircraft carriers to high-end warfare is now in doubt: Accurate anti-ship missiles can hit carriers at much greater range than carrier planes can attack. China in particular has spent decades building a military that keeps US carriers too far from Taiwan to join the fight. Generally, carriers may only be good for symbols of power (perhaps China's purpose for building a couple) and against less capable enemies - the Houthi's, for example, not China. They also enable you to have an airbase without local permission - if the US wants to bomb Somalia (as they currently are doing), and nobody nearby wants to be involved and let the US use their airbases, the US can put a carrier in international waters. It's a floating, mobile bit of domestic territory. > That and the highly internally facing quality of the rhetoric: Talking up Taiwan is seasonal politics as people jockey for control of the structures. It's not preparatory to invasion. Such talk can create a movement that takes on a life of its own; wars have been fought because someone inflamed the population and the leaders had no choice (or, being human, were inflamed themselves). One way to look at it is that such talk increases public support for war.
- Vecr 3y agoCloser to 1/5000 for the vaccine thing, depending on the sub-population.