5 ms·
Rethinking my economics
- defrost 3y ago[flagged]
- sheepscreek 3y agoNice way to sum up capitalism: it is about the consolidation of power. Money also corrupts power, thereby reinforcing the consolidation of power - a way to preserve self-interests. The prime example of this is: political lobbying and funding of super-PACs by corporations. The regular people (read: not executives, social, political or tech elites) suffer.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- defrost 3y agoFrom the Crikey coverage: What’s extraordinary is that a Nobel Laureate economist has only achieved this realisation so late in his career. Anyone with practical experience of policymaking, or with training as a historian, or even someone who has worked as a lobbyist or consultant, has a grasp of what Deaton has only belatedly realised: modern capitalism, particularly in its neoliberal form that disempowers governments and rivals like trade unions, is about the use of power by corporations to “change the rules of the game”, to increase certainty for themselves and reduce it for competitors, workers and consumers. It speaks volumes about how sheltered many mainstream academic economists really are.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rawgabbit 3y agoNice. It sums up the rage and populism in American politics. The political elite will ignore it of course and will continue to push a program of platitudes and nonsense. An excerpt: I am much more skeptical of the benefits of free trade to American workers and am even skeptical of the claim, which I and others have made in the past, that globalization was responsible for the vast reduction in global poverty over the past 30 years. I also no longer defend the idea that the harm done to working Americans by globalization was a reasonable price to pay for global poverty reduction because workers in America are so much better off than the global poor.
- gonzo41 3y agoThere's so much institutional inertia to these things. Globalization didn't just happen. People pushed for it for years. I find it a bit trite that economists can write these self indulgent essays and don't recognize the outsized impact they have had on society. I appreciate the change or heart. But the impacts on people have been so great it would be more of a gesture if this person took all their wealth, put it in a pile, burned it, and then walked into the ocean. This is someone who got to have their cake, Whole career built on a fad, and eat it too, ie be fawned upon with esteem due to a regretful essay in their winter years. We're going to see more of this stuff, and next it'll be Big Oil execs regretting their career and then doing nothing about the problem.
- boringuser2 3y agoAnother facet to it is that most disciplines where you can just about-face all of your established core theses is generally called "pseudoscience".
- boringuser2 3y agoOne thing that absolutely savages my mind is the fact that those on the nominal left-wing have abandoned this obvious truth and focused on an ideology that benefits some sort of global majority versus their own theoretical constituents. The perfect example is Bernie Sanders going from "immigration is obviously bad because its a tool capitalist's use to undercut American labor" to generic racial grievance "progressive" guy.
- fallingfrog 3y agoI feel like you’re confusing free movement of goods/capital with free movement of people. The two can have different policies applied to them. It’s a bit silly to use “globalization” to mean both.
- boringuser2 3y agoI'm not confusing anything, so your comment ended up being useless noise.
- fastball 3y agoThis is many words to say something fairly simple: microeconomics is a science (/math), macroeconomics is mostly voodoo that macroeconomists pretend is science and for which they give each other bogus awards. Maybe one day we will have the ability to properly model the incredible complexity of a macroeconomic environment, but doing so requires encapsulating thousands (if not millions) of variables and we are not there yet. You cannot simplify anything at the macroeconomic-level to an equation or theorem with a handful of variables or concepts, which macroeconomists want to do. Said another way: macroeconomics is a social science, and like psychology or similar, most of the output of this discipline has piss-poor predictive quality and has an abysmal track record when it comes to reproducibility.
- AmericanChopper 3y agoHe’s simply rediscovered Hayak’s central grievance with Keynes, but somehow made the leap to placing the blame for this with corporations, rather than the actual governors of macroeconomics, central banks…
- hayst4ck 3y agoIf anyone wants a fun quick summary of Hayek this throwback to the 2008 crisis is an easily consumed primer on Keynes vs Hayek: Keynes vs Hayek rap battle 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0nERTFo-Sk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0nERTFo-Sk Keynes vs Hayek rap battle 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GTQnarzmTOc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GTQnarzmTOc
- SantalBlush 3y ago>You cannot simplify anything at the macroeconomic-level to an equation or theorem with a handful of variables or concepts, which macroeconomists want to do. They do this in a 101 class. They absolutely do not use "a handful of variables or concepts" when they're setting policy.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoWho is "they" and what policy are you referring to? Folks at central banks setting monetary policy? Advisors/elected officials who decide fiscal policy? Regulators at various agencies deciding regulatory policy? Something else?
- tootie 3y agoThis seems a bit more personal than academic. I don't think there was ever a consensus that unions were bad. Not for the sake of capitalism. And I'm not sure how he equates reduced immigration with reduced inequality without controlling for a zillion other variables that were happening at the time. And I'm not really sure any of this stuff was ever really dogma among the academic circles. The benefits of free trade were generally accepted as prevailing wisdom and sold as a panacea by politicians, but no serious economist would refuse to accept new data when it was available.
- WalterBright 3y agoThere is nothing inherently wrong with unions. The trouble comes when they are given power that goes beyond market forces. It's the same problem as when the government gives monopoly protection to a corporation.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoThis isn't talked about enough. It would be interesting to see unions play out in the modern world with pure market forces.
- bawolff 3y ago"Savages" feels like overkill (at least he didn't "slam"), i honestly don't find this very compelling. The second half more or less just lists some currently popular views. There is very little argument for them. They might very well be right, but whether they are right or not isn't so interesting as why they might be right or wrong. The most compelling part i think was the argument that power's distorting effect on markets is not well enough understood. That seems plausible to me (albeit i am definitely not an expert in this field) and also seems like a direction for future study. I disagree with the morality point because i think that understanding how something works is entirely different than understanding what we should do about it, but we can't know what to do without understanding the how. Thus we need people to study the how separately from the moral component in order to be moral.
- orochimaaru 3y agoKrugman, another one of the economists who was a staunch supporter (if not the initiator) of the globalization doctrine has backtracked on it since 2019. He hasn’t been as vociferous as Deaton though. Giving away manufacturing is like handing over the keys to your war machine to someone else. The ONLY thing the US has going for it now is the dollar. However, given our behavior on freezing Russian funds and weaponizing it countries will look elsewhere. There are no alternatives - yet. But when one begins to emerges it will cause the next world war. Interestingly the conservatives who complain about fiscal imbalance should embrace a neutral currency. It will force the US to balance its books. The implications to workers over the years has been horrendous with whole industries being decommissioned across the United State, especially in poor rural areas. And you wonder why they look towards Trump. Well, it’s because the mainstream has been lying for a long time. What doesn’t get enough attention is the impact to national security. This level of outsourcing and hollowing out of US industry is going to take a long time to rebuild. In the meantime - battle readiness suffers which in turn will bring challenges to the USD.
- mistermann 3y ago> The ONLY thing the US has going for it now is the dollar - most powerful war machine - most powerful propaganda machine (international and domestic) - genuinely powerful economy - best geopolitical "alliances" (see above) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full-spectrum_dominance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full-spectrum_dominance --> https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_warfare https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_warfare
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoIt’s not how many weapons you have at the beginning of the war that counts. It’s how many you can make during the war that matters. We can’t even build aircraft carriers that can launch more than two aircraft every 30 minutes, and that before we talk about how carriers may be useless already.
- hayst4ck 3y ago> - most powerful propaganda machine (international and domestic) This is clearly false given the previous presidency. Russia's ability to project chaos and authoritarianism vastly exceeds our own. Additionally our rhetoric (rules based international order) is clearly false given that our observable stance is rules for our enemies but not our "allies". We have been shown to be bad faith actors geopolitically. Xi's geopolitics is winning in many places. Domestically we are divided and conquered. You don't have to take that from me. You can look up what Mattis and Milley have to say on the state of American "unity". The constitution is overthrown by an openly corrupt judicial junta and the idea of things like Civil War and Texxit (the balkanization of America) are becoming less fringe every day. We literally had an attempted coup that most of the people who the coup was against are either completely impotent against or literally in denial about. That is deep political instability and chaos for enemies to abuse. > - genuinely powerful economy Our economy is not powerful. Our financing is powerful. Our economy looks powerful because the US Dollar is the worlds reserve currency, something China and Russia are working very hard to chip away at. In a war, financing takes a back seat to actual ability to produce. America's economy is built on intangibles. A powerful economy can make medical masks and bullets when they need to. That's not us. Inflation is barely managed, and "greed"flation, which is inversely proportional to a markets competitive forces, is definitely un-managed. > - most powerful war machine And yet our war machines strength is being tested. Ukraine is stalling. Inability to provide bullets is a clear indicator our war machine is weak. Ironically China is showing to have the superior war machine given the success of consumer drones. It's worth considering how much of an effect sanctions did not have. I don't think we have any kind of reputation for efficiently and quickly building any kind of infrastructure. 60 days for an ocean based logistics port? The Afghanistan exit wasn't exactly confidence building. > - best geopolitical "alliances" (see above) Half of our government is promising obstruction and isolationism. "America first" is not something countries in a functioning alliance say. The Nord Stream pipeline isn't something allies build. A president was impeached over how they interacted with an "ally" and then protected despite their abuse. The US is a paper tiger. America is imploding from the inside.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe opposite of globalization is protectionism. Protectionism is when a country embargoes itself. How can it be that we punish other countries with embargoes if protectionism makes a country more prosperous?
- monitron 3y agoI know nearly nothing about this field and yet at least one big reason is obvious to me: A country set up for global trade is not ready to lose access to that trade. They depend on things not produced locally, and depend on the proceeds of exporting things they produce in surplus. It would take decades to adapt by returning to a self-sufficient economy. And some goods (phones, for instance) could barely exist without global trade, so an embargoed country will lose access to those things inevitably.
- danielmarkbruce 3y agoDepends on the country. Some countries are heavily dependent on other countries for basic needs like energy. Some, not so much. Some countries are heavily dependent on other countries to buy their labor, others not so much.
- dang 3y agoThe submitted title was "Nobel laureate economist savages his own profession" - that's against the HN guidelines, which ask: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). I've reverted it now. If you want to say what you think is important about an article, that's fine, but do it by adding a comment to the thread. Then your view will be on a level playing field with everyone else's: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22level%20playing%20field%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
- defrost 3y agoFair point, there was dithering about the link, whether the essay as primary or the commentary on the essay - I split the difference & went half & half and pointed that out in a comment to clarify. The essay itself is interesting, the commentary that frames it as a break from usual economist behaviour gives a background that adds. I've zero interest in self elevation and I heed your notes, it's always tricky when there's both an interesting source and and interesting take on that source.
- dang 3y agoNo problem! I appreciate the reply.
- barnabyjones 3y ago>And poverty reduction in China could have happened with less damage to workers in rich countries if Chinese policies caused it to save less of its national income, allowing more of its manufacturing growth to be absorbed at home. Isn't it more relevant to look at the individual savings vs. investment of the countries which were "damaged," and the policies which encouraged that? I also don't see how that's an argument against free trade, putting up barriers to trade wouldn't encourage saving.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]