3 ms·
There is a bit of a problem using a "must cite our paper" clause. It's very similar to the "obnoxious" advertising clause of the original BSD license, described
by dalke 15y ago
There is a bit of a problem using a "must cite our paper" clause. It's very similar to the "obnoxious" advertising clause of the original BSD license, described at http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/bsd.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/bsd.html .
In short, it would mean that people who incorporate your software into their work must also include that citation requirement. Put enough of those together and you might end up with a dozen or more required citations - even if the only thing I copied from your code was a routine for, say, doing matrix multiplies!
Also, what constitutes a "publication"? Is it in a peer-reviewed journal only, or do non-peer reviewed publications also count? Conference papers? Blog posts? If someone does not cite the paper then is the license withdrawn for that person? For how long? Do they restore the license by downloading a new copy of the code?
I'll use the Biopython practice as an example of how another project does things. The README says "If you use Biopython in work contributing to a scientific publication, we ask that you cite our application note (below) or one of the module specific publications (listed on our website): ..."