6 ms·
The Epson HX-20 – A Contrarian's View (2021)
- aidenn0 3y agoIt seems like it would have been easy to use as a battery-powered POS terminal, with just some simple BASIC software. That might not have been sufficiently better than a mechanical cash register or a carbonless-copy receipt pad though to justify it.
- spiderxxxx 3y agoYou'd think so, but I can't find anyone had actually been using it as such. Since it can read and write tapes, it seems it would be perfectly suited to running a retail store's day to day business. The barcode scanner and some basic database software would have probably sold like hotcakes as a portable POS system.
- aidenn0 3y agoWere there barcode scanners that were efficient enough to be battery-operated in 1981?
- kalleboo 3y agoLooks like there was one you had to swipe over the barcode, likely just a single CCD type device https://computarium.lcd.lu/photos/albums/EPSON_HX20/album/slides/DSC03181.html https://computarium.lcd.lu/photos/albums/EPSON_HX20/album/sl...
- rbanffy 3y agoThe printer is very slow, one line at a time. It would not be great as a POS terminal, but it could connect to a serial printer over RS-232 and external disks and a screen via the other TTL-level 36400 bps port.
- internet101010 3y agoEpson is one of those companies that creates a solid product and just lets it ride. Like their V600 scanner has been $250-350 for its entire lifetime and is still the best on the market; it came out in 2009.
- throw_pm23 3y agoI remember my family having bought a PC and an Epson printer sometime in the 1990s. Both were roughly in the ~$1000 range. Almost a decade later we considered selling the computer for ~$50, and gave it away instead. We sold the printer for about the same price we bought it. (It was a type of printer that was in demand as small companies could print invoices and receipts with it). EDIT: I checked the model and incredibly it is still sold, between $300-$1000 on ebay, etc.
- buildbot 3y agoScanners are also a tech that has pretty much plateaued - correct me if I am wrong, but the linear arrays are fairly cheap and the resolution is a product of the linear array and the minimum step size, and steppers have not gotten much better. There are 2x+ more dense linear arrays than the v600 has that exist, but that only would improve one dimension of the resolution. Also, the v600 is a great consumer scanner, but OH BOY can you get more fancy, for film you have the hasselblad/imacon line that are still a few thousand used, then you have drum scanners for the highest possible film scanning quality. For a more direct v600 comparison, there is this really, really old scanner that outperforms it: https://www.scansolutionsonline.com/media/1168/cezanne-elite-brochure.pdf https://www.scansolutionsonline.com/media/1168/cezanne-elite... A more modern flatbed scanner: https://epson.com/For-Work/Scanners/Photo-and-Graphics/Epson-Expression-13000XL-Archival-Scanner/p/B11B257201 https://epson.com/For-Work/Scanners/Photo-and-Graphics/Epson... Sadly lower res than what used to be out there.
- fmajid 3y agoThe Imacon Flextight has been discontinued for a while now. Flatbed scannners are stagnant because there isn't enough demand to drive investment. Sheet-fed document scanners are still lively, but quality has gone down, my 2010 vintage ScanSnap S1500M has a high-quality CCD sensor, but newer models are almost invariably CIS with much lower color fidelity for scanning artwork. High-quality XY prepress scanners like the Cézanne you mention, or prepress leaders like Fuji Lanovia, Creo-Scitex are also discontinued since the industry's gone fully digital and doesn't expect to scan medium-format slides any more. No wonder Gen-Z finds scanners exotic and terrifying: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/feb/27/gen-z-tech-shame-office-technology-printers https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/feb/27/gen-z-tec... The only actively produced scanner that can outperform the V600 is Epson's V850.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoI have one, funnily it was from the German military that used it for artillery calcularions.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWho said there's no digitalization in Germany?
- bballard 3y agoAs a forward observer once radioed to artillery during WWII, "Stop computing and start shooting!"
- helpfulContrib 3y agoIts really nice that the language of that era still informs and inspires designers today. I have a small collection of ClockworkPi toys, most recently a couple of uConsole's, and they are delightful reminders of an aesthetic that still lingers on, in the minds of those raised on computers-as-life. The cyberdeck guys are going to continue this, I just know it. I hope we see an Epson HX-20-esque re-imagining of the ClockworkPi somewhere along the line ..
- surteen 3y agoThe later Epson PX-8 has a much more usable screen in a similar form factor.
- sleepybrett 3y agoThe DevTerm is their closest form factor imo https://www.clockworkpi.com/home-devterm https://www.clockworkpi.com/home-devterm. I bought one for kicks, the keyboard kinda sucks but the built in receipt style printer is badass. The uClonsole also looks pretty sweet.
- spiderxxxx 3y agoIf there was a devterm with a 80% keyboard I'd gladly buy it, but that tiny keyboard on it makes it a no from me.
- rbanffy 3y agoI’d LOVE a Devterm the same size as the TRS-80 model 100 or the HX-20. Would get it immediately.
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- somat 3y agoA question I have about this era of of computing. Why did DOS win? BASIC, for all it's faults, would have been a much nicer shell environment than the extremely limited CPM/DOS syntax. From this modern perspective I would have guessed at the time that BASIC would have grown better file management operations and been the home computers equivalent to the unix shell. that is, not a great programing language but let you run commands and easily, using the same language, program them. Instead the primitive(in comparison to BASIC syntax) CPM command interrupter and moreso Microsofts "we have CPM at home" DOS syntax won the home computer market. why? every computer in that critical 1981 lineup, including the IBM PC, had a BASIC rom.
- snakeyjake 3y agoThis may come as a shock to someone reading HN, but approximately 0.0% (rounded) of all people care about shell programming. Whatever gets programs to run the easiest wins. DOS was easier than BASIC. Hell, I had been using computers for well over a decade to accomplish tasks when they plopped me down in front of a Sun SPARCStation 5 and someone mentioned that the Bourne Shell could automate a bunch of the stuff I was doing.
- groby_b 3y agoBecause BASIC is a programming language (and was included with DOS, cf MS BASIC) DOS won because it offered a consistent way to manage your files and applications, it was "better" than CPM, and it was available on more machines than anything else. (DOS didn't win. The PC won. DOS tagged along) It's worth noting that it didn't, for a long time, "win" the home computer market. That was wildly diverse, until PCs were good & cheap enough to replace home computers. And at that point, sheer prevalence started squeezing out home machines. That world ended, more or less, with the Atari ST and the Amiga 500 - because both of those were great, and both were niche tools. PCs were the thing that you could use for games and work stuff. It turns out "getting stuff done" matters much more to people than engaging in purity debates. (Also relevant in this context: https://www.dreamsongs.com/RiseOfWorseIsBetter.html https://www.dreamsongs.com/RiseOfWorseIsBetter.html)
- AkBKukU 3y agoI am deeply steeped in the history of computers and the biggest three things I can point to as the reason (MS-)DOS won are: - Licensing: Most computers either had custom operating systems that were not shared with other hardware vendors, or in the case of BASIC frequently, were licensed themselves. - IBM letting the genie out: The BIOS on the IBM PC 5150 was cloned, quickly and legally, and other companies started making compatibles. This caused an explosion of computer variety in a few short years for a single platform. - Microsoft: DOS usually means "Microsoft DOS", Microsoft also was responsible for many of the BASIC environments of early systems as well. The ability to buy your OS from someone else lowered the pressure on hardware makers. IBM also favoured Micorsoft's DOS over CP/M-86 and stopped supporting it quickly. All this meant the PC compatible ecosystem with Microsoft DOS became easy to make from a hardware side, and lacked a single point of failure like Apple, Radio Shack, Commodore. Atari, etc. There were other MS-DOS compatible DOS's out there, but MS-DOS was usually the one shipped with computers to be as "IBM compatible" as they possibly could and gained dominance through that. EDIT: To those who may not be aware, BASIC did become more OS like before going away. HP BASIC was extremely feature packed before HP-UX replaced it and was more capable than MS-DOS in many ways. It evolved far beyond just a programming language.
- microtherion 3y agoMy first sizable programming job in high school was with one of these, I think. A special education teacher had written an app to create a Blissymbolics <https://www.blissymbolics.org https://www.blissymbolics.org> communicator and hired me to tune it up, because some of his more prolific students had mastered more symbols than the app could readily handle. I spent quite some time with the machine, and felt it was fairly capable for the time (my reference being CBM a.k.a. PET desktops).
- deldelaney 3y agoYep cool, but the tiny screen was ridiculous and hard see, let alone sell.
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoThis is a weird take - dunking on a product from more than forty years ago because it doesn't have modern ease of use. It's like complaining a 1990s dumb phone wasn't an iPhone, or that a 1920s string and canvas biplane wasn't a 1960s SR-71. Yes, obviously, but why would anyone expect that?
- throwme_123 3y agoIndeed, another instance of presentism...
- TMWNN 3y ago>This is a weird take - dunking on a product from more than forty years ago because it doesn't have modern ease of use. Oh, good grief. The author repeatedly discusses the limitations of the product as they would have been seen by someone today and 40 years ago.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- squarefoot 3y ago"... the charging circuit is, to put it mildly, primitive. There is no charging indicator. Nor is there a sign that the batteries are fully charged. The HX-20 manual states that empty batteries should be put on charge for 8 hours. Leaving them longer risks damaging them, but without any way to tell that they are full there is no way to be sure you’ve timed it right. " This is normal for NiCd and later NiMH batteries. They're recharged applying regulated (ideally constant) current for a given time, and it's impossible to get a figure of their charge status just by sampling their voltage like with Lithium cells, which are dangerous indeed if abused, still much much easier to recharge. The only known ways to check those cells status are to either continuously sample the energy put in, or to intercept the so called delta V and delta T, a very slight (millivolts) decrease in cell voltage near the end of charge, paired with an increase of temperature which indicates the cell can't store more energy. This becomes even more difficult with battery packs, and makes measuring their status very hard when charging, and completely impossible if kept in use at the same time. Many portable safety anti-blackout lamps from the 70s to the 90s used NiCd and NiMH batteries, and many of them broke after some time because they kept their batteries under constant charge.
- jhallenworld 3y agoI used one long ago: I remember that, as with the TRS-80 model 100, the keyboard was outstanding.
- TMWNN 3y agoThe HX-20 lost while the Tandy Model 100 won, because the latter found a real market: Journalists and others who wanted to write on the road. The former's screen isn't large enough for writing despite the good keyboard, and vertical markets where the screen size didn't matter as much weren't large enough to drive HX-20 sales. BYTE's review explains this. <https://archive.org/stream/byte-magazine-1983-09/1983_09_BYTE_08-09_Portable_Computers_in_Depth#page/n201/mode/2up https://archive.org/stream/byte-magazine-1983-09/1983_09_BYT...>
- guenthert 3y ago"For a start, Epson insists that it must only be run from batteries" I don't think that's correct. I had one handed down to me in the early nineties. Afair (well, it's a long time), I operated it w/o batteries at all.