3 ms·
tokamak researchers generally do not agree with you the humans only achieved breakeven in 02022, and not in a tokamak, but in an inertial confinement experimen
by kragen 3y ago
tokamak researchers generally do not agree with you
the humans only achieved breakeven in 02022, and not in a tokamak, but in an inertial confinement experiment, which is to say, a tiny bomb. thinking you need a trillion dollars is a symptom of not knowing how to do it; the trillion dollars are to spend on experiments
- Retric 3y agoActually that trillion dollar number was from a Tokamak researcher. Though I am not sure how serious they where being when using it. With Tokamak's Q isn't a constant for a general design it's a result of scaling laws and a specific size thus ITER was chosen at Q >= 10 but they could have picked bigger or smaller target. EX: https://nucleus.iaea.org/sites/fusionportal/Shared%20Documents/FEC%202016/fec2016-preprints/preprint0759.pdf https://nucleus.iaea.org/sites/fusionportal/Shared%20Documen... In 1997 JET hit an equivalent Q of 0.67 using a 3m by 1.25m device and D-T. You can look at costs and scaling factors along with the output of DD vs DT fusion. I took a trillion dollar budget just mean ~10,000x the cost of JET which seems to line up reasonably well. Though making such a large jump in scale would have it's own challenges.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt's also always been possible to reach breakeven (and above) in magnetic mirrors. These are linear devices that leak out the ends, so just make them long enough and they will reach breakeven. The problem has been "long enough" has been "kilometers".