3 ms·
>I think TFA's most-useful observation is a throwaway: "but you could probably get away with just picking old men for the job." Yes - just choose astronauts tha
by dylan604 3y ago
>I think TFA's most-useful observation is a throwaway: "but you could probably get away with just picking old men for the job." Yes - just choose astronauts that aren't expected to live very long anyway. As a bonus, that makes it less important to figure out how to get them back.
Why is this deemed as such a negative that people won't be coming back? Is it strictly fear of negative PR? I get that if an unscheduled rapid disassembly happens, that people get upset. However, if it is a part of the original plan that the first people will not be coming back, but instead become permanent resident aliens on Mars, then why is the negative PR being attached? People left their land to never return but settle and establish new places to live through out history, yet no negative PR was associated. Why now about Mars?
- virgildotcodes 3y agoThere’s something very alien about dying on an inhospitable, dead, cold world millions of miles away from all that humanity has ever known. I find it hard to believe that we’d be able to find a sizable group of people who wanted this to be their fate and who were actually otherwise qualified for the mission. Imagine the nightmare scenario of someone changing their mind partway through the mission. Talk about a disaster (PR and otherwise) that could be significant enough to chill the entire push for manned missions beyond the moon.
- dylan604 3y ago> I find it hard to believe that we’d be able to find a sizable group of people who wanted this How do you think the Americas were settled by Europeans? These people decided that whatever their fate, it would be worth making the attempt. That's just the most recent, but history is clearly full of a group of people deciding that the horizon demanded to be investigated. Otherwise, we'd all just be massed together in what ever the current belief on where humans started is at the moment. The call of the wild, the sense of adventure, exploration, or whatever you want to call it is part of human nature. > Imagine the nightmare scenario of someone changing their mind partway through the mission Yeah? And? So? You think people moving from Europe to the colonies didn't get cold feet? Hell, as times get hard, it's only natural to wonder WTF you made this decision. Those people will probably be culled from the herd so to speak. It's only a PR disaster because people like you sound like without the sense of adventure and too meek to do anything other than leave their house for work. Just because someone else is much more bold than you does not mean that you should prevent them from doing it because you might feel uncomfortable upon hearing about something.
- nemomarx 3y agoin those cases, people expected to live there, settle and have children, etc Which seems very unrealistic for the first stage trip to Mars? you'd need several waves to even have enough material there to be livable for more than a year. No one moves to the south pole without a plan to go back, for instance.
- dylan604 3y ago> in those cases, people expected to live there, settle and have children, etc exactly. These people are choosing to go to Mars without expecting to come back. If they die of old age or catastrophic failure doesn't matter. They willingly had no intent of coming back. So the cheeky comments about only send "old" to Mars is not totally out of line. Just remove the age constraint, and make it people willing to take a one way trip. There are people right now willing to do it. It totally changes the agenda. If we can just plan on making long term remote isolated bases, then we just focus on that. But it takes the same amount of effort to survive on the surface for short stays that then require the extra effort of returning. So I'm saying we're wasting effort on the first stages including the return. Let the people willing to relocate do it, establish a foot hold so that the "weekenders" can come visit if that's something that is still felt as a need.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> Let the people willing to relocate do it Well, sure. As long as they don't cause serious environmental and safety problems while they do it. But that's obviously a personal choice; it's absurd to expect the public finances to support the project. If they want to make money out of weekender tourists, then presumably they are making some kid of business plan; I'm fine with them losing all their money.
- chrisfosterelli 3y agoI feel like your analogy conflates early explorers (who definitely intended to go home unless something went wrong) with early settlers (who did not). I feel like Mars is very much in the "explorer" phase more than the "early settlers" phase.
- chrisfosterelli 3y agoBecause people imagine most quintessential heros to dream of exploring but also dream of coming back to their friends and families at the end of it.