3 ms·
I think it is very strange how politicized the topic is in the USA, and the level of interest. I think many Americans see it as symbolic of their own personal p
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
I think it is very strange how politicized the topic is in the USA, and the level of interest. I think many Americans see it as symbolic of their own personal political pet interests.
Brits should either suffer for the illiberal hubris, or are noble for defying tyranny.
Few of the terminally online take the position that it is simply a British issue to determine what they want, and wish them the best in sorting it out.
- tivert 3y ago> I think many Americans see it as symbolic of their own personal political pet interests. I don't know if it's true of other nationalities, but Americans definitely project their domestic politics onto foreign conflicts and controversies that they know nothing about, and then very strongly take sides (e.g. viewing Israel/Palestine as something close to American racial politics with funny accents).
- s1artibartfast 3y agoAgreed, I just find it interesting how intense the projection is, and also how superficial.
- tivert 3y ago> Agreed, I just find it interesting how intense the projection is, and also how superficial. I think it's because they're basically "casting" some foreign faction into a domestic political role. The Remain faction are the "Democrats" of Brexit, the Russians are the "MAGA Republicans" of the Ukraine war, the Israelis are the "white people" of the Israel/Palestine conflict, etc.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI get that, but what I would like to know is how these topics end up end up selected, and not something else. What were the magic combinations of factors led everyone to project onto these topics specifically. There is lasting resentment over Brexit (in the US), but nobody cared about Croatian ascension. Ukraine is a US political battleground, but the loss of Crimea was greeted with indifference. I think there must be something about the political and cultural moments that cause these issues to gain traction over other topics, or none at all.
- tivert 3y agoMaybe it's headline-grabbing drama? > There is lasting resentment over Brexit (in the US), but nobody cared about Croatian ascension. One factor (of many) is language: I'd imagine any domestic happening in an English-speaking country will loom much larger in the minds of of Americans than anything happening in a non-English-speaking one. I'd also image that leads to a lot more convergence. So a US Democrat would in fact have more alignment with a UK Labor party supporter that a lot of other foreign factions. > Ukraine is a US political battleground, but the loss of Crimea was greeted with indifference. I recall Russia's 2014 actions in Ukraine as being confusing (little green men) and being accepted with a whimper. Russia's 2022 actions had high drama: unprovoked invasion, columns of tanks, videos of fighting, big losses followed by big gains, etc. But to your point about "political and cultural moments," that's definitely at play too. The Russian attempts at election interference and the Trump presidency made Russia into an enemy in the minds of liberals, and sometimes I feel like they feel the Ukraine war is almost a front in the anti-Trump "resistance." One other interesting example is Falun Gong. Before Trump, my impression was that Americans were generally sympathetic. But once Trump started taking a more antagonistic stance against China, and Falun Gong then aligned with him because of that, I noticed Liberals echoing CCP talking points about Falun Gong pretty frequently.