20 ms·
Automakers are sharing consumers' driving behavior with insurance companies
- fn-mote 3y ago> In recent years, automakers [...] have started offering optional features in their connected-car apps that rate people’s driving. At least the programs are (currently) opt-in. This amusing anecdote is buried: > One driver lamented having data collected during a “track day,” while testing out the Corvette’s limits on a professional racetrack. > [...] he was denied auto insurance by seven companies [...]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xattt 3y agoBut are they really optional? I can’t imagine that the telematics link is going unused for the value it provides (i.e. crowd-sourcing for speed and road map data). The worst part is that assumptions about who’s driving the vehicle.
- cg505 3y agoYour quote is misleading. The "he" is in the next paragraph and refers to someone else who owns a Cadillac, not a Corvette. The track day thing probably was the funniest thing in the article, though.
- themaninthedark 3y agoThere is another commenter further up that says they had to opt out on a Toyota and the rep acted like he didn't know until the opt out text was read verbatim. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39667268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39667268
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoI just purchased a Camry Hybrid from a Toyota dealership. The operator tried to tell me that "because I financed it they cannot turn off analytics." I had not financing, paid cash. Pressing the SOS button to cancel [as sticker suggested] was met with so much difficulty that (while the operator was on the line still) I found the fuse panel and pulled out `DCS` to disconnect the call/tracking. This ended our trasmission.
- jrochkind1 3y agoI would be willing to bet even if you told the insurance companies it was totally legal on a professional race track -- they'd say "Nope, we still don't want to insure someone that takes his car on professional race tracks like that."
- wolverine876 3y ago> At least the programs are (currently) opt-in. The article makes clear that most people don't know what's happening with their data. They opt into something else and this data collection is included - that doesn't sound like much of an 'option'.
- themaninthedark 3y agoAll the companies were have bee hoovering up our data, where did you think this was going to end? Add in the fact that if you are not getting "growth" on the stock market, then you must be doing something wrong.
- bell-cot 3y agoThe Stasi didn't add anything to the GDP of the GDR, either. That wasn't the point then, and it isn't now.
- themaninthedark 3y agoMy point is that companies start to collect data; either for debug purposes or to try and better understand the customer. Then there is a lot of pressure to monetize the data. So from a consumer POV, it is better to not have anything collected.
- bell-cot 3y agoYes. My quip was to make a rather negative comparison, while noting that the whole collect-and-monetize industry is a net negative for both the economy and human society.
- jprete 3y agoThe US doesn't just need laws about disclosure of these practices. It needs to mandate that this kind of corporate surveillance must be a clearly labeled opt-in and cannot be mandated by any contract.
- RachelM71948937 3y ago[dead]
- bloomingeek 3y agoYes, but to me there's another important issue, with all the tracking tech in our vehicles, who actually owns them? We need to treat this similar to the "right to repair" issue! I paid my money, so I own the product. [IF] I own the vehicle it should be my right to say what software runs in the background. Of course the company can say, "If you don't like our product, don't buy it." If I want to keep up with the latest safety upgrades to my vehicle to protect myself and all car companies have the same tracking software, my only option is to look for a "dumb" vehicle. This is blatantly unsafe and irresponsible. So, they're saying that my safety comes with a price other than the $40K I shelled out?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> who actually owns them? We need to treat this similar to the "right to repair" issue Ownership is a bad framework for this issue—it’s too ambiguous. You can “own” a vehicle all you want, that doesn’t give you the right to fuck with its odometer or catalytic converter.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoBut.. it really does. As most states don't require annual inspection, you are free to smash up your odometer and sell your cat to the scrapyard. It hurts the resale value, but it's not illegal to do this at all.
- ixwt 3y agoI disagree. You can mess with odometer as much as you like. Trying to sell it off with a different amount of miles than have actually been put on it is called fraud. You should own your car and be able to do as you wish. You should also be able to turn on or off any tracking. There are just consequences for some of the things you might want to do.
- oliv__ 3y agoIt's pretty clear we've reached the point where technology has shifted to working against us, and not for us anymore. I work in tech but as far as I am concerned, you can keep all your smart homes, cars and other gadgets and soul sucking (anti) "social" apps. Somewhere along the way technology was hijacked to control us rather than empower us. And if you don't like it: shut up because "progress" is inevitable
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> we've reached the point where technology has shifted to working against us Everyone has always said this since the dawn of farming. It’s not a particularly useful insight: the question is in how and how it is to be banned or balanced.
- oliv__ 3y agoSo you think today's technology is comparable to farming?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> you think today's technology is comparable to farming? That’s a not what “since” means. If a technology causes social change, it will create winners and losers. Those winners tend to autocorrelate (inversely to the magnitude of the shift). As a result, small technological revolutions tend to result in a shift against the broader “us” while broader ones disempower an elite that tries to gain sympathy by aligning itself with that broader “us”. If it doesn’t do either of those, it is—almost by definition—not a technological shift that resulted in social change. As a result, complaining about technology working against a nebulous “us” is basically saying we had technology that caused social change. Which isn’t a novel point.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoTechnology is amoral. The power shift happened because we are no longer in control. It's these corporations who are the masters of the computers now. They're just allowing us to use their computers. Of course those computers work against us, they are treacherous by definition.
- barrkel 3y ago> An employee familiar with G.M.’s Smart Driver said the company’s annual revenue from the program is in the low millions of dollars. It doesn't seem in the car company's interests to take on the reputational risk for this kind of financial reward.
- rightbyte 3y agoShort term profit long term losses things are done a lot. Also, companies seem to work against their own interests quite often. The spyware is probably on some separate budget with separate bonuses attached. So "locally" in the department it might make financial sense to spy on the users.
- mschuster91 3y ago> It doesn't seem in the car company's interests to take on the reputational risk for this kind of financial reward. Tell that to Boeing, they're on course to tank the entire company out of the financial shenanigans they pulled after 1997. As soon as a company goes publicly traded, the incentives change - there is no more priority on long term, the only thing that matters is INVESTORS INVESTORS INVESTORS (read that one in your finest Steve Ballmer voice).
- astura 3y agoWhat sort of "reputational risk" do you think they are taking on? Data sharing with third parties is ubiquitous in almost all industries. Every single company that deals with financial products reports account information to third parties (Experian, Equifax, TransUnion, Early Warning Services, ChexSystems). If you return an item at a retail store it gets reported to fraud alert databases. Most medium to large employers report the contents of the paychecks of their employees to The Work Number. Insurance claims are reported to LexisNexis. Oil change companies report milage to CarFax, which insurance companies use to look up if you're reporting accurate mileage. Data reporting and sharing is ubiquitous; it's standard operating procedure. Having a few "privacy nerds" complain about it on the Internet is not risking their reputation.
- rootusrootus 3y ago
- sandspar 3y agoHear hear! And why not? Fuck the consumer I say! The one thing we can all agree on is that human dignity must be paid for in cash. If normal people wanted to be treated with respect then they would be high earners like us.
- max_ 3y agoThe problem with such issues of data misuse is that people only provide 2 solutions. a) Go off grid. Don't use The tech that these cars make. The problem with this is that it is impractical for people that use see alot of value in using this tech. b) Pass more regulation. I am a Hayekian and I believe that regulation will not help with people that know the ins & outs of the regulation, also it's doesn't stop them. It just means corporations are willing to misbehave as long as they can play the legal gymnastics and pay rudimentary fines. Now, The third option which I see would be the best but isn't talked much about is the promotion, and installation of homomorphic computing or homomorphic encryption. I am not a cryptographer so I really don't fully understand it's limitations. But adopting this would simply make all these data abuse issues vanish. Cryptographers, why hasn't homomophic Computing or homomophic encryption been massively adopted?
- Eisenstein 3y agoDo companies ignore regulations? Sure, some do. But saying 'they will just pay the fines' ignores the fact that we could make the fines existential, or punish board members by kicking them out of the industry. The answer to 'the regulation we haven't even tried won't work if we do it improperly' is 'let's do it, and do it properly'. I have no idea what homomorphic encryption is, but rarely do 'let's add more tech to magic bullet a human problem of incentives' solutions work.
- floating-io 3y agoStrangely enough, I know the answer to that, if memory is serving. Homomorphic encryption is where you can compute on the encrypted data without ever decrypting it. Logically, it sounds like a pipe dream to me, but apparently it's a thing.
- max_ 3y agoWhy is it a pipe dream I know companies that use it. And it serves their purposes well.
- 3y ago
- xnx 3y agoAs a safe driver, I like the idea of dangerous drivers paying more. There's no good reason the participants should not be aware they are under surveillance though. Sidenote: I wonder if they've considered close follow distance or frequent lane changes as a risk factor.
- idiotsecant 3y agoIts telling how you phrase this.
- mycologos 3y agoIf it's so telling then tell us, enough with the dark innuendos!
- RandomBacon 3y agoAppearing "safe" via slow speeds and slow turns does not equal "safe" in the real world. Unless the car has cameras staring at you, it doesn't know if you're checking your mirrors before lane-changes, going 10-under the limit in the far left lane on a busy highway, etc. Even then, cameras aren't good because assuming people are telling the truth when they use test-taking software, there are false positives that have to be manually-reviewed by proctors when the computer thinks you're looking in the wrong place. (Edit: it also doesn't know if your mirrors are positioned properly so you do not have a "blindspot". In every modern vehicle I've driven, it is possible to set the mirrors so you can continuously see cars in the left or right lane next you - from the rearview mirror to the sideview mirror to the side glass. Hint, if you can see the side of your own vehicle in your sideview mirror: it is set improperly.) --- > frequent lane changes as a risk factor. People not willing to change lanes is how you get more traffic and more dangerous driving overall. Traffic should stay right unless passing - which means once someone is done passing, they also need to move to the right. People crusing in the left lane is how backups happen and people trying to make more dangerous lane-changes to pass on the right. Less lane changes would be a bad thing to incentivise. If more people used cruise control in general, that might help (don't know if any studies have been done about that). As it is now, most people's speeds ebb and flow and that causes traffic, especially when they either consciously or subconscious try to speed up to match someone trying to pass them, or whether it's curves, hills, narrower lanes due to automated tollbooths, bridges, etc.
- batch12 3y agoWhen I got my last car, it had a sticker instructing me to press the SOS button to opt out of data collection. The gentleman that answered acted confused when I made the request, taking the stance that he wasn't aware of data collection from the car and maybe I should contact the manufacturer. It was only after I read him the sticker text verbatim that he went into a scripted response and confirmed the opt out. Shady.
- VHRanger 3y agoBrand?
- batch12 3y agoToyota. I still had the sticker- I peeled it off and put it in the manual. The exact text is: VEHICLE DATA TRANSMISSION IS ON! Your vehicle wirelessly transmits location, driving and vehicle health data to deliver your services and for internal research and data analysis. See www.toyota[.]com/privacyvts. To disable, press vehicle's SOS button.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoPrepare to be creeped out: https://www.toyota.com/privacyvts/ https://www.toyota.com/privacyvts/
- janice1999 3y agoPeople seem to unaware of it: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/feb/08/toyota-cars-collecting-and-potentially-sharing-location-data-and-personal-information-choice-says https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/feb/08/toyot...
- HankB99 3y agoYeah, right at the top > We may modify this Privacy Notice by posting a new version at this website effective on the date of publication. No actual notification needed. Are they screaming to be regulated?
- jgalt212 3y agoI hope so. Get the animals off the road.
- 654wak654 3y agoImagine a scenario where bunch of those animals brake check you, and then your insurance company calls you up and says "Hey jgalt212, we're seeing that you your forward collion avoidance system got activated too many times this year. We're going to flag you as a tailgater and up your premium by %80. Have a lovely day."
- jgalt212 3y agoAs opposed to the jackass whose pulling high lateral G's and going 90 on the freeway. I think I can explain my way out of the insurance hike easier than the aforementioned jackass--who actually should be deemed uninsurable.
- rootusrootus 3y agoPlaying devil's advocate, the answer is that brake checking only works if you are tailgating. If you increase following distance such that you cannot be brake checked, the insurance company has succeeded in making your driving habits safer.
- throw_a_grenade 3y agohttps://archive.is/lmMp9 https://archive.is/lmMp9
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mycologos 3y agoI think there are a few reasons to be mad about this, but some are better than others: 1) People don't understand they're being monitored. I think this is a good reason to be mad. People should have some understanding of the agreements they make. It's part of being a functional adult in the world. It's also annoying that the companies keep spinning this as a tool to improve your driving, when it's clearly an attempt to price insurance against a person's actual driving habits. 2) The system's assessments are opaque. I don't have a good sense of how accurate any of these measurements are, nor what system is in place to ensure that. If the information collected is consequential enough to double a person's insurance costs, there should be some effort expended to be confident that the collected metrics actually reflect reality. I didn't see anything like that in the article, maybe I missed it, but it shouldn't just be some random team in a private company doing their best. 3) People's driving habits shouldn't be shared with insurance companies. This one ... this one I think is not great. It looks like the shared data at least tries to be anonymous -- they share driving behavior and times, but not actual location data. Heck, I'd be fine with scrubbing the times and just sharing the hard start and stop and speeding numbers (assuming point 2 above is addressed). I get that a knee-jerk defensiveness about privacy would make Thomas Jefferson proud or whatever, but we strike balances on public welfare and private freedom all the time. If you're itching to manufacture 1 gram of ricin to put in a sealed glass vial above your mantle, too bad, you can't. Cars aren't ricin, but they are the shortest path between most humans and homicide. If this kind of intervention induces people to be more careful to keep their current insurance rates, I think that's reasonable. Driving like a maniac is not a human right or a protected characteristic.
- everforward 3y agoLocation can be relevant. There is both a quarter mile drag strip by me and a circuit lap by me that both allow you to drive your own car on them. Both styles of driving would be... Alarming from a telemetry perspective. Afaik neither is covered by regular auto insurance anyways so it really shouldn't factor into rates. There's specific racing insurance, but it's quite pricey. Not that I want them sharing location data, but pure acceleration/velocity data won't show areas like that. I'm also not sure how well regionalized the data is. Though neither is good, there's a very big difference between going 15 over on the highway and going 15 over on back country roads with blind turns. Or between going 15 over on the highway vs in a shopping center parking lot. Speeding is contextual.
- moooo99 3y agoI‘m a huge fan of s telemetry insurance. I have I personally and it saves me around 300€/year on my cars insurance because I am a very defensive driver. However, this being integrated into the vehicle in an absolutely intransparent way is a huge step up and a really unsettling privacy violation. For this to be ethically viable imho, there need to be a few prerequisites - it’s transparent what has been transmitted - you can always easily opt out, but you may loose the discount you earned - your driving can’t make your premium go up beyond the base premium without the discount (sensors will never paint an entirely accurate picture)
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIn which country is that?
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agoThey're describing what should be, not what is.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoNo, I was asking about this statement which I assume wasn't hypothetical: > I have I personally and it saves me around 300€/year on my cars insurance because I am a very defensive driver.
- PH95VuimJjqBqy 3y agogotcha, I misunderstood.
- QVVRP4nYz 3y agoI don't know about OP but in Poland https://yanosik.pl/ https://yanosik.pl/ offered such deals ( https://payhowyudrive.pl/ https://payhowyudrive.pl/ ). It is probably a bit self defeating - the app's main function is warning about speed traps, that means unsafe drivers as significant part of its users.
- explorigin 3y agoSurely these cars have an "offline-mode". Anyone know how to force it? (I almost said "airplane-mode".)
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> almost said "airplane-mode" My old Jetta’s door once fell off.
- MarioMan 3y agoDisconnect the antenna or the whole modem itself.
- mancerayder 3y agoMy insurance went up 10 percent out of the blue. Wonder if Tesla shares?
- 654wak654 3y agoCould've just been "inflation" (read: Opportunity to jack up prices) too. Although if one car company is going to be on the bleeding edge of data collection & sharing it'd probably be Tesla. They're the most Silicon Valley of all.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoHow do you know labor prices to fix cars and more complicated/costly car parts did not cause the increase?
- rootusrootus 3y ago10% is below average, you should feel lucky. Car insurance premiums have been rising dramatically, especially for EVs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- techdmn 3y agoMy biggest concern is that rather than comparing difficult to identify behavior against claim rates, they will penalize behavior that is easy to identify. For example, yesterday I was traveling 15 MPH over the speed limit on a multi-line highway where traffic is often traveling 10+ MPH over the limit (the limit is objectively wrong for a divided, grade separated, access controlled highway). I typically drive as far right as I can to make room for faster vehicles, but eventually got stuck behind someone camping in the left lane. When opportunity presented itself I went around them in the center lane. They expressed anger at this by encroaching into my lane to squeeze me against traffic in the right lane. There were four inches between their vehicle and my side mirror. Who is driving dangerously, and more likely to cause an accident? I would argue it's the driver who is obstructing traffic and behaving aggressively toward others on the road. But if GPS isn't accurate enough to show their lane deviation, it's a lot easier to ding me for my speed.
- 654wak654 3y agoMaking it easier to determine who's at fault in cases like you mentioned would involve more sensors, radars, cameras etc. So we either 1984-ify everyones car or we just don't do any monitoring at all (since half-assing it can lead to false positives). I have a feeling insurance companies (and therefore governments) will slide more towards the 1984 side to save a couple dollars.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoInsurance companies don’t have to, people are voluntarily installing dash cams to show who was at fault (or at least show they were not). Chances are, someone is recording your collision, and you might as well have your evidence to fight against someone else’s.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoMore concerning is how we are not able to view and challenge this data. It's a one-way street.
- fabiofzero 3y agoSome insurance companies make you use an app if you want lower payments so this battle is mostly lost.
- elevenones 3y ago(From the Toyota Connected Services Disclaimer) Your Responsibilities Your responsibilities include: (1) informing passengers and drivers of your vehicle that data is collected and used by us, and (2) notifying us of a sale or transfer of your vehicle. If you do not notify us of a sale or transfer, we may continue to send data about the vehicle to the subscriber's Account Information currently on file, and we are not responsible for any privacy related damages you suffer.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoThis needs to be illegal.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoSenator Wyden has been a champion of data privacy. If you are an Oregon resident, please reach out to his office. https://www.wyden.senate.gov/ https://www.wyden.senate.gov/
- m463 3y agoI remember driving a nissan leaf. You had an opt-out prompt every time you drove the car.
- rkagerer 3y agoThis is why I like paper contracts. I would simply cross out a stupid clause like this before signing. 99% of the time the rep doesn't care, and if the company can't be bothered to put someone on the other side of the table who is actually paying attention or has bargaining power then they deserve it.
- prometheus76 3y agoI called to turn off the data in a Toyota, and the guy wanted my name, phone number, email address, physical address and even more I can't remember right now. I was like "why do you need this info?" He said, "We need a record of who made this request for our records." I told him "do you understand that I am calling your company specifically because I don't want you to have records?" This went round and round about three times before I just gave him fake info.
- MrDrMcCoy 3y agoWere you able to obtain any records of your own where they agree to cease collection that you can hold against them if they continue? Do you have any means of verifying that the collection has ceased? I don't believe that their word means much without these.
- prometheus76 3y agoI just wrapped my truck with several layers of copper mesh, so it should be fine. In all seriousness though, no. I have no way of confirming the data transmission has stopped.
- kkfx 3y agoLadies and gentleman if we want a fair society we MUST: - mandate FLOSS by law, starting from the first SLoC, meaning no company can sudden publish software to sell something with it, the software must be published since the day zero of it's development or the hw/sw/service can't be on sale; - mandate local first for anything, so connected cars are ok, but they just offer a simple DynDNS mechanism the owner can add to it's own domain name as a subdomain like car.mydomain.tld and reach a relevant set of APIs the car offer. All data collected by the OEM must pass though the car owners systems, in an open and readable and documented form. If this is not mandate, by popular acclaim, surveillance capitalism will stay, since it's the new tool to know and conform the masses. Surveilled people are known, and knowing they are surveilled try to behave in a "social norm" way, fearing the judgment/social score, as a result people evolve toward slaves who obey those who establish and update current social norms. We all know cooperation is needed to do anything, those who compete then need many who cooperate, obeying their orders, to craft anything. In the past was religion, then money, now social scoring the way to stiffen the masses. Such powerful tool is not something anyone accept to loose without a desperate and limitless fight. Only a large public reaction can force a change.
- ljosa 3y agoIs there a good source for which makes, models, and model years “phone home”? I would absolutely take it into account when shopping for a new or used car, but I’ve had no luck with Googling.
- cebert 3y agoI’d imagine any car since 2019 can likely share such data.
- leotravis10 3y agoGift Link: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/11/technology/carmakers-driver-tracking-insurance.html?unlocked_article_code=1.b00.lsua.hw-GuRYlzIeE https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/11/technology/carmakers-driv... US lawmakers can put a stop to this and every other privacy scandal over the years at any time you know by passing a strong privacy law but nahhhhhh we can't do that! It's yet another reason why people should buy older cars (preferably 2012 or older) since the automotive, insurance, and data broker industries don't give a total jack about your privacy and sadly the US aren't going to do jack about this either until we can elect more people in office that does care and pass a strong privacy law in the process.
- jrochkind1 3y ago> An employee familiar with G.M.’s Smart Driver said the company’s annual revenue from the program is in the low millions of dollars. Is that a lot of money for GM? I would have guessed no, but it doesn't seem like very much for selling out their customers like this. Either it's more to GM's profits than I'd expect, or they really don't expect much PR blowback risk at all? I don't know if they are right or wrong, but... > Drivers who have realized what is happening are not happy. The Palm Beach Cadillac owner said he would never buy another car from G.M. He is planning to sell his Cadillac.
- morninglight 3y agoThey share your data in order to help lower your insurance rates. Imagine what your premium might be without this service. For example, I drive less than 900 miles a year, have had no accidents, citations or thefts and keep my 10 year old car in a garage. Yet my payments are $1500 per year. And after getting estimates from several companies, this was the lowest we could find. Even with this service, the inflation rate for auto insurance is higher than anything else in our family budget. Thank the lord for data sharing.
- NN88 3y agoI mean, I knew…but… I didn’t know...
- theogravity 3y agoAfter seeing this article, I did a bit of searching and you can also get your LexisNexus report and also opt-out of data sharing along with deleting associated data. I did it and recommend everyone else does as well. https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/consumer https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/consumer
- ajcp 3y agoThat link only allows you to request the LexisNexis Risk report on you. Do you have a link where one can opt-out of data sharing or deleting associated data? I cannot find anything on the LexisNexis site allowing for that.
- theogravity 3y agoIt turns out only certain states allows for deleting like California
- HnUser12 3y agoFor anyone looking https://www.lexisnexis.com/global/privacy/en/privacy-center-ca.page https://www.lexisnexis.com/global/privacy/en/privacy-center-... This looks like the Canadian page, made a request and let’s see where this leads to.
- nonstopnonsense 3y agoHello there - This form is from a different business of LexisNexis. Not pertaining to their Risk business. This form will not get what you want.
- alexjplant 3y agoAll new manufacture cars sold in the US already have "black box" data recorders that can be dumped in the event of an accident. In many cases this can even be done without a warrant as of a decade ago [1] - not sure whether that's changed. In any event it seems as though this is a natural evolution in concert with those voluntary ODB-II devices that insurers started using to record driving habits. [1] https://www.edmunds.com/car-technology/car-black-box-recorders-capture-crash-data.html https://www.edmunds.com/car-technology/car-black-box-recorde...
- alwaysrunning 3y agoThere needs to be a Pi-hole for cars.
- navigate8310 3y agoGrapheneOS for Automotive
- unethical_ban 3y agoCan this be opted out at the dealer? Black box collection OR wireless connectivity? If not, are there guides on disabling the modem without damaging diagnostics or infotainment? I want a car that does not transmit data. Which means I may need to get my 2010s crossover rebuilt and reupholstered instead of getting a new car.
- giantg2 3y agoYes, many models have guides out there for disabling wireless connections. On a previous vehicle of mine, it was as simple as disconnecting the bridge/jumper between the main board and the wireless board.
- macNchz 3y agoI think it varies manufacturer to manufacturer, but even those that make it possible seemingly make you jump through hoops. I was researching potential replacements for my 16 year old car and found a lot of discussion about this re Mazda models: https://www.cx30talk.com/threads/thoughts-on-tcu-disable.3748/ https://www.cx30talk.com/threads/thoughts-on-tcu-disable.374... > Mazda CEC makes it quite difficult to actually request/disable your TCU. It can take many phone calls and escalations to get someout to understand the request and actually "push the button" to send the disable event to your car. Honestly I’m just totally disinterested in just about every current new car model.
- ytx 3y ago> "More specifically, automakers are selling access to the data to Lexis Nexis, which is then crafting “risk scores” insurance companies then use to adjust rates. Usually upward" In an ideal world, such data-harvesting might lead to cheaper prices / a more efficient insurance market - which would make the privacy loss worth considering from a trade-off standpoint, at least in theory. Unfortunately it's instead likely to just lead to higher margins for insurance companies. And the only way to compete would be to harvest more data for better predictions.
- elzbardico 3y agoBasically they keep the profits and socialize the risks.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> Unfortunately it's instead likely to just lead to higher margins for insurance companies. Why? Insurance pricing is heavily regulated, and profit margins for insurers have always been very low.
- thfuran 3y agoIn an ideal world, such data harvesting would be illegal, with liability adhering to the executives pushing for and approving the initiative as well as any legal counsel involved. Acquiring the data should require explicit, truly informed, and revocable consent not buried in a bunch of BS and not required for the purchase of a vehicle or insurance.
- ytx 3y agoI wholeheartedly agree that the dark patterns around consent are atrocious. But I also think hn is probably biased in its valuation of an individual's data. If companies offered say a $50/month discount on car insurance premiums in exchange for gathering data, I imagine a large proportion of people would indeed opt in to that (setting aside issues of selection bias or trust in this ideal world)
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nhance 3y agoI have been convinced for several years now that insurance companies are likely buying up personal data from many different sources. They seem to be ideal consumers because it'll lead to better outcomes when they can increase rates on those that identify as risky.
- ldayley 3y agoThis has been true for several years. An insurance agent once told me that there are life insurance companies dropping the requirement for blood draws / medical exams and are just buying prescription records to correlate with financial, educational, and other behavioral data. Edit: changed prescription “data” to “records”
- dml2135 3y agoWouldn’t this violate HIPAA?
- warkdarrior 3y agoDepends who is selling that data. Some pharmacy delivery services or billing services may not be covered by HIPAA, since they are not necessarily "covered entities".
- ethbr1 3y agoIs this true? My understanding of HIPAA (possibly incorrect) is that it's attached to the data. If a covered provider is leaking HIPAA covered data to a non-covered business associate entity... that's a big no-no and a fine.
- snowwrestler 3y agoThere are criteria for which organizations are covered by HIPAA’s privacy protections. It is not attached to the data wherever the data goes.
- ozymandium 3y agoThe easiest way to disable this is by physically removing the cell modem from your vehicle, which is very straightforward. Without egress, the only way for data harvesting to occur is by physical access, typically at a dealership. However, virtually all automotive cell modems are either packaged on the same chip as the GNSS receiver, or colocated on the same daughter board. As such, choosing to retain control over your data typically comes at the cost of foregoing the built in navigation system and other features such as emergency calling.
- elzbardico 3y agoUnless most people do it, their answer will be to put you on the high risk bucket by default.
- chongli 3y agoThere are insurance companies that allow you to voluntarily submit to tracking in exchange for reduced premiums. What is happening here is that those savings are being passed on to auto makers as an extra revenue stream.
- rubatuga 3y agoThe easiest way to disable this in a Chevrolet with OnStar is to pull the fuse (Fuse 38 under the dash for the Chevrolet Malibu 2024). Other options disconnecting the antenna (can still connect if strong signal), or pulling out the box/microphone (disassembly required). At least for the 2024 model CarPlay features seems to keep working, but I haven't tested Bluetooth yet. There's somebody on YouTube describing the parts of the OnStar feature: https://youtu.be/TZILodhvjdw?feature=shared https://youtu.be/TZILodhvjdw?feature=shared
- foobarian 3y ago> (can still connect if strong signal) Wonder if that would still work if you additionally shunted the antenna with some kind of impedance matched load.
- thereddaikon 3y agoAll the Hams scramble to grab a spare dummy load.
- giantg2 3y agoMany GM models used to have a bridge/jumper between the network daughter board and the rest of the car. Pretty easy and didn't affect anything else (sometimes the fuse for OnStar also covered your Bluetooth or voice commands).
- f3d46600-b66e 3y agoI read that microphone in Bluetooth stops working (on Chevy bolt)
- Mistletoe 3y agoIs there any hope for something like a Privacy Bill of Rights to ever be passed? I feel like privacy is an inalienable right for all humans and the passage of something like this would be a light speed jump ahead for personal freedom in the new era we find ourselves in. Just because tech enables it doesn’t make this any creepier than someone following behind you in the woods stalking you on your horse 200 years ago.
- jeffbee 3y ago[flagged]
- AlexandrB 3y agoMany things people do are extremely dangerous and detrimental to society. Not sure that's a great rationale for stripping someone of their privacy. > You even sign away your rights to the privacy of your own blood when you get a license to drive. I'm not sure what this is referring to. Is any random government agent allowed to take a DNA sample if you're behind the wheel of a car?
- jeffbee 3y agoYeah, pretty much. It is called "implied consent".
- BitwiseFool 3y agoI assume that person is talking about blood tests for suspected DUI's. >"All U.S. states have driver licensing laws which state that a licensed driver has given their implied consent to a certified breathalyzer or by a blood sample by their choice, or similar manner of determining blood alcohol concentration." -https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied_consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Implied_consent
- rurp 3y agoLike it or not most of the US is oriented around driving and it's basically unavoidable for most adults. Using that as justification to erode everyone's rights feels deeply wrong to me.
- jrochkind1 3y agoTopic is previously discussed (163 comments, 2 days ago) off NYT article at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39666976 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39666976
- mperham 3y agoAnyone know where I can find /etc/hosts on my Ford? /s
- mh- 3y agoBehind the firewall.
- nemo44x 3y agoThere's a lot of jerk drivers who go way too fast and drive very dangerously. They should have to pay significantly more for it. For people that drive correctly, they should be charged less as well. I don't see why this is an issue.
- loeg 3y agoThe cars are not capable of measuring how dangerous the driving is.
- nemo44x 3y agoSure they are. Speed is easy to detect for instance. Someone driving 50mpg in a 25mph school zone should have massive increases to their insurance as they present huge risk.
- thfuran 3y agoShould the fine be the same regardless of whether it's five minutes after school let out out or 3AM on Christmas day?
- nemo44x 3y agoIt would be up to the insurer and how their models reflect and manage risk. The point being, individual insurers would be able to better price insurance based on discrete customer behavior.
- thfuran 3y agoShould cell providers sell customer data/metadata to car insurance providers? It, after all, in the best interest of the insurers.
- nemo44x 3y agoIf there's enough data to suggest that with a high degree of probability people using their cell phones in certain ways while operating a vehicle causes damages then yeah, there should be a market for that. I'm not saying there shouldn't be legislation that limits which types of data can be shared, but certainly if there's useful information that has a market that leads to better safety and lower insurance prices, then I'm all for it.
- itsoktocry 3y agoI mean, Tesla has their own insurance product that they claim is better and cheaper than alternatives because of the data they track. People cheered for this. Personally, I"m not opposed to dangerous drivers paying higher rates, but the devil is in the details.
- toss1 3y agoThe worst thing about this is that all of their conclusions about what data constitutes "bad driving" or "risky driving" is dead wrong. The signs they consider to be "bad driving" are high-g braking and turning. Yet these are EXACTLY the same signs created by highly-skilled driver or racer operating at the limit, as they would to avoid an accident (thus costing the insurer $0), where the same situation would catch 90% of the low-g drivers into a wreck that totals the vehicle and causes injuries. A core element of high-performance driving for accident avoidance and racing is to understand the limits of tyre traction, and how to operate the car up to those limits — but not over them — i.e., just under the limit of sliding (sliding friction is always less than static or rolling friction), and to choose lines that maximize available traction. Distinguishing the signs to tell a high-skilled driver from a bad driver requires more than just "is that number high?". You must look at the circumstances, the frequency, the conditions, the rate of increase and decrease of pressure, the slip angle, the grip state of all 4 tires, and more. But of course, no one bothers to do this. It is the same kind of institutional stupidity that causes a world-class weightlifter with 4% body fat to be classed as "obese" because s/he scores high on the stupidly simplistic BMI scale(a ratio of weight to height). Except with BMI insurance companies are not allowed to re-rate people and doctors can instantly adjust treatment when they see the person is obviously not obese but highly trained. With auto insurance, they can secretly re-rate us on bogus numbers that actually down-rate the highly skilled. Seems more attractive with every passing year to rebuild older nice cars than get into the new rolling spyware contraptions.
- rnk 3y agoI'm skeptical of this argument. I don't want to be on the same road with people who self identity as expert drivers going at the limit.
- toss1 3y agoI completely agree. My example is NOT about "self identified" "experts", but REAL experts who ACTUALLY have the skills. They also are typically very safe on the roads and know that race-like on-the-limit driving on the streets is idiocy. The point is that people who ACTUALLY have these skills have a far wider margin of safety than the ordinary driver, and far better capability to avoid accidents. But, they will also — with that far wider margin of safety — often turn or brake with higher than ordinary G-forces. For example, ordinary street tires and suspensions on modern cars can handle 0.9G lateral or braking acceleration. Ordinary people get uncomfortable at 0.2G lateral acceleration. An unskilled driver approaching 0.25G lateral acceleration does risk exceeding adhesion limits and losing control because they are insensitive to inputs and feedback. In contrast, a skilled driver can turn at 0.25G all day with virtually no risk, as they are accustomed to driving at 3-4 times those Gs, and are situationally aware, sensitive to inputs and feedback, and choose lines and inputs that avoid the limit. They are far less of a risk than an unskilled driver at 0.1G. Yet, the skilled driver will get flagged as "bad". With deeper understanding and analysis, they could make the distinction between actual expert drivers vs overconfident idiots. But I see no indication that this will happen.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] Some more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39666976 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39666976
- g9yuayon 3y agoCan someone educate me why insurer should not know one's driving habits? I'd imagine that the risks calculated from one's driving habit will be more accurate than that derived from only past accidents, car color, user profile and etc.
- JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B 3y agoFor me it’s because of this dirty concept called "privacy" and it’s the reason why insurers don’t have access to the list of items that I buy at the grocery store (also health records, name of sex partners, what I do all day long, whether I walk enough every day, etc.)
- achristmascarl 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240313200717/https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/11/technology/carmakers-driver-tracking-insurance.html https://web.archive.org/web/20240313200717/https://www.nytim...
- theogravity 3y agoYou can get your data from LexusNexus or opt out and delete data if you're in a state that mandates the option (such as CA) here: https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/consumer https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/consumer
- nijave 3y agoWhen I worked in car insurance, besides our own telemetry, we got at least - Willis Towers Watson (WTW) aggregated driving data - Verisk (afaik this was mostly around vehicles, not people) - Various reports directly from state governments - LexisNexus (multiple different report types) Really any mobile app that has accelerometer or gyroscope access (even without GPS) can estimate driving safety. Using phone movement and angle, you can estimate driver vs passenger. Cambridge Mobile sells equipment a lot of insurers use and afaik also data The magic keyword to look for is "telematics"
- bluishgreen 3y agoGives the creepy vibes, but if you stop to think about it - this can stop good drivers from subsidizing the bad drivers. Not like the insurance companies are doing to lower the premium on good drivers, if you have a problem with that talk to capitalism. But bad drivers getting higher premiums is good for everyone.
- antiframe 3y ago> But bad drivers getting higher premiums is good for everyone. Not necessarily. In many parts of the United States, a car is the only viable mode of transport. If you price the bad drivers out of the insurance market, they will forgo insurance all together. Then, if they cause a loss, they will be uninsured and the other driver's insurance will have to pay for the loss (or spend resources in costly suits) anyhow. So, then good drivers premiums will need to go up to compensate for the extra "bad drivers can't afford insurance" risk that good driver's carry. We end up in a similar situation in a roundabout manner but with the added element that now all our data is stored on everyone's servers.
- rmbyrro 3y agooh f**, we invented this shit in software, now it's coming back to bite us
- jevoten 3y agoBeing mad about this is like being mad the thief who stole your belongings then pawned them. The crime was spying on you in the first place. Automakers should not have any data, to share or sell or give to law enforcement with a subpoena.
- MichaelMoser123 3y ago> An employee familiar with G.M.’s Smart Driver said the company’s annual revenue from the program is in the low millions of dollars. i would have guessed that this is making more money. Does anyone know why this is the case?
- smackeyacky 3y agoGood luck collecting that from a 1992 Mitsubishi L200
- DANmode 3y agoGot any apps?
- smackeyacky 3y agoWell, yeah, other than that :-)
- alakep 3y agoThis happens with healthcare data too. Every prescription you fill is tracked and used as input data for many insurance models that make health insurance pricing decisions.
- gentleman11 3y agoDoes anyone have a list of companies that do not do this?
- op00to 3y agoSubaru opt-out https://subarucustomersupport.powerappsportals.com/Consumer-privacy/ https://subarucustomersupport.powerappsportals.com/Consumer-...
- rkagerer 3y agoI hate how many companies don't give a flying shit about privacy and completely ignore user selections under the guise of incompetence. I would like to see a judge with sympathy for this sentiment fine them out of existence.