4 ms·
Exploring Bauhaus: Revolutionary design school that shaped modern world
- throwawayyy9237 3y agoI'm no expert in design, but it's really interesting to see the signs that a design "won". That is, when you see echoes and influnces of it everywhere.
- johncoltrane 3y agoSee also, the Ulm School of Design: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulm_School_of_Design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ulm_School_of_Design
- snowpid 3y agoIt is worth to note, that more architects love the design than the average German. There is a huge district in the south of Berlin called Gropiusstadt (designed by Walter Gropius) which is so unpopular that only lower class people live there. While pre Bauhaus buildings are very popular in Germany. Bauhaus and its predecessors is more a problem than a solution.
- aeyes 3y agoI'd argue that this has nothing to do with Bauhaus because this district was planned to have 90% social housing. Of course cramping 30k+ low income workers (or unemployed people) into a small space is going to cause trouble. And if I remember correctly the original plans were changed and the buildings ended up much higher and denser to meet the goals of the city. Edit: Found this article which states that the plans were modified by Wils Ebert, Gropius had no say in this. https://www.goethe.de/ins/au/en/kul/arc/bau/21319032.html https://www.goethe.de/ins/au/en/kul/arc/bau/21319032.html
- snowpid 3y agoI still see my point standing that modern architecture is very unpopular in Germany.
- qwytw 3y agoBrutalism (which generally most/many people seem to dislike) isn't the same as Bauhaus though. > modern architecture is very unpopular in Germany IMHO it has much more to do with the constraints of the 50s and 60s. All major cities in Germany were destroyed and had to be rebuilt fast and cheap. Of course buildings from the late 19th/early 20th century might have looked a lot nicer but they were also massively more expensive (would you rather many cheap and ugly high density buildings or a few better looking expensive ones, it's not like there were that many other options).
- snowpid 3y agoMany, many, many, many of pre WWI buildings were constrained by budget and had poor inhabitants. Today they are very popular (and nobody poor can afford it anymore)
- usrusr 3y agoWhere I live it was a close call between rebuilding in modern layouts (car-friendly and that entire "block in a park landscape" approach that I consider the biggest failure of 20th century architecture, nobody likes these "parks" that are too close to buildings to feel public and too open to feel private) and rebuilding in the old layout, with houses on the edge of the street enclosing hidden backyards, roof lines closely matching pre-war roof lines. Old layout won and today everybody is very happy about that. But wherever there are old stock buildings and post war reconstruction buildings in the same street, the old ones are considered much higher standard, despite best efforts to avoid modernism in the reconstruction. From today's perspective, the actual age difference between one group and the other is laughably small. But in the rush to rebuild post war, the "good enough" threshold was so much lower than pre WWI the difference echoes on through the renovations to this day.
- lukan 3y agoBecause labour was cheap and plenty, when they were built with hand with bricks. Also some survivorship bias, as many badly build ones, did not survive the bombs so well. After WW2 it was mainly cheap concrete.
- rickdeckard 3y agoMight be controversial, but in my opinion the impact (and long-lasting aesthetic) of Bauhaus is much more visible in the industrial design of modern products than it is in architecture. After all, a consumer product can win by individual choice of the consumer, with failed attempts of interpreting Bauhaus design disappearing again, which makes it easy to cite good examples of lasting Bauhaus style over time (i.e. showing similarity of Braun products with Apple design, etc.). But a failed interpretation of Bauhaus in Architecture continues to live among us for decades, watering down the value of well-executed Bauhaus design with an appearance of being a cheap bland building...
- ethanbond 3y agoEvery Chipotle in America is part of the Bauhaus lineage. Wildly common, if not "popular."
- qwytw 3y agoGropiusstadt isn't exactly the best example of Bauhaus though. IIRC Gropius original plan was changed a lot to maximize capacity/minimize cost, the buildings were only supposed to have 5 stories or less etc. I don't think those issues have anything to do with the the specific style.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- keiferski 3y agoFor anyone that wants to read a critical take of Bauhaus and modernist architecture in general, check out the very funny From Bauhaus to Our House by Tom Wolfe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/From_Bauhaus_to_Our_House https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/From_Bauhaus_to_Our_House His other book on art was pretty good too, and both were received very poorly by their respective industries, which is probably a sign that he was on to something.
- joarv0249nw 3y agoSiemensstadt seemed pretty nice.
- usrusr 3y agoThose ambitious Weimar era housing estates in Berlin are all awesome, with their careful balance between efficiency and preventing excessive cookie-cutter. It's interesting to contrast them with their less modernist "Gemeindebau" contemporaries in Vienna, which share some ideas and contrast in many others. In my opinion the Vienna ones deserve far more attention than they get (than they get outside Vienna?). I guess their biggest hindrance to fame is that there are so many of them, and that the biggest ones that unsurprisingly draw all the attention (e.g. the match made in heaven of Karl Marx Hof and George Washington Hof) aren't quite as interesting as their entirety, in particular the continuity through Anschluss, war and the aftermath.
- lukas099 3y ago> so unpopular that only lower class people live there. Sounds like Bauhaus was better at building affordable housing than other styles.
- rickdeckard 3y agoGood article, but a weird choice to focus so much on Bauhaus architecture and so little on Bauhaus and its influence especially on industrial design (IMO a much more significant impact of Bauhaus in the modern world).
- xnx 3y agoIndeed. To my untrained eye there seems a clear line from Bauhaus to Dieter Rams to Apple (https://www.cultofmac.com/188753/the-braun-products-that-inspired-apples-iconic-designs-gallery/ https://www.cultofmac.com/188753/the-braun-products-that-ins...)
- JusticeJuice 3y agoThey had a teaching ethos that architecture was the center of design education, and that all skills, such as material practice, aesthetic graphic skills, color theory, etc., all lead towards building design. I suspect this attitude spills over into what people view as their 'best' work. https://smarthistory.org/the-bauhaus-and-bau/ https://smarthistory.org/the-bauhaus-and-bau/
- rickdeckard 3y agoAgree, but I'm not sure that explicitly Bauhaus building design actually "shapes the modern world" as stated in the title. I'd argue that only a fraction of well-designed buildings in your surrounding actually embody the Bauhaus ethos and its derived aesthetics, but possibly a majority of well-designed products around you do.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pgtan 3y agoThat article not even mention Bauhaus in Tel Aviv! https://bauhaus-center.com/bauhaus-in-tel-aviv/ https://bauhaus-center.com/bauhaus-in-tel-aviv/
- tainted_blood 3y ago[flagged]
- ffgjgf1 3y agoIt’s not ; ) (or are you mixing it up with brutalism?). IMHO it’s the best looking architectural style from the 20th century (not that there is a lot of competition besides maybe art deco) > degenerate The was another group of people in the 1930s Germany who had similar thoughts and mostly killed it.
- tainted_blood 3y ago[flagged]
- cadr 3y ago[flagged]
- trevithick 3y agoEarlier HN discussion on this topic (different article): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30270286 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30270286 I mentioned Tom Wolfe's book "From Bauhaus to Our House." I don't think he likes Bauhaus much. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41001.From_Bauhaus_to_Our_House https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41001.From_Bauhaus_to_Ou...
- rendang 3y agoAn even more extreme response to modernism is Ann Sussman's claim that it originated from trauma and mental illness: https://commonedge.org/the-mental-disorders-that-gave-us-modern-architecture/ https://commonedge.org/the-mental-disorders-that-gave-us-mod... Although I agree with her that traditional, ornamental design is more beautiful, something bothers me about her line of argument; it seems cheap and patronizing to take ideas expressed with rigor and good faith by talented people and dismiss them w/o engaging them intellectually. Nevertheless, its an interesting point of view
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AlbertCory 3y ago> it remains a symbol of a modern approach to architecture and design. As if that's a good thing. I see someone else has already referenced "From Bauhaus to Our House." The bottom line is just this: Bauhaus is ugly. It does not uplift people's spirits and it does not make us happy. The authors inadvertently give the best argument against it: > Many also believed that only dedicated craftsman, with their hands-on approach, could produce the highest quality work. They argued that machine production inevitably led to a decline in aesthetic quality. Furthermore, they contended that individuals surrounded by such unattractive surroundings lacked an appreciation for beauty.
- lukas099 3y agoI'm not an architect or anything, and I think Bauhaus looks awesome. And sure I wish we could all live in perfect craftsman houses painstakingly put together with a hammer and nails but that's not realistic.
- hammock 3y agoMy idea of a perfect house involves post-and-beam construction with no nails at all and only traditional joinery :) Although I know a guy who takes down really old buildings and regularly sees hand-wrought nails, those are cool too
- paradox460 3y agoIf you are ever fortunate enough to book a stay at the Aspen Institute or Aspen Conference Center in Colorado, you're in for a Bauhaus treat. My family used to take fairly regular trips up there; the LIGO planning meetings were held at the ACC, and so we'd typically lodge either there or in nearby Snowmass, which also is home to a large number of Bauhaus designs.
- Scene_Cast2 3y agoColorado in general has some amazing architecture, including residential architecture. I saw a lot of this style when I was there: https://kellyandstonearchitects.com/portfolio/completed-portfolio/ https://kellyandstonearchitects.com/portfolio/completed-port...
- codethief 3y agoDoes this style have a name?
- Dig1t 3y agoI often wonder how much of the design aesthetic is due to Apple. Apple turned bauhaus into the “premium” aesthetic, at least in the US. So many companies just copy their premium style from Apple with slight variations, I wonder how much of its presence in our world is simply due to everyone trying to associate themselves with the “premium”/minimalist aesthetic that Apple has cultivated.
- RamblingCTO 3y agoI think it's the other way around. Apple was heavily inspired by Braun/Dieter Rams. When I look at this work I immediately think premium. And this was long before Apple.
- hackernoteng 3y agoThe future will be shaped by Minecraft. I foresee very blocky looking buildings.
- lukas099 3y agoIf that means modular houses that people can expand and contract quickly and easily based on current needs, I'm there.
- JR1427 3y agoDid it bother anyone else that in the photo of the Wassily chair in the article, only one of the little feet is in the correct orientation? Without commenting on the overall design, the fact that this can apparently happen smacks of bad design to me, at least in the details.
- kansface 3y agoThose are removable for carpet … or maybe addable for hard floors is more accurate. Someone just put them on upside down on the front and then photoshopped out all context. See https://www.knoll.com/product/wassily-chair https://www.knoll.com/product/wassily-chair
- kjkjadksj 3y agoI think what made these good design is that they were pioneers. Consider the eames chair. Plenty of people lust after one, they are worth more than a used car. I have sat in one but there wasn’t any magic or anything. Any recliner feels the same. But that being said my perspective is from a world post eames chair. Before this chair maybe there wasn’t a comparable experience at all among what people were usually buying for chairs.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoI think the real sell with bauhaus design is that it was and is super cheap. Look at these examples in the article. Simple forms. Simple materials. Cheap and fast. Compare that with an earlier building like the empire state building and we see the exact opposite. More complex forms. More craftsmanship required to create the overall decor and trim designs, and no doubt more cost compared to a bauhaus style building one could make with some chicken wire, plaster, and cheap windows. Its kind of a shame then that the international standard today has basically been the fast and cheap bauhaus inspired 5/1 style building, in a sort of race to the bottom away from the building forms that once defined a place.
- hammock 3y agoCf. IKEA
- kjkjadksj 3y agoNot just ikea but all the cheap melamine board furniture out there today takes inspiration from the bauhaus philosophy. And also the fact melamine board is so cheap and comes finished.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's also the real problem with Bauhaus (and IKEA) - if you're going for cheap and fast, you're not going to stop at "cheap enough whilst still being durable, etc". IKEA has some wonderful furniture that is cheap and fast, but cannot survive being moved. And Bauhaus has some cheap and fast buildings, but they cannot survive being unmaintained - which is often what happens to buildings that were built to be cheapest.
- milesvp 3y agoI think it may be unfortunate to lump Ikea in with Bauhaus. While I agree with the general sentiment that Ikea tends to be single use, the idea of the flatpack was truly revolutionary. Shipping furniture used to be crazy expensive, but the idea of designing a bookcase that could take minimal space to ship and let the customer with no tools other than a screwdriver and a hammer put it together was truly a leap that I’m not sure many at the time were prepared to take.
- d--b 3y agoI don't know the field all that well, but my feeling is that Bauhaus is overrated. The architecture of the school buildings themselves is quite remarkable, but as a school, it din't really work. The professors were acclaimed artists, but the alumni aren't all that well-known and as far as I know haven't contributed enormously to the field of arts and design.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bratwurst3000 3y agoMid century design is a good example of very good bauhaus design. One of my favorites.
- silent_cal 3y agoI hate Bauhaus
- crowcroft 3y agoI find that there's often something very subtle in Bauhaus design that can make things awful very quickly. Sometimes I see 'Bauhaus' style things and I think they're incredible, but then very slight variations of that same thing immediately look ghastly to me, but I can never quite put my finger on what it is. I think there's a certain kind of purity required in the design to make sure the simple look works. I think this is also why Bauhaus design often ages terrible. Immaculate plaster walls can look nice, but the second they age, get weathered or develop a 'patina' they look awful.